Tuesday, August 25, 2009

THE EMPLOYEE FREE CHOICE ACT: Good for Small Business

Seth D. Michaels
Online Communications Coordinator
Employee Free Choice Act
202-637-5008
employeefreecchoice.org

A Competitive Economy Needs Labor Law Reform

Small businesses are the backbone of our economy, employing almost half of the American workforce.

Small business owners strongly believe that their employees are a vital asset to their success. Yet, our labor law is not ensuring a level playing field for responsible businesses, large and small.

Businesses that comply with the law face unfair competition from companies who refuse to respect the rights of their employees to join unions. The current labor law system allows employers to veto the will of workers, violate the law with relative impunity, and systematically delay sitting down at the table to negotiate a first contract.

The Employee Free Choice Act makes no changes to the existing National Labor Relations Act’s definition of a small business, which is largely based on revenue and type of business. It does, however, restore the role of our labor laws to act as a watchdog to make sure every business is playing by the rules, while at the same time restoring every American’s
right to join or form a union so they can reach for the American Dream.

The legislation will give back to small businesses the freedom to compete based on innovation and quality instead of who can afford the most expensive anti-union consultants. In this economic crisis, the nation has a duty to enable entrepreneurs and start-up companies to focus on building sustainable, long-term success, instead of being forced to compete against irresponsible businesses in an unwinnable, low-wage race to the bottom.

Urgent action is needed if we are to join together, management and workers alike, and climb out of this economic recession. The Employee Free Choice Act provides a process to get us there that is streamlined and efficient.

Claims of Negative Impact Simply Not True

Small and large businesses across the nation who have respected their employees’ choice to form a union have reported that the sky did not fall – far from it. In fact, a 2005 report by an economist on behalf of the Small Business Administration found that a higher percentage of unionized workers in a state significantly reduced the probability
of small business failures.

More generally, University of Michigan scholar John DiNardo has a body of research demonstrating that firms that become unionized are no more likely to fail than comparable firms that remain non-union.

Moreover, workers emerge from successful organizing drives with an enhanced sense of their common stake in the long-term stability and profitability of their company. This results in negotiated wage increases that are commonly designed to be implemented slowly over time. This stability can help small employers plan and forecast better.

Finally, if we look at the larger context, we see economic policy that has allowed a handful of greedy speculators to wreak havoc. Their power has been unchecked.

Small businesses are not receiving bailout funds, but they are certainly paying the price. This country has been at its strongest when it has made sure that the voices of the most powerful among us are balanced with those with less power, like small business owners, family farmers, and working people.

The Employee Free Choice Act is explicitly designed to help restore that balance.

A Win-Win for Small Businesses

Boost Consumer Spending

First and foremost, small businesses need customers to purchase their products and services. An estimated 70 percent of our nation’s economy comes from consumer activity.

The Center for American Progress Action Fund found that if union membership rates increased just 5 percent over current levels, newly unionized workers would earn an estimated $25.5 billion more in wages and salaries per year—money that will be pumped right back into our economy.

Another recent study conducted by the nonprofit Economic Roundtable found that the wages negotiated by union workers in Los Angeles add $7.2 billion a year in pay. As these workers spend their income on food, clothing, child care, car and home repairs, and other items, their additional buying power creates 64,800 jobs and $11 billion in
economic output.

Access to Training

There is a general consensus among economists that unionization is linked to reduced turnover. In a small company, even losing one or two trained workers can hit the bottom line hard. Thus it’s no surprise that across the country, businesses are working in tandem with unions to help with training, skills building, and career development.

Small businesses that are limited in their budgets can benefit enormously from union-sponsored training programs that combine resources over multiple employers and draws on the well-established training and apprenticeship infrastructures of labor unions.

Pooling to Reduce Healthcare Costs

Many business owners say they want to offer or to continue to offer health insurance and believe it is vital to attracting and retaining high-quality employees. But skyrocketing healthcare costs are making this nearly impossible.

Unions are stepping in with healthcare plans that pool many unionized workers and small businesses together to bring costs down. Many unions and businesses are working together for meaningful reforms on issues that strongly affect small businesses such as public funding for home care and child care, fair trade, pension reform, and financial assistance for
start-up green companies.


AFL-CIO leader chosen to be N.Y. Fed chairman

By Michael McKee
Bloomberg News

Denis Hughes, president of the New York State AFL- CIO, has been designated as chairman of the New York Federal Reserve Bank's board of directors for the remainder of 2009, bank spokesman Calvin Mitchell said in a statement.

Hughes, 59, has served as acting chairman since May, when Stephen Friedman resigned from the position to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest over his ties to Goldman Sachs Group Inc.

Friedman, a director on Goldman Sachs' board and a former chairman of the investment bank, purchased shares in Goldman Sachs while serving as chairman of the New York Fed. The district bank oversees Goldman Sachs.

Friedman, chairman of Stone Point Capital LLC, had received a waiver to continue serving on the Fed board after Goldman Sachs became a bank-holding company last September after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.

Hughes joined the New York Fed board in January 2004.

Lee Bollinger, the president of Columbia University, was designated as vice chairman. Bollinger, 63, became a director in January 2007. He has been reappointed to a new three-year term that begins Jan. 1.

The New York Fed is one of 12 regional Fed banks that, along with the Board of Governors, make up the Federal Reserve system.

Next AFL-CIO chief pledges to press for health care, labor law reform

By Michael Mishak (contact)
http://www.lasvegassun.com/

Richard Trumka fashions himself after some of the 20th century’s labor firebrands.

Set to become AFL-CIO president next month, the mustachioed third-generation mine worker from southwestern Pennsylvania cuts an imposing figure. His fists are the size of softballs and he pounds the lectern to make his point. But he’ll need more than might to reinvigorate a flagging movement beset by globalization, corporate power and union infighting.

On Monday, Trumka said he’s up to the challenge, pledging to capitalize on Democratic majorities in Congress — and to heal bitter union divisions. He told convention delegates of the international painters union here that he would recast the nation’s largest labor federation into an “agitating, mobilizing, organizing” machine.

Health care and labor law reform, he said, will set the stage. The AFL-CIO has stepped up pressure on both fronts, with Trumka taking partial credit in an interview for turning back an apparent effort to ditch the so-called public option in health legislation. In the past week Senate Democrats have talked openly about using a rare procedure to overcome Republican opposition and centrists in their own party.

Sen. Max Baucus, the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee who is leading bipartisan negotiations, recently voiced his support for the public option.

“I think we helped them do that,” Trumka said.

It’s one example of a more aggressive brand of politics the AFL-CIO intends to play after being outmaneuvered early on in the health care and labor law debates this year. For instance, Senate Democrats negotiating a compromise bill that would make it easier for workers to organize reportedly conceded a key provision to advance the legislation.

“It’s up to us to help Congress and the president do what’s right by working people,” Trumka said. “Trust me, we intend to help them do what’s right.”

He added: “It’s in their heart. Now we need to get it down on paper and make it law. We will take well-defined positions and we’ll fight to keep those positions … Politicians who vote against (health care reform) do so at their own peril.”

Trumka vowed victories on health care and labor law reforms this year.
With Democrats in control of Congress and the White House, union leaders see a rare opportunity to shape labor policy for the first time since the Great Depression and are redoubling their efforts after seeing signs that some of their allies in Washington are wavering.

Trumka said labor will settle for nothing less than fundamental reforms. As for management style, Trumka said he planned to grow the movement from the grass roots, drawing contrasts between himself and labor leader Andy Stern of the Service Employees International Union, the fastest-growing labor organization in the country. Stern’s union has drawn criticism for compromising contract standards in return for organizing rights.

Stern has countered that the moves are part of a long-term strategy that will boost membership and lead to gains down the road.

“When you look at the policies of the last 30 years, they’ve put a box around labor,” Trumka said, citing widespread deregulation and a series of pro-business decisions by the National Labor Relations Board. “That system has proved an utter failure. The difference between me and (Stern) is that he believes you can look at that system and play within that box by accommodating employers. I believe that the system has to be changed because it’s designed for employers to win and workers, every time, to lose.”

Trumka said he isn’t alone in that philosophy. He’s in reunification talks with three unions that Stern helped lead out of the AFL-CIO in 2005, a split that cost the federation “years of momentum,” he said. Among those unions is Unite Here, parent of the Culinary Union. Trumka is also meeting with the National Education Association, the country’s largest union, representing 3.2 million teachers and retired educators.

A reconstituted labor movement must focus on organizing younger workers and unions must stop raiding one another to win over existing members, Trumka said.

Toward those ends, he said the AFL-CIO would build a “reserve army” of 1,000 organizers to assist in strategic drives and prevent union raids.

Trumka’s animating vision: Don’t be timid. Act bold.

It’s the kind of thing Trumka’s father taught him.

“If it was right you fought for it. If it was wrong, you fought against it,” he said. “And there was no in between.”

Looks like the family legacy lives on.

Why Are So Few Women Directing In Television?

By BRADLEY BORUM
http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/

Caught between the camera and the cradle: Why are so few women making television films?

TELEVISION production does not just need more women, it needs many, many more women, according to Lord Rees-Mogg, chairman of the Broadcasting Standards Council. He recently bemoaned the fact that television is dominated by male executives who fail to represent the interests of women and children. They are responsible for violent programmes that no woman would make, he believes.

In fact, however, the film and television world is not only inundated with the female sex, they underpin the whole industry. The problem is that they are in the engine room and not on the bridge.

Pivotal to determining the quality and meaning of a film is the role of director. The job requires vision, conviction and organisation, coupled with humility and toughness - qualities that are not exclusive to men. Yet there are far fewer women than men directors.

Is this because women are discriminated against, or is it because the profession is so demanding that it forces most women to choose between family life and a career?

From mainstream drama and documentary to lesbian films, the consensus is that film-making is an ideal activity for obsessives. Which is not to say one cannot have a partner, family and work, but, as one woman director put it: 'The industry is no respecter of a private life, let alone a home.'

The documentary director Molly Dineen is frank about the difficulties of combining her job with a personal life.

'I did try for a month, I thought right, put yourself out to tender, Dineen, and get on with it. The presumption was terrible - that people were going to appear because suddenly I was in the mood to create some kind of private life.'

She is best known for her portraits in films like Home from the Hill, a documentary about the English expatriate Hillary Hook, which was twice shown on the BBC. She is now working for the BBC on a series about London Zoo. 'It preoccupies me a bit because I'm 33, still up the back end of a rhino, and totally obsessive about what I do, and I feel locked into that. I'm not going to pretend I can spend 13 hours a day in London Zoo and go home and look after a family.'

Sarah Hellings is probably responsible for more prime-time television drama than any other director - man or woman. Her numerous credits include Capital City, Lovejoy, and The Ruth Rendell Mystery Movie. She has received two BAFTA nominations.

She says that throughout her twenties and thirties her creative instincts went into her work. She doesn't believe children are compatible with her job. She has been married twice - both times to men in the film industry.

She says that marriages in the industry are usually tripartite affairs: husband, wife and the film. In terms of personal relationships, she believes she is perhaps unfulfilled, and she bemoans what she sees as a choice women in the industry have to make between children and a career.

She also believes that some of the skills of a good director, such as motivating and leading without coming across as bossy, are 'particularly hard for women to do. I wanted to be liked, but from an early age I decided it wasn't always possible.'

She has twice been turned down for jobs because a member of the cast objected to working with a woman director.

Most of Cheryl Farthing's work has been for Out, Channel 4's gay and lesbian series. She believes that 'women see the world through completely different eyes, (and that view is) of as much interest to men as it is to other women'. At 29 she has recently completed a short cinema feature called Rosebud, which is a lesbian love story deliberately made with mass appeal.

'It was very important to me that the film looked good, was accessible and sexy for everyone: and I think it's sexy for straight women and men and lesbians. I've even had gay men say they found it sexy.'

She blames cautious producers and commissioning editors for not giving more women a chance and believes sexism has a lot to answer for, starting with training.

In her experience, women tend to differ from men in mixed training groups and this affects 'the way they enter the industry and how ambitious they are in setting ceilings for themselves'.

Fizz Waters, 35, started her career at 16 as a tea lady in the Thames Television canteen. Now a first assistant director, the right hand to a drama or feature film director, her credits include many of Thames's long-running successes, such as The Benny Hill Show, Rumpole and The Bill.

'I used to take my tea trolley around to all the departments and one of the heads was a lovely fellow who I used to wake gently with a cup of tea.' He later had the confidence to take Fizz on as a 'call boy'. When the Sex Discrimination Act became law, her title was changed to 'floor assistant'.

Early on, while she was still Benny Hill's 'floor polisher', Hill used to tell her to carry a pencil and paper and ask herself what she had done that day to further her career.

'Sometimes I think it would be nice to be half of a couple again and then I think no, it might get in the way of doing what I want to do when I want.'
Like Sarah Hellings, she also thinks women can find being in charge difficult. 'Maybe women are put off being first assistants because you have to be bossy,' she says.

Sharon Miller, 35, began as an actress, but, being 6ft tall, she was quickly confined to playing 'big girl' roles; first with Ronnie Corbett and then as Bill Oddie's mum in The Goodies.

'It was so devastating to any kind of artistic integrity when the only reason you're hired is for your height and the fact that you can have your tits padded.'

So, minus the padding, she went into children's programmes, a traditional employer of women and sometimes a ghetto: 'There's an image of a director who works for the children's department - the kind of woman who doesn't have children, and wears loud stockings and brogues.'

For a while she was 'that girl from children's' who got out - even if it was straight into a pothole full of bats, dripping water, and the cast and crew of an episode of Casualty. From there she directed further episodes and eventually had the clout to do work such as A Woman Alone with Lynn Redgrave.

Women directors do not want to be seen as strident or whingeing. They acknowledge that many of their work difficulties are shared by men, but most feel they have to work harder, especially in the early stages of their careers.

Film-making has always been competitive, especially so now that there is a recession, so does it matter that there are so few women directors?
Molly Dineen is not convinced it does: 'There are fewer women in most things, but is that a problem?' she asks.' I mean, we are physically built to do a different task. I basically believe in natural functions, and my generation assumes we can have both. It's bollocks.'

She recalls making a film about London's underground, working with a former sound recordist- turned-mum: 'I was trying to get her to stay in the station all night and get drunk with me and the ticket collectors (and) she basically really wanted to be with her babies, and that's when you realise there is something a little bit out of the ordinary about making films like this and trying to have your own life. A boyfriend once said: 'I think I'll make films now and have babies when I'm about 46' - I wish I could say that.

'I think, at the moment, people who have nannies are guilty that they've got nannies. People who don't have nannies feel inadequate because they're not working. People who don't have children think that they're going to be barren and terribly sad career women in nylon suits at 50. I'm terrified of it, I absolutely don't want to be in a power suit at 49. You know, I consciously find myself going to things, wearily thinking, well I'd better go because I might meet somebody, and I hate it because I might as well go to Dateline.'

So speaks one of the leading figures of British documentary cinema, whose illuminating films about 'the ordinary', as she puts it, could perhaps only have been made by a woman. 'And let's be frank, it's bloody unfair, but why does anyone expect life to be fair? I think it's equally ghastly for a geezer to suppose he's got to produce financial support.'

Sharon Miller also believes women have to choose: 'The demands of the business made the choice for me, which was that I neglected my private life while my professional life benefited hugely. You are permanently under attack in this business, your confidence, your energy and your validity, and it's difficult for any partner to understand the complexity of what you're going through.

'It's very hard when you're in your mid-thirties and you've got to make some sort of decision. I want both - I want a family and I want to make a wonderful film, and that's the dilemma.'

The author is a freelance producer and director.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Job Openings At WPIX

Hi All,

There are job openings at WPIX posted over at:

www.entertainmentcareers.net.

Except for the Director of Engineering job, the other positions could go to IBEW 1212 members if shared jurisdiction actually meant "shared".

BD

8/21/2009 Director, Operations & Engineering WPIX-TV

8/21/2009 Commercial Coordinator WPIX-TV

8/21/2009 Entertainment Segment Producer WPIX-TV

8/21/2009 Web Producer WPIX-TV

Friday, August 21, 2009

Tribune Finalizes Sale Of Cubs To Ricketts Family

By: Mike Colias
http://www.chicagobusiness.com

(Crain’s) – Tribune Co. made it official Friday, announcing an $800 million deal to sell the Chicago Cubs, Wrigley Field and a 25% stake in Comcast SportsNet to the Ricketts family.

Tribune will retain a 5% stake in the assets, as expected, which means the overall transaction is valued at about $845 million, Tribune said.

“Our family is thrilled to have reached an agreement to acquire a controlling interest in the Chicago Cubs, one of the most storied franchises in sports," Joe Ricketts, family patriarch and founder of T.D. Ameritrade, said in a statement. "The Cubs have the greatest fans in the world, and we count our family among them. We look forward to closing the transaction so that we can begin leading the Cubs to a World Series title.”

The two sides reached a tentative agreement in January, but the deal was thrown into question last month when Tribune re-opened talks with the runner-up bidding group. Tribune first put the franchise on the selling block in the spring of 2007.

Report: Tribune Says It Expects Changes; Debt Reduced

http://www.bizjournals.com/

Tribune Co., owner of the Orlando Sentinel, said in an internal memo that its ownership will likely change as it emerges from bankruptcy protection.
A report from The Wall Street Journal states that the note informed employees that even though the ownership structure of the company will change, current operating management intends to stay in place during and after restructuring.

The Thursday note to workers came from Tribune Chief Operating Officer Randy Michaels, the Journal reports. Citing two people close with negotiations, the Journal also reports what the New York Post has reported this week -- that Tribune lenders will end up owning most of the company. The move will shrink the company's debt by 90 percent.

The Post reported this week that creditors who seek to oust Tribune CEO Sam Zell probably won’t keep the employee stock ownership plan either. The Post, citing a source familiar with the matter, states that Zell is close to leaving the company.

Zell owes these creditors $8.6 billion. However, the Journal reports that Zell and other executives have convinced the lenders that Tribune will never return to the profit levels it once saw. They’ve convinced the creditors to cut the debt down to $500 million from $8.6 billion.

The Journal reports that the lenders include Deutsche Bank AG, JP Morgan Chase & Co. Angelo Gordon and Avenue Capital. No solid reorganization plan has been reached, the report states.

Michaels’ note on Thursday releases the most details on Tribune and the rumors since June.

Michaels told employees that Tribune hopes to have a reorganization plan fleshed out by fall, the report states.

Tribune Aims To Give Competitive Wages - Memo

http://www.reuters.com

Aug 21 (Reuters) - An internal memo at Tribune Co (TRBCQ.PK) said the bankrupt media company was working to provide market-level competitive wages for employees and sought to allay employee concerns.

"It would be absurd to think that this company will be 'liquidated'," Tribune Chief Operating Officer Randy Michaels wrote in a letter to employees, which was obtained by Reuters.

The company's ownership structure is likely to change, but the current operating management intends to remain in place during and after the restructuring, Michaels said.

Earlier this week, the New York Post reported that Tribune Chief Executive Sam Zell was close to giving up his claims to buy a 40 percent stake in the company.

Tribune, which owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune and other U.S. papers, filed for bankruptcy last December.

Tribune could not immediately be reached for comment by Reuters outside regular U.S. business hours.

(Reporting by Robert MacMillan in New York and S. John Tilak in Bangalore; Editing by Muralikumar Anantharaman)

Tribune Expects Changes

By SHIRA OVIDE
The Wall Street Journal

Tribune Co. said its ownership is likely to change as the newspaper-and-television company emerges from bankruptcy-court protection, a shift that people familiar with the matter say would likely put the company in the hands of its lenders and shrink primary debt by more than 90%.

In a note Thursday to employees, Tribune Chief Operating Officer Randy Michaels said "the ownership structure of the company is likely to change." He added that "current operating management is committed, and intends to remain in place during and after the restructuring."

Two of the people familiar with the matter said Tribune's senior lenders are likely to end up owning nearly all of the equity in a reorganized company, with a small amount reserved for Tribune management, employees and unsecured debtholders.

Mr. Michaels's note is the most details Tribune has released about its fate since the company entered bankruptcy protection in December. The collapse made the Chicago-based company the poster child for the decline of the newspaper industry.

Samuel Zell, the real-estate mogul who in 2007 led a debt-heavy buyout of Tribune, came in promising to revive the moribund newspaper industry. Instead, the bankruptcy taints Mr. Zell's reputation as an investor able to a turn big profit from troubled companies.

At least four other newspaper publishers have filed for bankruptcy protection since December.

The possible ownership change caps a nearly two-year saga that began when Mr. Zell closed a deal for Tribune, the owner of newspapers including the Chicago Tribune and Los Angeles Times, a string of 23 local-television stations and the Chicago Cubs baseball team.

The foundation of Mr. Zell's hold on Tribune is a warrant that entitles him to buy as much as 40% of Tribune's equity for at least $500 million. Two of the people familiar with the matter said his warrant is likely to be wiped out in the bankruptcy process.

It is unclear whether Mr. Zell would remain involved in Tribune after it emerges from bankruptcy. One of the people familiar with the matter said while Mr. Zell might not stay as CEO, it is logical for him to remain on Tribune's board, in part because he has hand-picked nearly all of Tribune's top management.

Mr. Zell was out of the country Thursday and couldn't be reached, a spokeswoman said.

Mr. Zell and other Tribune executives have convinced creditors that Tribune can't return to earlier profit levels, and the company needs to substantially reduce debt. Senior lenders have agreed to cut their debt to roughly $500 million from $8.6 billion, according to the people familiar with the matter.

The diverse group of senior lenders include Deutsche Bank AG, JPMorgan Chase & Co., distressed-investment firm Angelo Gordon and Avenue Capital.

Bankruptcy talks are fluid, and a final plan hasn't been reached, people familiar with the matter say. The company's creditors may be offered some compensation other than equity, according to two of the people familiar with the matter. Tribune has a pending agreement to sell its Chicago Cubs and related assets for about $900 million, and the money could be funneled directly to creditors, one of these people said.

Mr. Michaels said the Tribune bankruptcy negotiations are a "slow process because we and they are trying to be very deliberate." Mr. Michaels said Tribune hopes to have a restructuring plan "fully fleshed out" this fall.

Write to Shira Ovide at shira.ovide@wsj.com

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Tribune Co. Executive: Operating Management Will Stay With Media Company

By Michael Oneal
Tribune staff reporter
http://www.chicagotribune.com

Responding to recent media reports he called "inaccurate," a top Tribune Co. executive sent a note to the company's employees Thursday saying that Tribune Co.'s current "operating management" intends to stay at the company following the Chicago media conglomerate's emergence from bankruptcy court.

Randy Michaels, Tribune's chief operating officer, also termed "absurd" suggestions in the reports that the company might be liquidated as part of its Chapter 11 plan of reorganization.

Apparently responding to a story in the Chicago Sun-Times last week predicting Tribune Co.'s lenders would gain control of the media conglomorate, oust Tribune CEO Sam Zell and sell the company's assets, Michaels said, "while the ownership structure of the company is likely to change, current operating management is committed, and intends to remain in place during and after the restructuring."

He also said that "we believe there is tremendous value in our current asset mix" and that "the whole of Tribune is greater than its sum of parts."

He noted that "in many respects, we're finding that our creditor groups agree with these principles, but of course, there are a lot of details to be worked out."

Michaels did not specifically acknowledge the Sun-Times story in the employee memo. But he said that "operating management" intended to stay, noting that "our business units, including all of our newspapers, are profitable. It would be absurd to think that this company will be liquidated."

U.S. Trustee And Unions Question Tribune Co. Bonus Plan

The U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee in Tribune Co.'s Chapter 11 case and three unions representing workers of the Chicago-based media conglomerate raised objections to Tribune management's plan to pay out tens of millions of dollars in performance bonuses.

The filings came in response to Tribune Co.'s July 22 request for authorization from the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware to pay from $21 million to almost $67 million in bonuses to more than 700 managers and other key employees for their work this year.

Tribune Co., which owns the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times and other media properties, also sought to pay nine of its top 10 executives $3.1 million in belated 2008 bonuses.

Sam Zell, the company's chairman and chief executive, is not part of the group of 10.In its response to Tribune Co.'s motion, the U.S. Trustee said the company didn't provide enough information to justify its incentive plan.

Specifically, the Trustee asserted that there is "insufficient information" in Tribune Co.'s motion to prove that the payments are for "bona fide programs and awards based on real performance targets."The Trustee, which is charged with enforcing the bankruptcy laws written by Congress, said that the awards are based on meeting specific cash flow targets but that Tribune Co. does not "give any factual and/or historical context to back up their characterization of that performance target as being 'real.'"

It also questions whether the awards are in the "ordinary course of business" as required by law.

Consequently, the Trustee said the company should provide cash flow targets for 2006 through 2008 and actual performance against those targets. Likewise, Tribune Co. should provide cash flow projections and actual results for 2009.

The Trustee said it reserves the right to supplement its response or object to the bonus request once it has this and other information. It objected outright to Tribune Co.'s request to seal certain parts of a consultant's report filed in support of its motion.

In a statement, Tribune Co. said, "The motion now before the court has the support of our senior lenders and the unsecured creditors committee. Importantly, the bulk of these incentive programs benefit more than 700 employees across the company and are performance-based. We believe our 2009 incentive program is both moderate and reasonable."

Four of Tribune Co.'s unions, meanwhile, lodged their own objections to the plans. The Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild, which sits on the unsecured creditors committee in Tribune Co.'s case and represents employees at The Sun, Tribune Co.'s daily in Baltimore, filed an objection which was joined by local units of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters in Baltimore, the Communications Workers of America and International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers in New York.

"At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," the union filing said.

"While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."

The unions question whether the goals set by the bonus plans are challenging enough and whether the awards can be considered "ordinary course" payments. They also contend that that Tribune Co. has provided no evidence that there is a causal link between the requested payments and the continued operation of the business.

"The (bonus plan) is not designed to drive employee performance toward challenging goals which are subject to the risks of the marketplace," the filing said. "Rather the (plan) is designed to reward insiders for remaining in the Debtors' employ through the end of the (plan) period.

Tribune Co., which filed for Chapter 11 protection last December because it was struggling to manage the heavy debt it took on in going private a year earlier, has said that the bonus payments are needed to motivate managers working under difficult conditions. They will only be paid in full if the company well exceeds performance targets.

mdoneal@tribune.com

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

Setting the Health Reform Record Straight

Many Americans are concerned that health care reform could be detrimental to their health benefits based on a great deal of erroneous information.

Congresswoman Lowey has compiled answers to the most frequent myths she has heard from constituents at Neighborhood Office Hours, during telephone town halls and roundtables, and via phone calls and emails to her office.

If you are worried about one of the myths listed below, please click on it to see what the House proposal for health care would do to address your concern.

MYTH: Health insurance reform would socialize medicine.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will increase the deficit.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will result in higher taxes for middle-class families.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will result in “rationing” medical treatment.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will force you to change your insurance.

MYTH: Health insurance reform means fewer choices for Americans.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will force Americans to buy insurance they can’t afford.

MYTH: Health insurance reform will force businesses to cut jobs by charging them increased taxes.

MYTH: Medicare benefits will be cut or eliminated entirely.

MYTH: Members of Congress are creating lousy public insurance for the rest of Americans while they will continue to have superior care.

MYTH: Members of Congress have not read the health care bill.

MYTH: The bill will provide coverage for illegal aliens.

MYTH: The bill requires that everyone covered by Medicare be visited by an “end of life council” to determine if they can still receive benefits for a terminal illness.

MYTH: The bill doesn’t do anything to address the pressing need for long-term care.

MYTH: Congress is eliminating Medicare Advantage plans to pay for health care.

MYTH: Congress is wrongly focusing on health care instead of the more immediate and serious economic crisis.

MYTH: The bill provides funding for abortions.

MYTH: The proposal will limit pay for doctors.

MYTH: Employees who receive employer-provided health benefits will be forced to enroll in the public insurance plan.

68 to lose jobs in KGMB, KHNL, K5 merger; programming will be retained

By Rick Daysog
http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com

The owners of KGMB9, KHNL and K5 television stations will eliminate 68 jobs, or more than a third of their staff, as they merge their operations.

Alabama-based Raycom Media, owner of KHNL and K5, said today that they plan to combine its newsrooms with that of KGMB, creating the state's largest television news department.

Ownership at none of the stations will change and programming currently running on three stations will largely be retained. Some of the news programming will be simulcast on KHNL and KGMB.
KGMB is owned by MCG Capital Corp.

Paul McTear, president and CEO of Raycom, said the deal will help preserve the news operations of three television stations that have been hard-hit by the downturn in the advertising market. He noted that annual television ad revenues will be down by about $20 million, or about 30 percent, from three years ago.

"Rather than experiencing the loss of one, or possibly two stations in Hawaii, we intend to preserve three stations that provide important and valuable local, national and international programming to viewers in Hawaii," McTear said.

McTear declined to provide estimates on job losses but KGMB's Web site noted that out of the three stations' 198 employees, about 130 will become part of the new combined organization.

Staffers at KGMB said the newsroom staff was told they will all be officially laid off on Oct. 18, and those selected to stay will be rehired.
Raycom Media is one the nation's largest broadcasters and owns and operates 46 television stations in 36 markets. MCG Capital is a private equity fund.

The deal is expected to close in 60 days. During that period, management will interview staffers for positions at the combined newsroom.
-----
Here is the press release that went out at 11 this morning.

HONOLULU — Raycom Media, owner of KHNL and K5, and MCG Capital Corporation, owner of KGMB, announced today a Shared Services Agreement which, upon completion, the two companies would combine the three stations to creatively and successfully address the impact of the negative economy and to secure the future of all three television stations in Hawaii.

"The purpose of a Shared Services Agreement is to not only secure the future of KHNL, K5 and KGMB, but to operate them more efficiently and effectively without diminishing the quality of news and other programming provided to our customers in Hawaii,"said Paul McTear, President and CEO of Raycom Media.

"We realize there may be other financial and business options available, and while we are certainly open to discussing these with any interested party, the economic reality is that this market cannot support five traditionally separated television stations, all with duplicated costs. Rather than experiencing the loss of one, or possibly two stations in Hawaii, we intend to preserve three stations that provide important and valuable local, national and international programming to viewers in Hawaii."

Under the agreement, Raycom Media would provide certain services to all three stations. The agreement is an operational arrangement, not an ownership change agreement. Raycom Media retains ownership of KHNL/K5 and MCG Capital Corporation retains ownership of KGMB.

"Companies that think and act far more creatively to protect their businesses and employees in this economy are the ones that are going to weather the storm and emerge stronger," said McTear. "Raycom Media is proud of its long relationship with Hawaii, and with the University of Hawaii, and we are excited that an agreement would allow us to, not only continue to serve the islands, but to serve residents in even more and better ways."

Raycom Media's KFVE, or "K5," produces and broadcasts well over 100 live sports events each year for the University of Hawaii.

The Shared Services Agreement creates what would be the largest local television news operation available to cover local, national and international news for Hawaii. The KGMB, KHNL, K5 newsroom and all those working there plan to produce more than 40 hours of local news each week, making it among the most productive newsrooms in the country. The stations will also continue to provide local web sites rich in news, weather, sports, entertainment, business, advertising and other content of community interest.

"Such an agreement allows the three stations to field the largest number of news professionals, particularly during times of major breaking news or severe weather, providing better coverage of stories impacting the lives of everyone who lives on the islands, and produced on multiple platforms – television, internet and on mobile devices." added McTear.

"Given the challenges of operating a standalone station in these very difficult markets, MCG views the Shared Services Agreement as a smart and creative way to manage its continuing ownership investment in KGMB," said Rick Blangiardi, President and General Manager of KGMB and MCG Capital's representative in Hawaii.

"We are very proud of our employees and the work that they do. Under a new agreement, KGMB, and the people who work there, will benefit from the scale and diversity which comes from a company like Raycom Media, recognized as a company that will be an integral part of the broadcast industry for years to come."

Under a Shared Services Agreement, the three stations will share in the news services as well as other combined services. It's anticipated that, once the two companies swap call letters, the national networks and other programming, along with the accompanying channel positions of each of the three stations, will remain the same.

Raycom Media, an employee-owned company, is one of the nation's largest broadcasters and owns and operates 46 television stations in 36 markets and 18 states, including Hawaii. In addition to television stations, Raycom owns Raycom Sports, a marketing, production and events management and distribution company; Raycom Post, a post production facility; Broadview Media, a post production telecommunications company; and CableVantage, a cable advertising sales group.

MCG Capital Corporation is a solutions-focused commercial finance company providing capital and advisory services to middle-market companies throughout the United States. Our investment objective is to achieve current income and capital gains. Our capital is generally used by our portfolio companies to finance acquisitions, recapitalizations, buyouts, organic growth and working capital. For more information, please visit www.mcgcapital.com.

Reach Rick Daysog at rdaysog@honoluluadvertiser.com.

Report: Tribune Employees To Get Shortchanged

Los Angeles Business from bizjournals

Creditors who seek to oust Tribune CEO Sam Zell probably won’t keep the employee stock ownership plan -- a move that will leave employees with worthless shares, the New York Post reports Wednesday.

The Post cites a source involved in creditor negotiations.

In 2007, Zell used the stock plan to gain tax benefits on the $8.2 billion Tribune buyout.

Under the plan, workers have 100 percent ownership of the company but no say on management or the board. Bankruptcy views them as shareholders.

On Tuesday, the Post reported that Tribune is giving up on an attempt to buy a large stake in the company. A report surfaced Friday that the real estate tycoon could be ousted as part of reorganization plan put forth by creditors.

Tribune, which Zell privatized in 2007, operates newspapers and TV stations including the Los Angeles Times, Chicao Tribune, KTLA, WPIX, and WGN.

Tribune entered bankruptcy protection in December.

Friday’s report says that the creditors Zell owes payments to plan to stage a takeover of their own and sell off the company's newspapers and broadcast stations as they see fit.

Zell owes these creditors $8.6 billion, and those creditors are reportedly becoming impatient with him. But the creditors must wait until Nov. 30 before they can file a plan since Zell was granted an extension on his own Tribune reorganization. That extension was granted on Aug. 10.

Reports came out in June that stated Zell would lose Tribune to the same group of investors.

That report stated that "the plan centers on a debt-for-equity swap that probably would give the senior lenders a large majority ownership stake in the reorganized company.
_______________

Reports: IRS Auditing Tribune ESOP

The Internal Revenue Service is auditing the Employee Stock Ownership Plan that was a key component of Sam Zell's purchase of the Tribune Co., according to media reports.

Under Tribune's ESOP, workers have 100 percent ownership of the company but no say on management or the board.

According to the reports, an IRS agent in Wisconsin is looking at the ESOP's $250 million purchase of new shares issued by Tribune. The question regarding the purchase is whether or not the purchase would be considered to the benefit of Tribune employees.

Should the purchase be considered to be of benefit, it would be classified as tax exempt. If not, Tribune would potentially have to pay corporate income taxes and excise taxes, the reports say.

The IRS agent filed a statement regarding the investigation with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, the reports say. Tribune is currently under Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.

__________________________

Former Tribune Exec Dennis FitzSimons Joins Media General Board

Media General Inc., the parent company of The Tampa Tribune and WFLA-Channel 8, has expanded its board of directors to 10 members to make room for its newest member: former Chicago Tribune executive Dennis FitzSimons.

“Dennis FitzSimons is a proven and innovative business leader who led a premier media company through times of outstanding growth and tough challenges,” said Marshall N. Morton, Media General’s president and chief executive officer, in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. “His industry knowledge and experience with the changing media landscape and the synergies of print, broadcast and online platforms will bring a valuable perspective to the Media General board’s deliberations.”

FitzSimons was the chairman, chief executive officer and president of Tribune Co. until December 2007 after completing the sale of the company to Sam Zell for $8.2 billion, ending a 25-year relationship with the company. FitzSimons is said to have earned $41 million in that deal.

Getting his start in the company’s broadcast division, FitzSimons was named an executive vice president at Tribune in January 2000 and earned an election to Tribune’s board of directors that same year, according to the SEC filing. He would become president and chief operating officer in July 2001 and then elevated to chief executive officer in January 2003.

Tribune Co. filed for bankruptcy in December 2008, caused mostly by the media company’s efforts to go private a year earlier.

Outside directors to the Media General board receive an annual retainer of $116,000 for all scheduled meetings as well as an additional $1,750 for each unscheduled board meeting and each committee meeting attended beyond the two included in the retainer, according to SEC filings. Half of that compensation is issued in deferred Class A stock, and each director can elect to receive the other half either in cash, deferred stock units, or split evenly in cash and deferred stock.

Media General (NYSE: MEG) reported a loss of $21.3 million, or 96 cents per share, in the most recent quarter ended March 29, deeper than a $20.3 million, or 92 cents per share loss, the year before. Revenue fell from $194.5 million in the first quarter of 2008 to $159.5 million in the most recent quarter.

Media General shares were trading at $2.06 just after 4 p.m. Wednesday, up more than 7 percent from their previous-day close of $1.92. The media company’s shares have traded between $1.25 and $27.18 over the past year.

Tribune Creditors Seek Probe Of Zell Buyout

BY DAVID ROEDER
droeder@suntimes.com

Firm would be hired to take closer look at ESOP, which U.S. already is investigating

Tribune Co. creditors are turning up the heat on Sam Zell by threatening an investigation of the leveraged buyout he used to take over the company.

The creditors asked the federal bankruptcy court for authority to hire an outside law firm to probe Zell's $8.2 billion deal. Zell took on debt to fund the takeover of what had been a publicly traded company, but the worst market for advertising since the recession forced the media conglomerate into bankruptcy last December.

To avoid taxes, Zell established an employee stock ownership plan that owns Tribune. The ESOP has no seat on Tribune's board and Zell controls the company because he put up $315 million for an option to buy 40 percent of it.

The creditors want to hire the firm Zuckerman Spaeder LLP to review the ESOP. The filing said the request comes from seven of the nine members on the creditors' committee.

The two members not involved are JPMorgan Chase Bank and Merrill Lynch Capital Corp., whose corporate affiliates helped finance the deal. A hearing on the request was scheduled for Sept. 4.

The U.S. Labor Department and the IRS already are investigating the takeover of Tribune, specifically the ESOP.

Tribune Co. forwarded a statement that said, "We have been fully cooperating with the review of our 2007 going-private transaction by the unsecured creditors' committee."

An attorney for the creditors declined to comment.

Last week, the Sun-Times reported that creditors are working on a Tribune reorganization that will push Zell out of management. If that occurs, owners of Tribune's nearly $13 billion in debt could attempt to break up the company.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

TV's Doomsday Scenario -- and How to Stop It

Part 2 of a Wrap series: "Is TV, as We Know It, Finished?"

The language is stark, the message is unmistakable: The future is looking bleak for network TV.

That's the verdict from Time magazine, which paints a bleak picture of what's to come for the big boys of broadcasting.

"In network television, nothing adds up," according to the newsweekly. "The networks are still scrapping with one another for ratings supremacy, but the days when they dominated the airwaves so thoroughly are just a 'Wonder Years' memory. (The) companies that have virtually defined American television...are sick and fighting for survival."

"As the network audience dwindles," Time continues, "one of the Big Three may be forced to close down or sharply curtail its operations."

Scary stuff.

One caveat, though: Time's harsh warning about the state of network TV was written back in October ... of 1988.

Twenty years later, the Big Three have become the Big Four (plus the CW). Advertisers still pay a major premium to sell their wares on broadcast TV. And experts of various stripes are still forecasting the end of network television as we know it.

Take Bob Garfield, the longtime editor at large for Ad Age and co-host of NPR's "On the Media." He's just published "The Chaos Scenario," a dark tome that offers little good news for anyone invested in the current ad-supported model of free, over-the-air TV.

"Without being overly simplistic or melodramatic, the state of the Old Commercial Broadcasting Model can be summarized as follows: a spiraling vortex of ruin," Garfield writes.

In an interview with TheWrap, Garfield doesn't back down from his harsh -- some would call it Chicken Little-esque -- assessment of commercial TV's future.

"These forces are all converging," Garfield says of the factors leading to the end of ad-supported TV as we've known it. "The handwriting had been on the wall and then the recession came along to accelerate the path to demise."

As Garfield sees it, advertisers have already started paring back their TV ad buys, in part out of frustration that -- until this year at least -- networks seemed magically able to foist higher ad rates on buyers, even as their share of the viewing audience continued to decline.

As overall ad revenues fall, and backend profits for even successful shows become less predictable, networks will inevitably begin paring back their spending on first-run, high-quality scripted fare.

"Audiences are fragmenting so much that soon there will be no critical mass" against which to sell substantial ad dollars, Garfield argues.

Lower ratings will cause even steeper declines in ad revenue (with a few exceptions, advertisers generally don't value reality shows as much as scripted series, so a scheduled filled with "The Biggest Loser" isn't an answer).

That cash crunch will force networks to take fewer chances on developing hits.

"The upfronts have always given the networks the cash they need, upfront, to shoot 13 or 22 episodes of a show," Garfield says.

"That upfront cash won't exist as much anymore.... The pool of production dollars is going to dry up. And it's expensive to get money (for financing projects). So where does the new high quality stuff come from? I don't know."

One possible solution, of course, could be for broadcasters to move toward a cable model -- abandoning their affiliates and owned stations in favor of subscriber fees. NBC Universal chief Jeff Zucker has hinted such a notion might one day be appealing for NBC.

But as Garfield notes, the cable model isn't perfect, either.

"Cable is no more insulated from chaos than anyone else," he says. "The very coaxial they've spent 50 years stringing is now the pipe for broadband that can distribute the very same programming for no fees and with less advertising."

Another possibility would be for networks to find a way to get consumers to subscribe to a service that let them watch their content online, with limited commercials, any time they want. The question, of course, is whether consumers would fork over any cash at all given how easy it is to find TV content online for free.

"It's damn near in our DNA not to have to pay for content," Garfield says.

Garfield offers some hope for TV types with his concession that "demand for high-quality scripted content remains at an all-time high."

He also suggests that the democratization of distribution -- namely, the fact that YouTube has eliminated barriers of entry for aspiring writers and actors looking to break through-- might yet be a good thing for media companies.

"The vast aggregated genius of the world" could eventually turn into a lower-cost pool for developing new hits, Garfield theorizes.

Garfield concedes that many folks consider him to be something of a Cassandra. In his book, he even quotes big names such as Bill Gates and YouTube's Chad Hurley dismissing his theories.

And as the Time article from 1988 makes clear, predicting gloom and doom for network TV is a tricky proposition. As ratings for "American Idol" and "CSI" demonstrate, network TV still has an amazing ability to lure viewers in relatively big numbers -- DVRs and YouTube be damned.

Still, in the end, Garfield says there's simply no getting around the fact that Madison Ave. types are increasingly convinced that it's foolish to continue spending billions of dollars on advertisers in order to reach fewer and fewer eyeballs. As ad money slips away from networks' coffers, massive change will be unavoidable.

"The status quo has been fantastic," Garfield says of ad-supported media. "But it turns out it was an accident of history. It happened, it was great for 350 years-- and now the digital revolution has rendered it unworkable.

"There is no solution for the networks, just as there was no solution for cobblers in the 1800s."

Compensable weight loss surgery? A new wrinkle in obesity

Posted by Julie Ferguson
http://www.workerscompinsider.com

Yesterday, my colleague blogged about employers that refuse to hire smokers and cited another employer who would like to extend that ban to obese applicants.

Health-related matters and their associated costs are challenging for employers and we expect they will continue to be played out in the courts. In fact, yesterday, Roberto Ceniceros blogged about a surprise ruling by the Indiana Court of Appeals about weight loss surgery related to a workers comp claim ... or at least the ruling was a surprise to us.

In Boston's Gourmet Pizza v. Adam Childers, the court determined that the employer must pay for weight-reduction surgery for Childers as a precursor to treating the work-related back injury. The employer must provide temporary total disability benefits while the employee prepares for, and recovers from, the weight-loss surgery.

The subsequent treatment path for the back injury is unclear, various treatments have been under consideration but the employer's weight was deemed a barrier to any success.

In 2007, the then 25-year-old Adam Childers sustained a back injury after being struck in the back by a freezer door while serving as a cook for his employer. At the time, he weighed 340 pounds and smoked about a pack and a half of cigarettes a day.

Because of his weight, his physician advised against any nuerosurgery, but Childers' back pain persisted and other treatments did not provide relief. Over the course of this treatment, his weight increased to 380 pounds.

His physician suggested lap band or gastric bypass surgery to get his weight down, both to relieve his symptoms and to improve his suitability for potential surgical treatments, such as spinal fusion.

The employer balked at footing the bill for weight loss surgery. While the employer assumed responsibility in providing treatment for Childer's work-related injury, they contested the idea that they should have any responsibility for providing secondary medical treatment for a preexisting condition. However, in Indiana, a preexisting condition is not a bar to benefits, a matter that the courts have taken up in several prior cases.

Ceniceros sums up it ups this way: But the court agreed with a Worker's Compensation Board finding that the worker's pre-existing medical and health condition combined with the accident to create a single injury for which he is entitled to work comp benefits.

We've posted many times about the high-cost of obesity and diabetes in the workplace, and how comorbidities can add to the cost of workers comp injuries.

We've also blogged about employers' increasingly aggressive efforts to target so-called lifestyle issues that impact health. Decisions like this might heighten employers' resolve to control obesity - but in that regard, they may find themselves between a rock and a hard place.

Workers Comp Insider

Lynch Ryan's weblog about workers' compensation, risk management, business insurance, workplace health & safety, occupational medicine, injured workers, insurance webtools & technology and related topics

Zuckerman Wants In on Tribune Bankruptcy

Posted by Zach Lowe
http://amlawdaily.typepad.com/

There's an interesting new development in the Tribune Co. bankruptcy case: The creditors committee, before now represented solely by Chadbourne & Parke, filed papers late last week requesting permission to add Zuckerman Spaeder as special counsel.

The reason? The committee wants to investigate possible causes of action against firms that helped arrange the $8.2 billion leveraged buyout in which Chicago billionaire Sam Zell took the company private in 2007.

Some of those firms are members of the creditors committee, which means this latest development could lead to fellow credit committee members suing each other--creating the need for additional counsel.

The maneuver to take the Tribune private failed in part because the company took on too much debt in the transaction, which ended with an employee stock ownership plan as Tribune's majority owner, according to this piece in the Chicago Tribune. The company filed for bankruptcy a year later (with Sidley Austin as primary counsel).

Two creditors committee members--JPMorgan Chase and Merrill Lynch Capital Corp.--participated in the financing of the leveraged buyout. The other members of the committee asked Chadbourne earlier this year to investigate filing suit against any company that helped arrange the buyout, but the firm declined, citing a conflict of interest.

Chadbourne told the committee it could "investigate and conduct settlement negotiations with the lenders" in the buyout, but that the firm "would be unable because of conflicts to bring claims against certain of such lenders," according to Zuckerman's filing to become special counsel.
Junior creditors in the Tribune case are planning to argue they should get paid before senior creditors, because some of those senior lenders financed the 2007 buyout--and presumably reaped big fees from their role in the transaction, the New York Post is reporting.

Howard Seife, chair of Chadbourne's bankruptcy department, did not immediately return a call seeking comment. Thomas Macauley, a Zuckerman partner who submitted an affidavit with his firm's application to join the case, also did not respond to a message seeking comment.

If retained, Zuckerman's partners and counsel will charge between $475 and $825 per hour, and associates will bill between $300 and $500 an hour.

Though the circumstances are slightly different, you might recall that small creditors in the General Motors bankruptcy case asked a federal judge for permission to form their own committee alleging that the official creditors committee wasn't adequately representing their interests. Judge Robert Gerber denied that request, in part because the debtor--GM's estate--would have been required to pay the committee's legal fees.

Presumably, that would also be the case in the Tribune bankruptcy.
Several bankruptcy experts told the Tribune that it's not unusual for creditors in a bankruptcy to challenge a leveraged buyout as a "fraudulent conveyance" of wealth to those who advised on it--including lawyers--if the buyout fatally damaged a company's solvency.

ZELL PREPARES TO ABANDON ILL-FATED TRIBUNE INVESTMENT

By JOSH KOSMAN
http://www.nypost.com/

So much for Sam Zell, newspaperman.

The developer, who arranged a controversial $11.7 billion employee buyout of newspaper giant Tribune only to see the company careen into bankruptcy a year later, is on the verge of giving up his claims to buy a huge stake in the company and, according to a source familiar with the matter, is ready to walk away from the company.

As the employees who own the company see the value of their stake evaporate, sources said Zell himself appears to be ready to give up a warrant that gives him the right to buy 40 percent of the company for $500 million without being compensated.

Zell had raised eyebrows in late 2007 when he used a tax-exempt employee stock option plan, or ESOP, to finance Tribune's purchase. It meant Zell had little skin in the game, while the company's employees were left holding the bag.

Now that Tribune is in bankruptcy, the ESOP's value will be further diminished as creditors hold $8.6 billion in debt that will likely be settled up first.

Said a Tribune spokesman, "No agreements have been reached to date. Sam, as well as the rest of the management team, remain actively engaged and committed to Tribune.

"The restructuring is still in progress and it is premature to speculate about the company's final ownership structure."

Meanwhile, some of Tribune's junior lenders are maneuvering to get paid before senior creditors do, arguing that the latter's financing role caused the company to become immediately insolvent as a result of the deal.

The junior creditors hired law firm Zuckerman Spaeder to determine whether they have a claim to fees that the banks involved in the buyout -- Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase and Merrill Lynch -- were paid for their services.

The idea would be for the junior creditors to leapfrog ahead of them in the capital structure in order to be paid back first, a source said.

Zuckerman Spaeder prevailed once before in a similar case in which it helped creditors reach an undisclosed settlement with Bain Capital over its buyout and dividend of KB Toys, which helped drive the retailer into bankruptcy.

josh.kosman@nypost.com
Subscribe to the Electronic Edition and get the New York Post exactly as it appears in print.

Losing Job, Consumer Columnist Cries Foul

By STEPHANIE CLIFFORD
The New York Times

The Hartford Courant and its former consumer columnist, George Gombossy, agree on one thing: that Mr. Gombossy was laid off this month. But was it because he would not stop unfavorable articles about advertisers, or because his job was simply eliminated?

The disagreement addresses a delicate area in journalism. As ad revenue drops, publishing executives are willing to go far to keep advertisers happy, running front-page ads and ads that look like news articles. Mr. Gombossy is claiming that Courant executives, under pressure from advertisers, did not want him to write critical reports about them, and fired him when he would not change his stance.

But Courant executives say that their reporters are welcome to write about advertisers, and that the separation between advertising and editorial content still stands. Mr. Gombossy’s complaints are just those of a “disgruntled employee,” Richard Graziano, the paper’s publisher, said on a voicemail message.

The argument comes at a time of upheaval for The Courant. It is owned by the Tribune Company, which filed for bankruptcy protection in December. The Courant laid off 100 employees in February as part of continued staff reductions.

In the spring, the Tribune Company merged operations of its Hartford television properties and The Courant. It replaced the paper’s publisher with Mr. Graziano, a Tribune television executive, and installed Jeff Levine as senior vice president and director of content, overseeing editorial operations. The paper’s top two editors, longtime employees, departed soon after Mr. Levine joined, and Naedine Hazell became editor and print platform manager.

The new bosses meant new rules, Mr. Gombossy said. He had been at The Courant for 40 years, and became the investigative consumer columnist three years ago, writing a watchdog column where he resolved complaints of readers and looked into unfair practices at companies.

A few months ago, Mr. Gombossy said, he was called into a meeting with Courant executives. He had written columns about a Connecticut contracting company that was also a Courant advertiser. Mr. Levine said that he had received a letter from the contractor about the columns, and asked Mr. Gombossy to meet with the company and to “be nice to them” because an advertising deal was at risk, Mr. Gombossy said.

“At that point, I told them I’m refusing and I said, ‘You’ve got to fire me if you insist on me doing that,’ ” Mr. Gombossy said. According to him, Mr. Levine then backpedaled on the demand to meet with the advertiser, but said that he could not write about a major advertiser unless it was cleared by Mr. Levine.

Ms. Hazell, who also attended the meeting, had a different recollection. “We said we wanted to go to more helpful news, and less gotcha news,” she said.

When Mr. Gombossy asked for an example, she pointed to his articles about the contracting company, which had asked to speak with him. “Would he be willing to at least talk to them, and could he be nice in a conversation like that?” she recalled saying.

He said no. “It was a very broad conversation about overall tone, and we said, would you be willing to talk to people” — that is, companies he was investigating — “about their complaints.” She said there was no mandate that he get clearance from editors to write about advertisers.

Mr. Gombossy said he had another run-in with the executives after posting a reader comment on his blog about a grocery chain that was a large advertiser. “This time, I was told that the publisher was furious with me and they’re thinking about firing me, and by running that blog I had caused the possible loss of a $100,000 advertising contract,” Mr. Gombossy said in a telephone interview.

He was told, he said, that he could not post blog comments critical of big advertisers, in addition to not writing about them without approval by an editor.

Ms. Hazell’s account is different. The meeting was about blog comments that were “fairly inflammatory and in some cases libelous,” she said. “We never said he had to get clearance to write about an advertiser,” she said. But she did alert him to an agreement between the advertising and news sides that her predecessor had agreed to, and that she would be adhering to.

“If there was going to be a story in the newspaper about a major advertiser, the advertiser would get a heads-up. They wouldn’t know the tenor of the story,” she said. Mr. Gombossy then requested a list of major advertisers, which the executives supplied.

One of the advertisers on the list, Mr. Gombossy said, was the mattress company Sleepy’s. Mr. Gombossy had been looking into consumer complaints about the company, and had prepared a column to be printed on Aug. 2. That column said that the Connecticut attorney general was investigating the company, a fact the attorney general, Richard Blumenthal, confirmed in an interview last week.

Mr. Gombossy said he had the column approved by his editor. But the article did not run, and on Aug. 3, he said, he was called into the office. “I was told that my position was being eliminated, and they were going to have a different kind of consumer columnist,” he said. He said his performance reviews had always been strong. “They had no intention of laying me off until this happened.”

Ms. Hazell said the Sleepy’s column was held, not killed. “George could have written about Sleepy’s,” she said. “We’ve never had and never will have a policy to favor advertisers in any form,” she said. “Our concerns had largely to do with sourcing.” In fact, she said, Mr. Gombossy’s final column, which ran on Sunday, was about an advertiser, Connecticut Light & Power.

Mr. Gombossy was laid off because he was not interested in a different position, which would focus on consumer complaints and not investigative work, Ms. Hazell said. “My understanding is that he just wasn’t interested in the direction we were going,” she said.

Mr. Gombossy said he plans to file a lawsuit against The Courant. He has started a Web site, ctwatchdog.com, where he has posted the column about Sleepy’s. Ms. Hazell said the posting was slightly different from the last version she saw.

Mr. Blumenthal, who often worked with Mr. Gombossy, said that he did not know what had happened between the columnist and The Courant, but that his departure was a “huge, gaping loss for consumers.”
“He is one of a kind,” Mr. Blumenthal said.

WashPost Interns Make $44k Yearly; Or $2k More Than Web Producers

Posted by Rachel Kaufman
http://www.mediabistro.com/mediajobsdaily/

The Washington City Paper reports that the WashPost guild has been busy negotiating salary for Web reporters. As the company completes its newsroom merger of print and web, the Web employees—which have gone a decade without union representation—are coming under the umbrella of the NABET-CWA Newspaper Guild.

But it's not that smooth, of course: Post management has proposed that the web producers start at $40,000.

Newsroom interns earn $44,416 yearly.

A Newspaper Guild statement explains all the duties a Web producer may be expected to handle:

Producers are expected to, among other things, update and maintain editorial content; assist in developing and producing monthly feature packages and tools; create new content for the website, including live streams of breaking news events and updating existing content; work with web publishing systems; and gather, write and edit news stories for text, photographic and video presentation.

Producers are also expected to stay abreast of breaking news and help mobilize coverage where necessary; seek to enhance online pages with photographs, multimedia and other tools; and think creatively about element highlights.

The Newspaper Guild says it's negotiated producers' starting pay up to $42k, but that's still less than a (print) intern.

It also says that the Grey Lady agreed to salary equity between web and print, which may be a bad move: why would "If your biggest competitor is doing it, you should too" be a convincing argument?

The City Paper notes that the Newspaper Guild has pledged to "strive for salary equity at The Post for as long as it takes."

Monday, August 17, 2009

Television -- As We Know It -- Is Finished

By Josef Adalian
http://www.thewrap.com/

"It's the beginning of a structural tailspin. The total collapse of the model."

Network TV may be a cyclical business -- but for bruised and battered broadcasters battling the worst economy in a generation, there's little evidence to suggest a bounce back is in the cards anytime soon.

If anything, things could get a lot worse before they get better. Some observers are even beginning to question whether there will ever be a turnaround, predicting that business model which has sustained broadcasters for close to 60 years has begun an irreversible decline.

The latest blow: A disastrous upfront advertising market that saw revenues plunge an estimated 15 percent from last year, dropping from $9.2 billion in 2008 to around $7.8 billion, according to estimates by several publications.

This is a turning point," argues Bob Garfield, author of the just-released media doomsday tome "The Chaos Scenario" and the long-time critic for Advertising Age.

He believes networks will continue to bleed ad dollars, which will lead them to reduce original scripted programming, thus causing deeper ratings declines.... and even further drops in ad revenue.

"It's the beginning of a structural tailspin... the total collapse of the network television model," Garfield predicts.

In fact, Garfield -- echoing the feelings of multiple industry leaders interviewed for this article, most of whom spoke only on the condition of anonymity -- believes the current network landscape will look dramatically different by the middle of the next decade.

"I don't think we'll have four networks five years from now," he said. "One of the networks will drop out, maybe two."

If there's any silver lining in all this doom and gloom, it's that broadcasters aren't completely burying their heads in the sand and ignoring the looming crisis.

While their public pronouncements remain largely upbeat, their actions over the past months indicate they realize massive change is a must if they have any hope of proving the Bob Garfields of the world wrong.

The shifts range from draconian belt-tightening to stepped efforts to create -- or at least consider -- new revenue streams for network programming outside of advertising.

On the cost side of the equation, networks are playing hardball with studios when it comes to license fees for veteran shows.

Witness NBC's decision to walk away from "Medium" and "My Name is Earl" last spring rather than meet the fiscal demands of CBS Television Studios and 20th Century Fox TV, respectively. Or Fox's up-to-the-brink talks with 20th on "Bones," a successful drama which nonetheless almost proved too rich for the network's blood.

In years past, networks tried to get tough on costs but were stymied because there always seemed to be another buyer willing to spend "crazy money" for a series, pilot or piece of talent.

But now, "The 'idiots with money' don't exist," said one senior network executive.
The same sense of realism holds in the actor, writer and producer markets.

Overall deals with writers, for example, have become all but extinct.

Case in point: the creator of one of TV's most successful franchises -- Anthony Zuiker of "CSI" -- recently saw his lucrative overall deal with CBS Television Studios replaced with a more modest first-look agreement.

Networks are also slashing writing staffs on shows, forcing producers to buy more freelance scripts or have their existing staffs crank out more episodes.

It's a return to how TV operated 20 or 30 years ago, when many top dramas and comedies boasted staffs of four or five scribes, rather than the dozen-plus members that had become commonplace.

Meanwhile, the little excesses once accepted as part of doing business in the land of show are no longer being tolerated. Even that most basic of Hollywood rights-- extravagant catering-- has been targeted.

Consider what happened when one TV executive walked on to the set of a pilot last spring.

"It was the most amazing spread I had ever seen," she recalls. "I called over the producer and said, 'You can't have this anymore.' They understood."

It's not just talent that's being asked to rein in costs. Earlier this month, a network publicity department sent a memo to all of its executives asking them not to eat any of the food served to reporters at the network's portion of the TV Critics Assn. press tour.

Another conglomerate is closing in on its goal of eliminating the hugely expensive practice of burning hundreds of DVD copies of screeners-- not just for critics, but for their own executives. Instead, this company is using technology to let execs stream both dailies and full episodes on whatever platform works best for them, including their home plasma sets.
"Every penny is being looked at," another top network chief says, noting complaints about the cutbacks are far fewer than you'd expect.

"We're losing salaries and we're losing people. If you can't get free sodas, I think people will survive," she says. "Everybody recognizes we have to do this to maintain the health of the business."

That's one reason talent in new shows doesn't tend to gripe when told the pilot they shot in Los Angeles will now be a series produced in Connecticut or Canada or one of the other locales that offer super-attractive tax deals to lure production.

And producers who stay in Los Angeles aren't bitching when they get a memo from the studio asking them to use a green screen instead of scheduling a location shoot.

"When you leave the studio, your cost goes up $35,000 to $75,000 per day," one studio executive says. "We're encouraging shows to put more investment into art direction...and visual effects."

The new fiscal discipline is particularly apparent on new shows, where studios are taking advantage of the current climate to establish miserly habits early on, since it's much harder to cut spending once a show is established.

Despite all this penny-pinching, network suits are well aware that reducing costs is simply a way of slowing the bleeding.

"Cost-cutting isn't going to cure our ills," one network boss says.

"At a certain point, you can't cut any more. There has to be a change in the business models."

For a time, network executives thought the answer was getting cable companies to pony up cash for their programming, they way they do for CNN and ESPN. But increasingly, networks are beginning to ponder the notion of a subscription model for their programming.

CBS research chief David Poltrack earlier this month outlined a scenario under which networks would bring in big bucks by getting consumers to pay to watch their shows online-- not directly, but via charges levied by their broadband supplier.

He even talked up the Christmas 2010 arrival of TV sets that will easily allow consumers to watch broadband video on their 52-inch LCDs.

"If the broadcast networks can establish online video as a preferred form of nonlinear television distribution... then (they) can develop the second revenue streamthat has to date eluded them," Poltrack said.

Networks are also realizing that they simply can't afford to produce anywhere near the once-standard 22 hours of original scripted programming.

Fox has always existed as 15-hour a week network which most weeks programs less than a dozen hours of scripted fare.

Now, NBC has taken the much-criticized step of replacing costly 10 p.m. dramas with "The Jay Leno Show," a nightly comedy hour that will cost about 1/5th the pricetag for five hours of first-run dramas.

While many are predicting long-term failure for the scheme, others think the Peacock is smart for conceding the fact that it no longer had the financial (or creative) firepower to keep churning out one scripted drama flop after another.

Garfield believes NBC's move is just the beginning of an even more significant shift away from scripted hours.

"Get used to no new episodes of 'Lost' and '24,' and seeing Jay Leno eight days a week," he says. "The number of scripted sitcoms and dramas will continue to diminish. And the number of episodes of 'Dancing with the Stars' and 'The Biggest Loser' will increase."

Tribune Co. creditors seek special counsel to probe buyout, could sue to recover money

By Ameet Sachdev
Tribune reporter

Tribune Co. creditors have asked the bankruptcy court for permission to hire special counsel to further investigate the $8.2 billion leveraged buyout of the Chicago-based media company engineered by real estate magnate Sam Zell.

The inquiry is common practice when a bankruptcy follows closely on the heels of an LBO, said bankruptcy experts. Zell closed the transaction that took Tribune Co. private in December 2007.

The new debt obligations were too big a burden amid rapidly declining advertising revenues, sending the company, parent of the Chicago Tribune, into bankruptcy in December 2008.

Creditors have not filed a lawsuit seeking to recover money against parties that were involved in the going-private transaction, which established an employee stock ownership plan to become majority owner of the company.

But the court filing on Thursday signaled that they are considering pursuing litigation, said Chicago-based restructuring expert Bill Brandt.With creditors likely to collect only a small percentage of their debts, "it is an absolute certainty that creditors look to the realm of lawsuits to try and get more money out," Brandt added.

There is precedent for challenging LBOs in bankruptcy court on grounds of "fraudulent conveyance." Such suits argue that LBOs have left companies with too much debt to operate and benefited former executives, bankers, lawyers and financial advisers at the creditors' expense. There's usually not a question of fraud with the buyout, but rather the issue of whether the transaction was commercially reasonable.

Creditors have a big burden of proof, said Douglas Baird, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School who specializes in bankruptcy issues."You have to make sure you're not just a Monday morning quarterback," Baird said.

Howard Seife, an attorney at New York-based Chadbourne & Parke who represents the creditors committee, did not return a phone call seeking comment on the committee's request to hire special counsel.

The need for special counsel arose because Chadbourne, citing conflicts of interest, would not be able to investigate or bring lawsuits against certain parties in the LBO, court papers said.

The committee selected the Washington-based law firm of Zuckerman Spaeder as special counsel. Two members of the committee, affiliates of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Merrill Lynch, are not participating in the review of the LBO because those companies helped finance the deal.

Fraudulent-conveyance suits in bankruptcy can target a number of entities, including financiers, current and former executives and even public shareholders who made possible or profited from a leveraged buyout.

In a statement Tribune Co. said, "We have been fully cooperating with the review of our 2007 going-private transaction by the unsecured creditors' committee."

The company, which declined to comment further, won an extension this week to file a reorganization plan with the court by Nov. 30.

The committee isn't the only one looking into the complicated ESOP.

A group of current and former employees of Tribune Co.'s Los Angeles Times have alleged in a suit that Zell and Tribune Co. failed to uphold their fiduciary duty. The U.S. Labor Department and the Internal Revenue Service also have opened probes into the ESOP.

Tribune reporter Julie Johnsson contributed to this report. asachdev@tribune.com8