Monday, March 5, 2012

Occupy Labor Law!

National Lawyers Guild NYC Chapter Labor and Employment Committee,
CUNY School of Law’s Community Legal Resource Network (CLRN) &
Labor Coalition Present:
Occupy Labor Law!
 
Labor Unions, Workers’ Centers and the Occupy Movement
 
With Distinguished Speakers:
 
Mario Dartayet-Rodriguez, Director of Organizing DC 37/OWS activist
Bennet D. Zurofsky, Practicing Labor Lawyer
James Gray Pope, Professor of Law, Rutgers University
E. Tammy Kim, Staff Attorney Urban Justice Center/OWS activist
 
Moderated by:
Daniel Gross, Executive Director, Brandworkers International
 
 
Martin Luther King Labor Center Auditorium, 1199 SEIU
310 West 43rd Street (at 8th Avenue)
Tuesday, March 27, 2012 ¨ 6:30- 8:45 pm

Doors open at 6:00 pm ¨ Food and drinks will be served at this time
For information and if interested in CLE credit: ursulalevelt@gmail.com


Tica Frazer
Admission Adviser- MA in Labor Studies
Joseph S. Murphy Institute, CUNY - SPS
Center  for Worker Education and Labor Studies

25 West 43rd St, Room 1802
New York, NY 10036

T- 212-642-2050
F- 212-827-5955
 


Joseph S. Murphy Institute, CUNY - SPS Spring 2012 Academic Calendar:
Joseph S. Murphy Institute, CUNY - SPS Spring 2012 Schedule of Classes


 

It Doesn't Suck To Get Ankled As CEO of The New York Times.


The New York Times Is Now Paying Former CEO Janet Robinson $25,000+ An Hour

By CEO and Editor-in-Chief of Business Insider.

Janet looking happy, but who wouldn't?

Former CEO Janet Robinson's exit package is now believed to be in the neighborhood of $21 million, much of which, to be fair, she earned over her two decades at the company.But $4.5 million of this package, which is being paid in cash this year, is for ongoing "consulting services."

It means that the New York Times Company is allowed to call Janet Robinson and ask her questions for up to 15 hours per month--a maximum time commitment for which Robinson will be paid $375,000 per month or $25,000 per hour.

 Of course, this wouldn't be a CEO exit deal if those payments were in any way contingent on the work Robinson performs or doesn't perform. 

She'll get the money each month--all of it--whether the New York Times ever calls her or not. 

And at the end of the year, when all those monthly consulting payments are added up, they'll total $4.5 million. 

Anyone else want to be the former CEO of the New York Times?

 For more Information go to: http://saveourtimes.com/

NYT Union Poster Features Janet Robinson and Her Golden Parachute



Check out the Guild’s pension calculator

 For more Information go to: http://saveourtimes.com/

New York Times' Former Chief Janet Robinson Could Make $25,000 Per Hour In Consulting Payments



Janet Robinson Consulting Pay

An SEC filing says Ms. Robinson will get $4.5 million plus health insurance for a 12-month retirement and consulting agreement, including "two-year non-competition, non-solicitation and non-disparagement covenants, a three-year cooperation covenant and an indefinite confidentiality covenant."

The Times itself reported that Ms. Robinson's pay in 2009 was $4.9 million, so she'll earn almost as much as a retired consultant as as a full-time CEO.

The handy investment calculator on the Times corporate Web site shows that $10,000 invested in NYT stock the day Ms. Robinson took over as CEO, on December 27, 2004, would be worth $1,855.14 today, a decline of 81.45%. 

The price of the stock went from $40.59 when she took over to $7.53 today, and though some dividends were paid out early in her tenure as CEO, the dividend has since been suspended.

It's all almost enough to be grist for one of those angry New York Times editorials or business section columns about executives whose outsized pay bears no relation to performance. 
Arthur Sulzberger

In this case, the board hasn't fired the chairman, Arthur Sulzberger Jr., whose family controls the board and the company through a special class of stock. Ms. Robinson could perhaps argue that she earned her pay by serving as someone outside the family for the family to blame for the poor performance.

Which do you think accounts for more of the $4.5 million, the non-competition covenant or the non-disparagement covenant? Mark your calendar for two years from now when the non-disparagement agreement expires.



"No minimum number of hours and a maximum of 15 per month. If she works the maximum amount of hours, which is doubtful, she will earn roughly $25,000 per hour, which is pretty significant for a company that is struggling financially.

In addition to the pension and consulting contract, Robinson is also owed a bonus for 2011 which has yet to be determined, but her most recent bonus was for $1.85 million.

Even though the Times is on the hook to Robinson for $4.5 million, they may be better off just paying her and not asking for her advice, based on her recent track record at the paper."



Janet L. Robinson
When the New York Times' (NYT) and its president and former chief executive, Janet L. Robinson, announced a few months ago that Robinson would step down at the end of the year - even though no successor had been identified - the news caught many off guard. 

The Times disclosed in an 8-K filed December 15, 2011 that it planned to pay Robinson $4.5 million for a one-year consulting gig; however, several interesting details about that consulting agreement weren't available until the company filed its 10-K late last week.

New York Times Editors Respond To Staffers' Protest 

Executive Editor Jill Abramson

On Thursday, the top editors of the New York Times responded to their staffers' open protest of ongoing contract negotiations. 

 Members of the New York Newspaper Guild lined the hallway outside the Page One meeting room in protest as editors entered a 4 p.m. meeting on Wednesday. 

The showing demonstrated staffers' dismay over their contract negotiations, which have been going on for over a year, and negotiators' calls for freezing their pension plans and ending their independent health insurance. A memo had alerted staffers to the protest, and called on senior editors to relay their concerns to the paper's management. 

Executive editor Jill Abramson, managing editor Dean Baquet and managing editor John Geddes responded to the grievances in a letter on Thursday, asking for patience as negotiators continue to plug away at a contract. 

In it, they stressed that the editors and staffers were "all in this together," and empathized with frustrations over the negotiations. "Yesterday’s gathering by the page one room shortly before the 4 p.m.meeting was another reminder of how deeply unsettling this time has been," they wrote. 

However, they said that there had been bright spots in the management's handling of employee pension plans, and made it clear that the discussion over contract terms would remain between the negotiators.

New York Times Employees Protest Contract Negotiations



New York Times employees are openly protesting the ongoing contract negotiations with the newspaper's management again. 

Poynter reports that members of the Newspaper Guild gathered outside the office's Page One meeting room for ten minutes in a quiet display of dissent on Wednesday afternoon.

On Tuesday, they had received a notice alerting them to the planned protest. The memo alleged that management was trying to "compromise our financial welfare, our access to health care and our security in retirement," and called on senior editors to relay the sentiment.

This latest development comes after hundreds of staffers signed an open letter expressing their "profound dismay" with the company's decisions in December. Guild members had been working without a contract since last March, and the letter expressed outrage over negotiators' calls for "a freeze of our pension plan and an end to our independent health insurance," amongst other things.

The tension appears to be heating up as the New York Times faces continued criticism over former CEO Janet Robinson's extremely generous severance package. Employee unions hammered the paper for paying her $4.5 million. The Times is also struggling to fill the leadership vacuum left by Robinson's departure. 

 For more Information go to: http://saveourtimes.com/


Details About The Gray Lady’s $25,000-per-hour Consultant



by Sonya Hubbard




Image source: sjsharktank via flickr



When the New York Times (NYT) and its president and former chief executive, Janet L. Robinson, announced a few months ago that Robinson would step down at the end of the year – even though no successor had been identified – the news caught many off guard. The Times disclosed in an 8-K filed December 15, 2011 that it planned to pay Robinson $4.5 million for a one-year consulting gig; however, several interesting details about that consulting agreement weren’t available until the company filed its 10-K late last week.

We found Robinson’s Retirement and Consulting Agreement attached as Exhibit 10.34 to the 10-K filed February 23.

Perhaps the most fascinating term is in the section that describes the consulting services that Robinson is to provide, where it states that in exchange for paying her $4.5 million:
“…(c) you shall not be required to provide more than 15 hours of such services or assistance in any month.”

In fact, though, the agreement doesn’t really require Robinson to provide a minimum number of hours at all. It states that she:

“…shall provide consulting services as reasonably requested by the Company concerning Company matters with which you have been involved or have knowledge; provided that, in each case, (a) the Company shall provide you with reasonable advance notice when requesting such services or assistance, (b) the Company shall exercise reasonable efforts to schedule any services or assistance requested so as to not unreasonably disrupt your business and personal affairs and you shall exercise reasonable efforts to fulfill the Company’s consulting requests in a timely manner, notwithstanding your personal and other business commitments,…”

So if the Times never calls Robinson, she simply gets the $4.5 million. If it does call her and she ends up consulting for 15 hours a month, that’s an effective rate of $375,000 a month, or $25,000 per hour.

Actually, however, the money won’t be paid evenly over the one-year term. The agreement promised to pay Robinson $2.25 million in equal installments “during the period between January 1, 2012 and March 15, 2012,” and it will pay the other $2.25 million in equal payments “during the period between July 1, 2012 and December 31, 2012.” We can’t know whether the irregular timing of the payments was something Robinson requested or a term that the Times wanted, but ultimately both parties agreed to it.

The agreement also promised Robinson that she will get a bonus for 2011 and an award under the long-term incentive plan. The bonus will be calculated according to a complicated formula that considers such factors as her bonus target and the Times’ adjusted EBITDA.

We’ll have to wait for the proxy – which we expect will be filed in mid-March, if the Times follows the same schedule as last year – to find out how much Robinson got. According to the 2011 proxy, Robinson most recently got a bonus of $1.85 million and another $474,375 as a long-term performance award for the 2006-2010 cycle.

As it determines her current bonus and long-term performance award, the Times promised not to exercise negative discretion towards Robinson’s awards unless it does so for “executive officers generally.”

There are so many variables at play here that we can’t speculate how much Robinson will get. But we did find this article that Bloomberg published late last month, which reported that

“Robinson will receive an exit package totaling more than $21 million, higher than previously reported, said the people, who wouldn’t be named because the information isn’t public.” Next month’s proxy should answer the question for all of us.

Robinson was a veteran at the Times, having spent 28 years there at the time she left, including her term as president and chief executive officer since 2004.

Perhaps the big payment as she left was simply to thank her for her long service and ease the sting of the meeting in which (according to the Times itself) Arthur Sulzberger Jr. reportedly told Robinson that it was time to “[install] a different type of leadership at the company.” If that’s the case, though, perhaps they should just call it what it appears to be – a separation payment – rather than a consulting fee.

 

For more Information go to: http://saveourtimes.com/





Saturday, March 3, 2012

NYT guild members have ‘quiet’ protest outside Page One meeting




Newspaper Guild members at The New York Times received this notice Tuesday:


A photo (sent to us) shows the turnout. There’s also a video (via Romenesko).
Please join us at 3:50 p.m. on Wednesday for a quiet, 10-minute display of unity, around the entrances to the Page One meeting room on the third floor.

The point is to show our common dismay over contract negotiations in which management seems determined to seriously compromise our financial welfare, our access to health care and our security in retirement. We hope that senior editors who witness and understand our mutual resolve will convey the gravity of the situation to management.

Quiet protest, everybody! Sorry: (quiet protest, everybody). You can vigorously rustle your copy of the Observer, or tap out a polite tweet on your phone (keyboard clicks off, please). Participants are encouraged to stare pensively at top editors, but not in any way that could be construed as threatening.

|| Related: Nearly 600 Times staffers have signed an open letter to Arthur Sulzberger expressing “profound dismay” over pension freeze and health insurance changes | New York Times’ buyouts, contract negotiations show newsroom shift to Web (Poynter) | New York Times Co. Calls Union Back to Negotiations After CEO’s Departure (Bloomberg) NYT says it’s seeking ‘a modern contract’ with the guild Boston Newspaper Guild members reject cuts  About 80% of Boston Newspaper Guild members voted on concessions
Why didn’t NYT do more to win the hearts and minds of Globe guild members?

For more Information go to:  http://saveourtimes.com/

Half of The New York Times Newsroom Is Politely Protesting

Photo by Reuters




By Adam Clark Estes

 The hallways were impassible outside the daily Page One meeting of the senior-most editors at The New York Times on Wednesday afternoon, due to an unfortunate series of events that has almost 600 journalists up in arms. An internal memo obtained by Poynter described the event as a "quiet, 10-minute display of unity … to show our common dismay over contract negotiations" for the members of the Newspaper Guild. The full memo reads as follows:

"Please join us at 3:50 p.m. on Wednesday for a quiet, 10-minute display of unity, around the entrances to the Page One meeting room on the third floor. The point is to show our common dismay over contract negotiations <http://saveourtimes.com/index.php> in which management seems determined to seriously compromise our financial welfare, our access to health care and our security in retirement. We hope that senior editors who witness and understand our mutual resolve will convey the gravity of the situation to management."

This comes after half of the Times newsroom expressed "profound dismay" in an open letter to acting CEO and owner Arthur Sulzberger Jr. (We've written a decent amount about why everybody is upset.)

This all seems pretty serious and dramatic for so sophisticated a place as The New York Times headquarters in that fancy midtown Manhattan skyscraper. But it's happening, and if it escalates to the point of a strike, you could be missing some news in the blue bundle that shows up on your doorstep every morning.

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at aestes@theatlantic.com.

You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Read more at: http://saveourtimes.com/


The Guild Celebrates Employee Appreciation Day at The New York Times



 Happy Employee Appreciation Day!! 

 The New York Newspaper Guild, Local 31003 thanks YOU for being 
The New York Times

Happy Employee Appreciation Day!!


Friday was Employee Appreciation Day (who remembered?)
 
In celebration of that -- and to draw a contrast to the way the Times is trying to celebrate it by eating the lunch and drinking the milkshake of their New York Newspaper Guild represented employees – the Guild bought everybody at The New York Times coffee and doughnuts.
 
The first shipment was delivered at 11:15an Friday morning.

 
A second one – for those who work evenings – was delivered at 4:45 PM
 
One person in each work area  volunteered to go downstairs and grab some and gave them out. 

Everyone was appreciative of the Guild's gesture.
 
Times Reporter Donald McNeil said, "The Guild said it bought plenty of doughnuts, so anyone who had one (or more) in the morning and wanted another – well, it’s between you and your conscience. However, my previous offer to personally buy a doughnut for anyone unhappy with this innocuous publicity stunt is limited to one.  Consider it a doughnut freeze.  Now you know how retirement is going to feel."

See more pictures here:  http://baranger.as/donuts/

For more information go to:  http://saveourtimes.com/

Occupy NYT


By KEITH J. KELLY
 
The top trio of editors at the New York Times, including Executive Editor Jill Abramson, released a very sympathetic letter to rank-and-file newsroom employees yesterday following a silent protest inside the paper’s offices by union members on Wednesday.

Members of the Newspaper Guild, the largest union at the Times, representing reporters and photographers and some business-side people, had staged a silent protest by lining the hallway outside the page one meeting on Tuesday afternoon.

A photo of the silent protest (above) was tweeted yesterday.

The protest was not directed at Abramson or Managing Editors Dean Baquet or John Geddes. The aim was for the editors to relay to Chairman Arthur “Pinch” Sulzberger, Jr. the newsroom anger at the stalled contract talks.

The Newspaper Guild has been without a contract since March 31, 2011. The Guild said that in talks the company has been pushing to freeze pension benefits.

Apparently, what stoked the newsroom anger was a report on Footnoted.org that crunched the numbers in the Times’ recently-filed 10-K revealing that ousted former President and CEO Janet Robinson will get, in addition to her severance and pension, an added $4.5 million for a gig that requires her to do no more than 15 hours of consulting per month. If she puts in all 15 hours, it works out to $375,000 a month or $25,000 per hour.

But the consulting gig is only part of her farewell package, estimated to be more than $21 million.
Bill O’Meara, president of the Newspaper Guild, said the protest was organized by the newsroom, not the Guild.

The editors appear sympathetic.

“Yesterday’s gathering by the page one room shortly before the 4 p.m. meeting was another reminder of how deeply unsettling this time has been,” said a memo released by Abramson, Baquet and Geddes to staffers yesterday. “We understand those concerns.”

kkelly@nypost.com

 Read more at: http://saveourtimes.com/



Friday, March 2, 2012

Newspaper Guild Protest at The New York Times

View from across court yard of Times building during Feb. 29 gathering of Guild members at daily Page One meeting

In silence, Times Guild members send a loud message


Managing Editor John Geddes

'Without us, it's just white space'


On Feb. 29, more than 250 New York Times Guild members in New York and Washington gave editors a silent but conspicuous demonstration of their anger at company contract proposals to cut their overall compensation, including retirement income.

Executive Edtior Jill Abramson
Journalists and other Guild-represented employees whose work makes The Times what it is – in print and pixels – lined the hallways as the newspaper's senior editors made their way to their regular meeting to discuss the day's top stories and to decide which would go on page one. Washington Bureau reporters did the same when their editors met to dial into the New York “Page One” meeting.

The reporters, editors, photographers, digital journalists, other newsroom employees and ad sales reps stood silently, leaving a narrow lane for the editors, including Executive Editor Jill Abramson, to pass. Most wore stickers that said, “Without us, it's just white space.” It is their work, after all, that fills The Times's print and Web pages and reinforces its reputation for journalistic excellence every day.



Associate Managing Editor Alan Flippen
 For most Guild members, the beef was not with their editors, but with high-level Times executives, who are seeking a wide swath of cuts in contract negotiations that, among other things, would freeze Guild members’ salaries, cut medical benefits and weaken retirement security. While progress has been made in some areas, management’s chief negotiator declared in mid-February that “the pension plan you’re in has to go.”

Most galling to Times staffers is that management’s demands come as the company sent former CEO Janet Robinson on her way at the end of 2011 with a severance package that has grown with every successive report like a Powerball jackpot.

A recent report valued her exit package at more than $21 million, including a $10.9 million pension payout.


Guild members maintain silent vigil even after start of Feb. 29 Page One meeting.





Guild member shows what the Times would look like without our efforts.




New York Times Page one meeting with members of The Newspaper Guild of New York, Local 31003, CWA in silent protest.

what the well dressed Times Guild member is wearing these days




 Read more at: http://saveourtimes.com/


We are the New York area workplace advocate for people in the news business, and that includes some of the best journalists in the country.

The Newspaper Guild of New York represents more than 3,000 employees at New York area-based news organizations, as well as a few non-news organizations.
Since its launch in 1934 by crusading columnist Heywood Broun and others, the Guild has been the voice in the workplace for practitioners of big-city journalism and employees in advertising, circulation and other related areas. It started with newspapers, but today the Guild’s reach extends to workers in all media. 



http://www.nyguild.org/index.html

Saturday, February 11, 2012

NABET-CWA Members Ratify NBCU Contract



B U L L E T I N

NABET-CWA/NBCU NEGOTIATIONS

Washington, DC

BULLETIN #32

February 10, 2012

The NABET-CWA Network Negotiating Committee has tabulated the votes for the NBC Universal ratification balloting concerning the Company's January 10, 2012 Master Agreement contract offer. Eligible NABET-CWA members employed at NBCU have ratified this contract offer by an overwhelming majority.

The Union's Bargaining Committee expresses their gratitude to the NABET-CWA members working across the country at NBC Universal, for their continued mobilization support and perseverance during this process.

The previous Master Agreement at NBC Universal expired on March 31, 2009. The new ratified agreement covers broadcast technicians, news-writers, building, air conditioning and plant maintenance personnel, staging services personnel, and couriers at various Company Network and TV station operations in New York, Chicago, Burbank and Washington D.C.

Most of the terms and conditions of the new agreement go into effect immediately, unless otherwise stated in any individual proposal contained in the January 10, 2012 contract offer. 

Some economic provisions such as penalty payment increases will go into effect tomorrow, which is the beginning of the next full payroll period at NBC Universal. Payment of the ratification bonuses will be made by the end of February. 

Additionally, the first annual wage increase of 2.75% goes into effect starting April 7, 2012, which is the beginning of the first full payroll period after April 1, 2012.

In the meantime, your Union Bargaining Committee reminds you to ignore all rumors. Further information about these new terms and conditions of the Master Agreement, including copies of the complete new contract, will be provided as soon as these items are available.

In Solidarity,

NABET-CWA Network Negotiating Committee

Monday, February 6, 2012

Bob Daraio joins the TNG-CWA Mobilization Team

 
Robert Daraio
Robert Daraio is the new mobilization consultant for the New York Newspaper Guild of the Communications Workers of America (TNG-CWA) Local 31003. Bob will be working on the contract campaign for the TNG represented employees at the New York Times.

Bob Daraio is currently the recording secretary for the New York Broadcast Trades Council (NYBTC) and moderator of the Broadcast Union News website.

Bob is the NABET-CWA Local 16 delegate to the New York City Central Labor Council, AFL-CIO (NYCCLC). This is Bob's return to the NYCCLC, having previously represented NABET Local 15 and then IATSE Local 644 at this body.

A BFA graduate of the first four-year class in Theatre Technology at SUNY Purchase, Bob earned an MA in Labor Studies at the CUNY Murphy Institute for Worker Education and Labor Studies, graduating in June 2011.

Bob has served on the Executive Boards of the National Association of Broadcast Employees and Technicians (NABET) Local 15, the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE) Local 644, and was a shop steward and negotiation committee member of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) Local 1212 at WPIX. Bob is one of a select few who have held elective office in all three of New York’s film, television, and theatrical technical employee unions. 

Bob joined WPIX as a video engineer on June 1, 1999 and remained with the company through May 2010. This was Bob’s first staff position following a 22-year career as a freelance camera, robotics, video, audio, and videotape technician. His news, sports, and entertainment clients include ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX5, TBS, WWOR, WPIX, WNET, MSG, CNN, HBO, Showtime, MTV, VH1, CTW, NEP, Unitel, MTI, ESPN, and the National Geographic Society.

In 2002 the National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences honored Bob for his video and robotic camera work on the Emmy Award winning “The WB11 News at 10”. Bob has been a video controller and digital imaging technician for hundreds of television commercials. His feature film credits include the Rosie Perez and Pattie Lupone independent film "24-Hour Woman" and "For Love of the Game" with Kevin Costner for Universal Pictures.

Bob is proud to be an IATSE Local One stagehand. His Broadway credits include "She Loves Me" and "Company".

IATSE Local One, along with NABET-CWA Local 16, IBEW Local 1212, and the Westchester Putnam Central Labor Body, endorsed Bob's successful campaign for election to the Board of Trustees in the Village of Ossining, New York.

Bob is a Trustee and Police Commissioner for the Village of Ossining, New York, where he lives with his wife Gayle Palmieri, an IATSE Local 764 member currently on the Broadway wardrobe crew of “Sister Act”.

Defending Workers Against Discipline



By Robert Schwartz
 
Labor Notes Editor's note: The author is working on a new handbook on defending workers against discipline. Here are some excerpts.


Forced Resignation

Q. Can we submit a grievance for a nurse’s aide who resigned from work after her supervisor falsely accused her of patient abuse, threatened to discharge her, and suggested that she quit?

A. Yes. Under a theory called “constructive discharge,” a resignation extracted by duress or coercion is considered equivalent to a discharge.

Retracting a Resignation

Q. When a supervisor demoted a worker, the worker lost it and declared, “If that’s how you feel about me, I quit.” That night she called the union and said she had made a big mistake. Management says a quit is a quit. Can we grieve under the just cause standard?

A. Yes. An employee who quits her position because of emotional stress can retract the resignation if she gives prompt notice by telephone, fax, or email and if the employer will suffer no significant harm by permitting the employee to return.

Applying Rules Off-Duty

Q. Does a work rule prohibiting the use, sale, or possession of controlled drugs apply when an employee is off-duty?

A. Generally, no. Company rules do not apply to off-duty conduct unless expressly stated. Even if the rule says it applies off-duty, the union can challenge the rule as unreasonable if the prohibited conduct does not have a demonstrably adverse impact on the workplace.

Drug Test

Q. A worker failed a drug test. Can the employer fire him without an interview?

A. No. Under due process principles, the employer must give the employee a chance to explain why he was taking the banned substance and why he should not be punished.

Double Jeopardy

Q. An employee threatened another worker. Two hours later, his supervisor said, “If you do that again, you will be in a bag of trouble.” The next day, human relations called the worker in and suspended him for a week. Can we defend on the grounds of double jeopardy?

A. Yes. A worker cannot be disciplined twice for the same conduct. The first notice was a verbal reprimand. The worker viewed it as final and continued working. The matter should have ended there.

Anonymous Complaint

Q. Personnel fired a driver after an anonymous customer sent a letter containing graphic descriptions of sexual misconduct. Do we have a chance at arbitration?

A. Yes. An employer cannot justify a discharge solely on the basis of hearsay. If the driver consistently denies the charges, and the complainant does not appear to testify, an arbitrator is likely to order reinstatement.

Snake in the Truck

Q. A driver drove his truck into a guard rail. He claimed he saw a large snake on the passenger seat and grabbed it with both hands to avoid being bitten. Impossible case?

A. No. When a discharge is based on circumstantial evidence (no witnesses), the evidence must eliminate reasonable explanations advanced by the employee. If the driver gave the snake explanation from the get-go, and stayed with it consistently, he should prevail at arbitration.

Lie Detector Test

Q. An employee suspected of theft declined to take a polygraph test. Can the employer cite her refusal as evidence of guilt?

A. No. Arbitrators disfavor polygraph tests. They almost never hold refusals against employees.

Disparate Treatment

Q. The company discharged a five-year worker for sleeping on the job. Two years ago, a worker with 20 years’ seniority was given a one-day suspension for the same offense. Does the difference in service time justify the difference in penalties?

A. No. Differences in seniority do not justify wide divergences in penalties.

Dog Ate It

Q. Management says it lost the paperwork that explains why it issued a lenient penalty two years ago. Is this sufficient to avoid a finding of disparate treatment?

A. No. An employer cannot escape a finding of disparate treatment by asserting that paperwork has been lost or misplaced.

Pick Your Poison

Q. The company fired a worker who was seen smoking marijuana in her car. Six months earlier a worker who drank beer on the job was given a five-day suspension. Isn’t this disparate treatment?

A. Yes. There is no acceptable basis for imposing substantially harsher penalties on employees who commit drug offenses than on employees who commit similar alcohol offenses.

Erasing Disparate Treatment

Q. If an employer suspends an employee for sleeping on the job, is it barred from firing future offenders?

A. No. An employer can erase past leniency by making a clear and unequivocal announcement to the workforce that it intends to discharge employees for all such offenses in the future.

Progressive Discipline

Q. Our contract has a four-step progressive discipline policy. An employee with 20 years’ service committed four offenses and was discharged. But in an earlier case, management gave a 22-year worker with four offenses another chance. Can we raise disparate treatment?

A. Yes. The employer surrendered its right to insist on a lockstep application of the progressive discipline provision. If mitigating circumstances are considered for one employee, they must be considered for all.

Zero Tolerance

Q. The company manual says any violations of safety policies “shall result in termination.” Is this penalty binding in arbitration?

A. No. Arbitrators frequently rule that zero-tolerance policies are trumped by contractual just-cause clauses.

Robert Schwartz is the author of several labor law handbooks published by Work Rights Press and available from Labor Notes, including The Legal Rights of Union Stewards.

About Labor Notes

Labor Notes is a media and organizing project that has been the voice of union activists who want to put the movement back in the labor movement since 1979.