Chicago Tribune
A bankruptcy judge said Tribune Co. can keep control of its Chapter 11 case for three-and-a-half more months as it looks to sell off some assets, including the Chicago Cubs, in its bid to exit bankruptcy protection.
Judge Kevin J. Carey of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Wilmington, Del., on Monday gave the publisher of the Chicago Tribune an extension to Nov. 30 to file its reorganization plan to emerge from bankruptcy and to repay creditors. He also set a March 15, 2010, deadline for the media giant to win creditor support for a plan.
The extension allows Tribune Co. to maintain exclusive control over the path of its bankruptcy case by preventing creditors and others from filing rival plans with the court.
The Chicago media company, owner of the Chicago Tribune, filed for bankruptcy seven months ago under the weight of some $13 billion in debt, much of it related to real-estate mogul Sam Zell's 2007 deal to take Tribune private.
The company said recently that it has achieved "significant progress" during the case but needs more time to negotiate with creditors and close the sale of the Chicago Cubs. The ball club, whose holdings include Wrigley Field, is one of Tribune's most valuable assets.
Tribune Co. has a tentative deal to sell the team to the Ricketts family, who founded TD Ameritrade Holding Corp., in a deal valued at just under $900 million. Tribune Co. is also reportedly considering a bid from a group led by private-equity investor Marc Utay. The sale of the team requires court approval.
Tribune - which also owns the Los Angeles Times, the Baltimore Sun and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations - is selling the Cubs, Wrigley Field and its stake in a Chicago cable sports network to raise capital.
The company, the nation's third-largest newspaper publisher in terms of revenue and circulation, has also moved to slash costs by cutting jobs at some of its TV stations and daily newspapers.
Faced with an unprecedented drop in advertising revenue and steadily declining circulation, a number of U.S. newspapers have been forced to cut editorial positions, close foreign bureaus and even cease publishing daily print editions in bids to survive.
Several other newspaper companies, including the publishers of the Philadelphia Inquirer, Minneapolis Star Tribune and Chicago Sun-Times, have followed Tribune into bankruptcy court in recent months.
Report Surfaces Again That Tribune's Zell Could Be Ousted
Los Angeles Business from bizjournals
http://www.bizjournals.com/
Real estate mogul Sam Zell, who privatized the parent of the Los Angeles Times Co., could be ousted as part of reorganization plan put forth by creditors, the Chicago Sun-Times reports Friday.
The Chicago Sun-Times reports that the creditors plan to stage a takeover of their own and sell off the company's newspapers and broadcast stations as they see fit. The Sun-Times cites sources who are close to the deal.
Zell owes these creditors $8.6 billion, and those creditors are reportedly becoming impatient with him. But the creditors have until Nov. 30 before they can file a plan since Zell was on Monday granted an extension on his own Tribune reorganization.
This isn't the first time this rumor has surfaced. Reports came out in June that stated Zell would lose Tribune to the same group of investors.
That report stated that "the plan centers on a debt-for-equity swap that probably would give the senior lenders a large majority ownership stake in the reorganized company."
Tribune went private in December 2007 through a buyout led by Zell. The deal left the company with nearly $12 billion in debt. Tribune has sold off assets and cut jobs since the close of the deal to help with the debt payments. The company filed for bankruptcy in December 2008.
Tribune Boss Zell On Way Out
by David Roeder
Chicago Sun Times
Sam Zell's days as a media titan in Chicago are nearly over.
The motorcycle-riding billionaire, renowned for his deft touch with real estate and corporate turnarounds, took Tribune Co. private in late 2007 promising to energize the lumbering company. He piled on debt at exactly the wrong time, and a collapse in advertising for traditional media forced him to take the company to Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
Eight months after the filing, two sources familiar with the process said creditors are working on a reorganization plan that elbows Zell aside. The creditors, including investment banks owed $8.6 billion from Zell's Tribune takeover, would stage a takeover of their own and sell off the company's newspapers and broadcast stations as they see fit.
"The banks will be in charge," one insider said, adding that they are growing impatient with Zell's stewardship. The bankruptcy court on Monday granted Zell extended time, until Nov. 30, to be the first to file a reorganization plan. Creditors have to wait at least that long before filing their own plan with the court.
William Brandt Jr., a corporate turnaround expert not involved in the case, said "enough time has passed so that creditors and the debtor want to cut losses and save face. He said an honorable exit is especially important to Zell, who might need investment banking help for future deals."
"This was a textbook case of a leverage buyout gone bad," said Brandt, president of Development Specialists Inc. "These were imbeciles who had no idea what they were doing."
Brandt said Zell waited too long to sell major assets, accomplishing only a $650 million sale of Newsday, the Long Island-based daily. A sale of the Tribune-owned Chicago Cubs for around $900 million is not final and suffered a months-long detour when Zell tried to sell Wrigley Field separately to an arm of state government.
Still, Tribune financial reports filed with the bankruptcy court show recent improvement. The company's cash on hand rose to $740.5 million as of June 28, up from $702 million in late May. It reported profitable operations in June aside from debt obligations, but for the period from Dec. 8, 2008 to June 28 it said it lost $836.5 million. The numbers don't include units such as the Cubs, which were left out of the bankruptcy filing.
Tribune spokesman Gary Weitman said, "Since going private, we have re-engineered many of our existing products and introduced new ones, expanded our local news programming, dramatically reduced our expenses and positioned the company to succeed in the face of an extremely difficult ad environment and a worsening economy."
He added that Zell and other managers "remain actively engaged and committed to Tribune. The restructuring is still in progress and we continue having positive discussions with our various creditor constituencies. It is premature to speculate about the company's final ownership structure."
While the company has laid off workers, it has hired others to fill new needs. Bankruptcy experts said creditors usually don't object to such new expenses if they believe they help preserve value.
Tribune debt recently traded for about 7 cents on the dollar, meaning investors think a lottery ticket is just as likely to pay off. The company's total debt, counting what Zell assumed in his takeover, is around $13 billion.
Brandt said the Tribune deal has become such a "reputational disaster" for Zell that's he's probably not involved much in management other than creditor negotiations. That could be one reason the company wants bankruptcy court approval to pay bonuses of about $70 million to top managers.
Tribune owns the Chicago Tribune, the Los Angeles Times and other major newspapers, as well as WGN-TV and radio and 22 other TV stations.
David Wirt, chairman of the bankruptcy practice at the firm Locke Lord Bissell & Liddell, said Zell may be getting pressure because creditors want to see revenue growth, and not just cost-cutting. Also, the bankruptcy process is expensive and participants tire of paying lawyer fees that can top $800 an hour for senior partners, said Wirt, whose firm is not involved in the case.
In late 2008, debt analyst Mike Simonton of Fitch Ratings estimated Tribune was worth about $4 billion if sold. Since then, the company's balance sheet has worsened. As of June 28, Tribune said its liabilities exceeded assets by $7.1 billion, vs. $5.7 billion at the time of Simonton's estimate.
Even after a drawn-out liquidation, creditors may be lucky to get a third of their investment back.article originally published at Chicago Sun Times.
Broadcast Union News is a clearing center for information of interest to people working in television, film, print/electronic media, and theater. A chance for AEA, AFTRA, IATSE, IBEW, CWA-NABET, DGA, SAG, Newspaper Guild, WGA, and non-represented entertainment industry workers to share information with an eye towards improving wages, benefits, and working conditions for all.
Friday, August 14, 2009
Sam Zell Would Be Out at Tribune in Creditor Reorganization Plan
Sam Zell may be on his way out at Tribune Co., after taking the company private in 2007 and then taking it into Chapter 11 bankruptcy, the Chicago Sun-Times reports.
Citing sources, the paper said a bankruptcy reorganization plan being hammered out by creditors would push Zell out. The creditors could then sell off Tribune’s broadcast stations and newspapers.
Zell still has court granted rights to file his own reorganization plan first, with a deadline of Nov. 30.--Elizabeth Jensen
Zell Out
By ANDREW GREINER
"The banks will be in charge," one insider says of Zell's possible departure.
Real estate magnate Sam Zell is on his way out of the Tribune Company, according to the Sun-Times.
Zell, a billionaire investor who took over the Tribune in 2007, mismanaged the privatization of the company and added too much debt at the beginning of a recession and at a trying time for newspapers, which are hemorrhaging advertising revenue.
"This was a textbook case of a leverage buyout gone bad," William Brandt Jr. president of Development Specialists Inc. a corporate turnaround expert not involved in the case, told the Sun-Times. "These were imbeciles who had no idea what they were doing."
The company was forced into Chapter 11 bankruptcy eight months ago, and as it gets ready to emerge from that status, creditors, who have grown impatient with Zell's stewardship are working on a plan that ousts him from power.
"The banks will be in charge," one insider told the Sun-Times.
The Tribune Company owns the Chicago Tribune, the L.A. Times, WGN-TV along with other newspapers and television entities.
"Since going private, we have re-engineered many of our existing products and introduced new ones, expanded our local news programming, dramatically reduced our expenses and positioned the company to succeed in the face of an extremely difficult ad environment and a worsening economy,” Tribune spokesman Gary Weitman told the Sun-Times.
“[Zell and other managers] remain actively engaged and committed to Tribune. The restructuring is still in progress and we continue having positive discussions with our various creditor constituencies. It is premature to speculate about the company's final ownership structure."
Zell Headed Out?
By Mark Lacter • Bio • Email
http://www.laobserved.com
Chicago Sun-Times is reporting that Tribune Co. creditors apparently have had enough of CEO Sam Zell and are working on a reorganization plan that would essentially break up the company and get him out. Story lacks detail and the process is still ongoing, but there have been rumblings in recent weeks that the creditors want out.
Before they can file a reorganization plan, however, the company must be given a chance to submit its own plan. A bankruptcy judge has given Tribune until Nov. 30 to do so.
William Brandt Jr., a corporate turnaround expert not involved in the case, said enough time has passed so that creditors and the debtor want to cut losses and save face. He said an honorable exit is especially important to Zell, who might need investment banking help for future deals.
Still, Tribune financial reports filed with the bankruptcy court show recent improvement. The company's cash on hand rose to $740.5 million as of June 28, up from $702 million in late May. It reported profitable operations in June aside from debt obligations, but for the period from Dec. 8, 2008 to June 28 it said it lost $836.5 million. The numbers don't include units such as the Cubs, which were left out of the bankruptcy filing.
Citing sources, the paper said a bankruptcy reorganization plan being hammered out by creditors would push Zell out. The creditors could then sell off Tribune’s broadcast stations and newspapers.
Zell still has court granted rights to file his own reorganization plan first, with a deadline of Nov. 30.--Elizabeth Jensen
Zell Out
By ANDREW GREINER
"The banks will be in charge," one insider says of Zell's possible departure.
Real estate magnate Sam Zell is on his way out of the Tribune Company, according to the Sun-Times.
Zell, a billionaire investor who took over the Tribune in 2007, mismanaged the privatization of the company and added too much debt at the beginning of a recession and at a trying time for newspapers, which are hemorrhaging advertising revenue.
"This was a textbook case of a leverage buyout gone bad," William Brandt Jr. president of Development Specialists Inc. a corporate turnaround expert not involved in the case, told the Sun-Times. "These were imbeciles who had no idea what they were doing."
The company was forced into Chapter 11 bankruptcy eight months ago, and as it gets ready to emerge from that status, creditors, who have grown impatient with Zell's stewardship are working on a plan that ousts him from power.
"The banks will be in charge," one insider told the Sun-Times.
The Tribune Company owns the Chicago Tribune, the L.A. Times, WGN-TV along with other newspapers and television entities.
"Since going private, we have re-engineered many of our existing products and introduced new ones, expanded our local news programming, dramatically reduced our expenses and positioned the company to succeed in the face of an extremely difficult ad environment and a worsening economy,” Tribune spokesman Gary Weitman told the Sun-Times.
“[Zell and other managers] remain actively engaged and committed to Tribune. The restructuring is still in progress and we continue having positive discussions with our various creditor constituencies. It is premature to speculate about the company's final ownership structure."
Zell Headed Out?
By Mark Lacter • Bio • Email
http://www.laobserved.com
Chicago Sun-Times is reporting that Tribune Co. creditors apparently have had enough of CEO Sam Zell and are working on a reorganization plan that would essentially break up the company and get him out. Story lacks detail and the process is still ongoing, but there have been rumblings in recent weeks that the creditors want out.
Before they can file a reorganization plan, however, the company must be given a chance to submit its own plan. A bankruptcy judge has given Tribune until Nov. 30 to do so.
William Brandt Jr., a corporate turnaround expert not involved in the case, said enough time has passed so that creditors and the debtor want to cut losses and save face. He said an honorable exit is especially important to Zell, who might need investment banking help for future deals.
Still, Tribune financial reports filed with the bankruptcy court show recent improvement. The company's cash on hand rose to $740.5 million as of June 28, up from $702 million in late May. It reported profitable operations in June aside from debt obligations, but for the period from Dec. 8, 2008 to June 28 it said it lost $836.5 million. The numbers don't include units such as the Cubs, which were left out of the bankruptcy filing.
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Gannett Cuts 70 More Jobs at Westchester Newspaper
By STEPHANIE CLIFFORD
The New York Times
The Journal News, a Westchester area newspaper owned by Gannett, told all 288 of its news and advertising sales employees on Wednesday that their jobs were being eliminated and they would need to apply for redefined positions by the end of the week.
After the redefined jobs are filled, there will be 20 fewer positions in advertising and 50 fewer positions in news, reducing the newsroom staff (which includes Web employees) by more than a quarter.
Last week, the paper laid off 57 employees in areas like production, finance, and information technology.
“We’ve been working on a restructuring plan for the Journal News for a while,” said Michael J. Fisch, publisher and president of the newspaper, in an interview. “That’s partly the reason for the move today, but the other part of the reason for having employees reapply for newly defined jobs is to recognize that our business has changed.”
A reporter who has been at the paper for more than 15 years said that matching old jobs to new was confusing. “For example, there are no photo jobs listed, but ‘visual specialists,’ ” the reporter said, while the closest jobs to traditional print reporting seemed to be “topics beat reporter” and “local beat reporter.”
“It seemed obvious that a lot of the local communities we cover will get shorted on coverage, mainly because there’s not enough people,” said the reporter, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of concerns over the job.
Employees whose jobs were cut must apply for the new positions via the company’s internal Web site by Friday, Mr. Fisch said.
The employees are to be interviewed next week. The Journal News says it expects to make the rehiring decisions by the week of Aug. 24.
The cuts include some midlevel managers, Mr. Fisch said. “Within the news and advertising departments, there are some managerial positions that have been eliminated in this structuring,” he said. “We had a number of high-level executive positions eliminated last year.”
After the cuts, the newspaper will have about 700 employees, Mr. Fisch said.
The Journal News reported an average weekday paid circulation of 95,389 in its most recent filing with the Audit Bureau of Circulations. The newspaper also covers Rockland and Putnam counties.
In July, Gannett reported an 18 percent decline in revenue in its second quarter compared to the same period a year earlier. Newspaper ad revenue dropped 32 percent, it said.
But Gannett has been slashing costs aggressively, including cutting thousands of jobs. That led to a second-quarter profit of $70.5 million. There was another bright spot in that report: Gannett executives said in a conference call with analysts that the advertising market had improved in June and July.
As It Cuts Jobs, Gannett Also Cuts Severance Pay
By RICHARD PÉREZ-PEÑA
The New York Times
Last December, when the Gannett newspaper chain laid off thousands of workers, Jenny Poon was not one of them. Now she wishes she had been.
Ms. Poon, an art director at The Arizona Republic, lost her job this month in the latest wave of layoffs, as the Gannett Company, like other corporations, shed jobs to keep up with falling revenue.
But rather than pay severance, as it did in previous rounds, Gannett is paying what is called supplemental unemployment benefits, which allows the company to shift part of the cost onto the states.
The company says that for most employees the result will be about the same — that in fact, many will get a little more, and a few could get much more. But employees are discovering that some of them, like Ms. Poon, stand to get a lot less than they would have under the old severance packages, and some will get nothing.
Ms. Poon, 26, has a graphic design business that generates a little income, which will lower her state unemployment benefits and may be enough to wipe them out entirely. She is awaiting the state’s ruling to learn which. And if she is not eligible for payments from the state, she will receive nothing from Gannett.
Other former Republic employees who had part-time second jobs say those jobs now mean missing out on thousands of dollars from the company.
“I don’t blame them for cutting and trying to save money because things are bad, but there ought to be a decent severance,” Ms. Poon said. “This way it punishes people for trying to find work.”
Gannett, a largely nonunion company, is under no obligation to make severance or any other payments to most of the people it lays off, and it is not alone in looking for ways to spend less on employees as it weathers the downturn; many newspaper companies, including The New York Times Company, have cut wages and benefits.
As for supplemental unemployment programs like Gannett’s, “they exist but they’re pretty rare,” said Andrew Stettner, deputy director of the National Employment Law Project. Several major publishers, including the Tribune Company, the McClatchy Company and the Times Company, said they have never used one and pay standard severance instead.
Robin Pence, a Gannett spokeswoman, said the 1,400 people laid off this month should not think of the program as severance. “The purpose of this is to supplement your unemployment while you’re getting a job,” she said. “It’s a transitional pay, not severance.”
That distinction is lost on employees who say that the practical effect of being paid — or not — is the same, no matter how the program is labeled.
In this month’s layoffs, as in previous rounds, affected employees can keep receiving the equivalent of their salaries for a number of weeks equal to their years of service; for instance, a 10-year employee would continue to be paid for 10 weeks.
But in this round, the company told workers to file for state unemployment, which in Arizona and some other states means filing again every week. If they qualify for state payments, they can apply for supplemental benefits to Total Management Solutions, a company hired by Gannett to run the program, and receive the difference between their former salaries and their state unemployment checks.
The company said it did not know how much it would save, compared with paying severance, or how many employees would be adversely affected. It said most employees would get a little more than they would have from severance, because unemployment benefits are exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes.
The move raised the minimum benefit from two weeks’ pay to three. And laid-off employees with more than 26 years’ service — Gannett said it did not know how many there were — could get significantly more than they would have from severance, because the maximum benefit was raised from 26 weeks to 36.
Gannett operates hundreds of newspapers in many states, but the benefit restrictions are a particular concern in Arizona, whose unemployment benefits are among the nation’s lowest, capped at $265 a week. The Arizona Department of Economic Security says that unemployment beneficiaries become ineligible if they bring in more in a week than their maximum weekly unemployment check. And for former Gannett workers, any interruption in unemployment eligibility means no further payments from the company.
“If you take part-time work or freelance work, even for a week, you get nothing from Gannett,” said Dave Lumia, 52, who was an assistant sports editor at The Republic. “It certainly doesn’t encourage me to go out and look for work.”
Mr. Lumia, who worked at the paper for 13 years, said his wife lost her job in December, and they are weighing whether they can afford to help their daughter pay for college this fall.
Jennifer Johnson, who was laid off from her job as an editor on The Republic’s Page 1 team, quickly found a new post, working for the Arizona Democratic Party. But that means she will not receive nine of the 10 weeks’ pay she would have gotten, she said.
Labor lawyers say that in a small number of states — including New York, where Gannett has several newspapers — there is another way that people could receive much less than they would have under the company’s former severance plans. In those states, people who lose their jobs can receive full severance payments and full state unemployment benefits simultaneously. But Gannett’s new program makes that impossible.
The New York Times
The Journal News, a Westchester area newspaper owned by Gannett, told all 288 of its news and advertising sales employees on Wednesday that their jobs were being eliminated and they would need to apply for redefined positions by the end of the week.
After the redefined jobs are filled, there will be 20 fewer positions in advertising and 50 fewer positions in news, reducing the newsroom staff (which includes Web employees) by more than a quarter.
Last week, the paper laid off 57 employees in areas like production, finance, and information technology.
“We’ve been working on a restructuring plan for the Journal News for a while,” said Michael J. Fisch, publisher and president of the newspaper, in an interview. “That’s partly the reason for the move today, but the other part of the reason for having employees reapply for newly defined jobs is to recognize that our business has changed.”
A reporter who has been at the paper for more than 15 years said that matching old jobs to new was confusing. “For example, there are no photo jobs listed, but ‘visual specialists,’ ” the reporter said, while the closest jobs to traditional print reporting seemed to be “topics beat reporter” and “local beat reporter.”
“It seemed obvious that a lot of the local communities we cover will get shorted on coverage, mainly because there’s not enough people,” said the reporter, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of concerns over the job.
Employees whose jobs were cut must apply for the new positions via the company’s internal Web site by Friday, Mr. Fisch said.
The employees are to be interviewed next week. The Journal News says it expects to make the rehiring decisions by the week of Aug. 24.
The cuts include some midlevel managers, Mr. Fisch said. “Within the news and advertising departments, there are some managerial positions that have been eliminated in this structuring,” he said. “We had a number of high-level executive positions eliminated last year.”
After the cuts, the newspaper will have about 700 employees, Mr. Fisch said.
The Journal News reported an average weekday paid circulation of 95,389 in its most recent filing with the Audit Bureau of Circulations. The newspaper also covers Rockland and Putnam counties.
In July, Gannett reported an 18 percent decline in revenue in its second quarter compared to the same period a year earlier. Newspaper ad revenue dropped 32 percent, it said.
But Gannett has been slashing costs aggressively, including cutting thousands of jobs. That led to a second-quarter profit of $70.5 million. There was another bright spot in that report: Gannett executives said in a conference call with analysts that the advertising market had improved in June and July.
As It Cuts Jobs, Gannett Also Cuts Severance Pay
By RICHARD PÉREZ-PEÑA
The New York Times
Last December, when the Gannett newspaper chain laid off thousands of workers, Jenny Poon was not one of them. Now she wishes she had been.
Ms. Poon, an art director at The Arizona Republic, lost her job this month in the latest wave of layoffs, as the Gannett Company, like other corporations, shed jobs to keep up with falling revenue.
But rather than pay severance, as it did in previous rounds, Gannett is paying what is called supplemental unemployment benefits, which allows the company to shift part of the cost onto the states.
The company says that for most employees the result will be about the same — that in fact, many will get a little more, and a few could get much more. But employees are discovering that some of them, like Ms. Poon, stand to get a lot less than they would have under the old severance packages, and some will get nothing.
Ms. Poon, 26, has a graphic design business that generates a little income, which will lower her state unemployment benefits and may be enough to wipe them out entirely. She is awaiting the state’s ruling to learn which. And if she is not eligible for payments from the state, she will receive nothing from Gannett.
Other former Republic employees who had part-time second jobs say those jobs now mean missing out on thousands of dollars from the company.
“I don’t blame them for cutting and trying to save money because things are bad, but there ought to be a decent severance,” Ms. Poon said. “This way it punishes people for trying to find work.”
Gannett, a largely nonunion company, is under no obligation to make severance or any other payments to most of the people it lays off, and it is not alone in looking for ways to spend less on employees as it weathers the downturn; many newspaper companies, including The New York Times Company, have cut wages and benefits.
As for supplemental unemployment programs like Gannett’s, “they exist but they’re pretty rare,” said Andrew Stettner, deputy director of the National Employment Law Project. Several major publishers, including the Tribune Company, the McClatchy Company and the Times Company, said they have never used one and pay standard severance instead.
Robin Pence, a Gannett spokeswoman, said the 1,400 people laid off this month should not think of the program as severance. “The purpose of this is to supplement your unemployment while you’re getting a job,” she said. “It’s a transitional pay, not severance.”
That distinction is lost on employees who say that the practical effect of being paid — or not — is the same, no matter how the program is labeled.
In this month’s layoffs, as in previous rounds, affected employees can keep receiving the equivalent of their salaries for a number of weeks equal to their years of service; for instance, a 10-year employee would continue to be paid for 10 weeks.
But in this round, the company told workers to file for state unemployment, which in Arizona and some other states means filing again every week. If they qualify for state payments, they can apply for supplemental benefits to Total Management Solutions, a company hired by Gannett to run the program, and receive the difference between their former salaries and their state unemployment checks.
The company said it did not know how much it would save, compared with paying severance, or how many employees would be adversely affected. It said most employees would get a little more than they would have from severance, because unemployment benefits are exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes.
The move raised the minimum benefit from two weeks’ pay to three. And laid-off employees with more than 26 years’ service — Gannett said it did not know how many there were — could get significantly more than they would have from severance, because the maximum benefit was raised from 26 weeks to 36.
Gannett operates hundreds of newspapers in many states, but the benefit restrictions are a particular concern in Arizona, whose unemployment benefits are among the nation’s lowest, capped at $265 a week. The Arizona Department of Economic Security says that unemployment beneficiaries become ineligible if they bring in more in a week than their maximum weekly unemployment check. And for former Gannett workers, any interruption in unemployment eligibility means no further payments from the company.
“If you take part-time work or freelance work, even for a week, you get nothing from Gannett,” said Dave Lumia, 52, who was an assistant sports editor at The Republic. “It certainly doesn’t encourage me to go out and look for work.”
Mr. Lumia, who worked at the paper for 13 years, said his wife lost her job in December, and they are weighing whether they can afford to help their daughter pay for college this fall.
Jennifer Johnson, who was laid off from her job as an editor on The Republic’s Page 1 team, quickly found a new post, working for the Arizona Democratic Party. But that means she will not receive nine of the 10 weeks’ pay she would have gotten, she said.
Labor lawyers say that in a small number of states — including New York, where Gannett has several newspapers — there is another way that people could receive much less than they would have under the company’s former severance plans. In those states, people who lose their jobs can receive full severance payments and full state unemployment benefits simultaneously. But Gannett’s new program makes that impossible.
New Contract at WPIX For Newspaper Guild
4-Year Agreement Reached Despite Tribune Bankruptcy
Newspaper Guild Members at WPIX last week ratified a new four-year pact with the Tribune Co.-owned television station that provides a 1 percent lump sum payment in January 2010, and 2 percent wage increases on January 1, 2011 and January 1, 2012.
With Tribune Co. in bankruptcy, WPIX management came to the bargaining table seeking concessions. But the Guild was still able to achieve some improvements in the new agreement, which runs through December 31, 2012, while beating back the company’s giveback demands.
Benefit improvements include the introduction of CWA-sponsored health care and short-term disability plans. The new plans take effect January 1, 2010 and provide better benefits than the current company-sponsored plans. The new health care plan will reduce co-pays, deductibles and out-of pocket maximums, saving members money when they need medical services. The new short-term disability plan ensures that members who are unable to work because they are sick or incapacitated receive 60 to 75 percent of regular pay for up to 26 weeks. Nonunion employees get just 40 percent of regular pay.
“Adopting these plans gives the union more control of our members’ benefits,” said New York Guild Representative Anthony Napoli, who led bargaining for the Guild. “The company won’t have the ability to unilaterally slash benefits or increase our members’ out-of-pocket expenses to cut costs.”
The Guild was also able to reduce trial periods to three months for both new and promoted employees. Funeral leave was improved with the addition of domestic partners to the list of “immediate family” for whose death employees are entitled to paid leave.
Bill O’Meara, president of the New York Guild, said “Given today’s economic climate and the additional challenges of negotiating with a company in bankruptcy, I am especially pleased we were able to avoid concessions and achieve improvements that will provide better benefits and save our members money during these trying times.”
New Three-Year Contract Ratified
At New York Times Digital
Guild members at the New York Times Digital unit have voted overwhelmingly to approve a new three-year contract. The final vote was 63 in favor of the settlement and four against, with no abstentions. The new contract includes significant wage increases and/or bonuses for 2008 and will achieve weekly pay parity with the newspaper beginning March 31, 2009. Highlights of the agreement are:
· Three Year contract running March 31, 2008 through March 30, 2011
· Wage increases retroactive to March 31, 2008 and salary hikes in 2009 & 2010
· For the first time, night and lobster differentials will be paid to Guild employees who are assigned to those shifts
· Pay for time worked in a higher job classification
· 8i training program for Web Producer, Web Designer and Video Journalist job categories
· Creation of Group O level positions
· Employees will be eligible to participate in the Time’s Distinguished Journalism Program
New York Guild President Bill O’Meara said, “Given the current economic environment and the challenges the media industry is facing we are pleased the Times has made a commitment to invest in the future of the website.” The Guild bargaining committee, led by O’Meara, included Local Representative Anthony Napoli, Unit Chair Erik Piepenburg, First Vice Chair Sarah Graham, Unit Members Matt Orr and Caryn Tutino.
Newspaper Guild Members at WPIX last week ratified a new four-year pact with the Tribune Co.-owned television station that provides a 1 percent lump sum payment in January 2010, and 2 percent wage increases on January 1, 2011 and January 1, 2012.
With Tribune Co. in bankruptcy, WPIX management came to the bargaining table seeking concessions. But the Guild was still able to achieve some improvements in the new agreement, which runs through December 31, 2012, while beating back the company’s giveback demands.
Benefit improvements include the introduction of CWA-sponsored health care and short-term disability plans. The new plans take effect January 1, 2010 and provide better benefits than the current company-sponsored plans. The new health care plan will reduce co-pays, deductibles and out-of pocket maximums, saving members money when they need medical services. The new short-term disability plan ensures that members who are unable to work because they are sick or incapacitated receive 60 to 75 percent of regular pay for up to 26 weeks. Nonunion employees get just 40 percent of regular pay.
“Adopting these plans gives the union more control of our members’ benefits,” said New York Guild Representative Anthony Napoli, who led bargaining for the Guild. “The company won’t have the ability to unilaterally slash benefits or increase our members’ out-of-pocket expenses to cut costs.”
The Guild was also able to reduce trial periods to three months for both new and promoted employees. Funeral leave was improved with the addition of domestic partners to the list of “immediate family” for whose death employees are entitled to paid leave.
Bill O’Meara, president of the New York Guild, said “Given today’s economic climate and the additional challenges of negotiating with a company in bankruptcy, I am especially pleased we were able to avoid concessions and achieve improvements that will provide better benefits and save our members money during these trying times.”
New Three-Year Contract Ratified
At New York Times Digital
Guild members at the New York Times Digital unit have voted overwhelmingly to approve a new three-year contract. The final vote was 63 in favor of the settlement and four against, with no abstentions. The new contract includes significant wage increases and/or bonuses for 2008 and will achieve weekly pay parity with the newspaper beginning March 31, 2009. Highlights of the agreement are:
· Three Year contract running March 31, 2008 through March 30, 2011
· Wage increases retroactive to March 31, 2008 and salary hikes in 2009 & 2010
· For the first time, night and lobster differentials will be paid to Guild employees who are assigned to those shifts
· Pay for time worked in a higher job classification
· 8i training program for Web Producer, Web Designer and Video Journalist job categories
· Creation of Group O level positions
· Employees will be eligible to participate in the Time’s Distinguished Journalism Program
New York Guild President Bill O’Meara said, “Given the current economic environment and the challenges the media industry is facing we are pleased the Times has made a commitment to invest in the future of the website.” The Guild bargaining committee, led by O’Meara, included Local Representative Anthony Napoli, Unit Chair Erik Piepenburg, First Vice Chair Sarah Graham, Unit Members Matt Orr and Caryn Tutino.
Internet Writers at CBS Organize
http://unionreview.com/internet-writers-cbs-organize
Internet writers employed at CBS studios in the L.A. area have unanimously voted to be represented by the Writers Guild of America, West.
The vote was conducted by the National Labor Relations Board. "This is good news for new media writers. Congratulations and welcome to the Writers Guild," said WGAW President Patric M. Verrone. "As more and more news, sports, and promotional content is distributed on the Internet, it is essential that its writers win respect for their work and all the benefits of a WGA contract."
WGAW Union Representative Lynda Whittaker and WGAW Organizer Laura Watson worked closely with WGAW shop stewards – Kathy Kiernan, Scott Gutman, and Brett Galde – throughout the campaign.
The next step for the 15 writers is contract negotiations.
“We hope to reach a fair deal with CBS as soon as possible,” said Whittaker. ”I know in this ever-changing world it’s important to be heard ... and it might be cliche, but there is strength in numbers. I’m not always sure the meek shall inherit the Earth, but I know the weak don't have a chance. I applaud the Guild for making us all stronger,” said CBS web writer Alan Carter.
Internet writers employed at CBS studios in the L.A. area have unanimously voted to be represented by the Writers Guild of America, West.
The vote was conducted by the National Labor Relations Board. "This is good news for new media writers. Congratulations and welcome to the Writers Guild," said WGAW President Patric M. Verrone. "As more and more news, sports, and promotional content is distributed on the Internet, it is essential that its writers win respect for their work and all the benefits of a WGA contract."
WGAW Union Representative Lynda Whittaker and WGAW Organizer Laura Watson worked closely with WGAW shop stewards – Kathy Kiernan, Scott Gutman, and Brett Galde – throughout the campaign.
The next step for the 15 writers is contract negotiations.
“We hope to reach a fair deal with CBS as soon as possible,” said Whittaker. ”I know in this ever-changing world it’s important to be heard ... and it might be cliche, but there is strength in numbers. I’m not always sure the meek shall inherit the Earth, but I know the weak don't have a chance. I applaud the Guild for making us all stronger,” said CBS web writer Alan Carter.
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
Motivate Me Too!!
Posted By Bob Daraio
Broadcast Union News
Tribune says they need a $70 million dollar executive bonus plan because "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level."
Apparently the handsome salaries Tribune executives receive just isn't enough to motivate them to provide their best efforts. It would be a lot cheaper to replace them with executives with a better work ethic.
In light of this, one wonders just how motivated Tribune management expects the writers at WPIX to be, given the zero percent (O %) raises they will be getting in each of the next two years as a result of recent collective bargaining.
Any idiot can bankrupt a company; it takes real genius to wreck a highly profitable one, and by the way Tribune is still a profitable company.
Tribune doesn’t report profit, but a Crain’s analysis of cash flow shows the company had an 8% profit margin for the first few months of the year, which, while less than half the 19% margin it boasted in the first half of 2008, still means Tribune took in $112 million dollars more than it cost to operate the company.
I'd love my bank and broker to be giving me an 8% profit on my money.
Perhaps 8% raises for everyone from top to bottom and an end to the massive layoffs and cutbacks might be a better use of $70 million dollars.
At the Tribune Company, Inquiring Union Minds Want to Know
by Michael Miner
http://www.chicagoreader.com/
The Tribune Company has always managed to keep the Newspaper Guild out of its newsroom, but some other papers in the far-flung Tribune empire haven't been so fortunate. And in Delaware, a federal bankruptcy judge just ruled that the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild must be told some of the details of the company's $70 million executive bonus plan.
The guild represents about 225 newsroom employees of the Baltimore Sun, where 61 journalists were laid off in April.
Earlier this month Tribune COO Randy Michaels wrote the court arguing for the bonuses. "Incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," he maintained. "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level."
The Newspaper Guild promptly wrote the court questioning the bankrupt company's incentivizaton theory. "The proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line," said the Guild. "Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."
The arcane art of incentivation is based on the premise that the more money high level executives make, the more extra they need to be paid in order to take their jobs seriously. Rank-and-file workers have traditionally struggled to get their minds around this theory.
I think the court restricted the disclosure of the bonus setup to just the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild. One would hope, however, that the Guild would then reveal what it learns to everyone.
Come to think of it, why shouldn't disclosure apply for all Tribune employees? After all, they own the place, don't they--albeit as 60 percent owners in thrall to creditors conveniently clamped to their backs by Sam Zell?
By the way, rank-and-filers have their own incentives, in the form of the constant threat of being laid off in a media environment in which journalistic skills have--and are increasingly unlikely ever again within our lifetimes to have--any market value.
At least, this is what we're constantly reminded of by media owners while they continue to rake in the profits that pay for the other, lavish, executive kind of incentive.
Of course, if they actually invested in their actually still-profitable products to actually compete aggressively in an expanding media environment, they might have to forgo the executive incentives for a short spell.
Then where would we be?
Goodness gracious, the papers:
Where the cash at? Where the stash at?*
Posted by Whet Moser on Wed, Aug 5, 2009 at 3:17 PM
Good news on the Trib bankruptcy front: the US bankruptcy trustee and three unions involved aren't going to roll over for corporate's blatantly offensive plan to reward themselves for actually doing the job that reasonable people who care about their colleagues expect of themselves as employees:
"At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," the union filing said. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
$70 million would go a long way towards more better content, which has the highest correlation to the bottom line, as Michael Miner reports.
* If you're curious why I'm so likely to use hip-hop in reference to certain stories, it's because, to steal an interpretation from one of my friends, the genre has developed a language to describe economic violence that's better than almost anything American culture has produced, save for perhaps gangster movies.
Broadcast Union News
Tribune says they need a $70 million dollar executive bonus plan because "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level."
Apparently the handsome salaries Tribune executives receive just isn't enough to motivate them to provide their best efforts. It would be a lot cheaper to replace them with executives with a better work ethic.
In light of this, one wonders just how motivated Tribune management expects the writers at WPIX to be, given the zero percent (O %) raises they will be getting in each of the next two years as a result of recent collective bargaining.
Any idiot can bankrupt a company; it takes real genius to wreck a highly profitable one, and by the way Tribune is still a profitable company.
Tribune doesn’t report profit, but a Crain’s analysis of cash flow shows the company had an 8% profit margin for the first few months of the year, which, while less than half the 19% margin it boasted in the first half of 2008, still means Tribune took in $112 million dollars more than it cost to operate the company.
I'd love my bank and broker to be giving me an 8% profit on my money.
Perhaps 8% raises for everyone from top to bottom and an end to the massive layoffs and cutbacks might be a better use of $70 million dollars.
At the Tribune Company, Inquiring Union Minds Want to Know
by Michael Miner
http://www.chicagoreader.com/
The Tribune Company has always managed to keep the Newspaper Guild out of its newsroom, but some other papers in the far-flung Tribune empire haven't been so fortunate. And in Delaware, a federal bankruptcy judge just ruled that the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild must be told some of the details of the company's $70 million executive bonus plan.
The guild represents about 225 newsroom employees of the Baltimore Sun, where 61 journalists were laid off in April.
Earlier this month Tribune COO Randy Michaels wrote the court arguing for the bonuses. "Incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," he maintained. "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level."
The Newspaper Guild promptly wrote the court questioning the bankrupt company's incentivizaton theory. "The proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line," said the Guild. "Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."
The arcane art of incentivation is based on the premise that the more money high level executives make, the more extra they need to be paid in order to take their jobs seriously. Rank-and-file workers have traditionally struggled to get their minds around this theory.
I think the court restricted the disclosure of the bonus setup to just the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild. One would hope, however, that the Guild would then reveal what it learns to everyone.
Come to think of it, why shouldn't disclosure apply for all Tribune employees? After all, they own the place, don't they--albeit as 60 percent owners in thrall to creditors conveniently clamped to their backs by Sam Zell?
By the way, rank-and-filers have their own incentives, in the form of the constant threat of being laid off in a media environment in which journalistic skills have--and are increasingly unlikely ever again within our lifetimes to have--any market value.
At least, this is what we're constantly reminded of by media owners while they continue to rake in the profits that pay for the other, lavish, executive kind of incentive.
Of course, if they actually invested in their actually still-profitable products to actually compete aggressively in an expanding media environment, they might have to forgo the executive incentives for a short spell.
Then where would we be?
Goodness gracious, the papers:
Where the cash at? Where the stash at?*
Posted by Whet Moser on Wed, Aug 5, 2009 at 3:17 PM
Good news on the Trib bankruptcy front: the US bankruptcy trustee and three unions involved aren't going to roll over for corporate's blatantly offensive plan to reward themselves for actually doing the job that reasonable people who care about their colleagues expect of themselves as employees:
"At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," the union filing said. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
$70 million would go a long way towards more better content, which has the highest correlation to the bottom line, as Michael Miner reports.
* If you're curious why I'm so likely to use hip-hop in reference to certain stories, it's because, to steal an interpretation from one of my friends, the genre has developed a language to describe economic violence that's better than almost anything American culture has produced, save for perhaps gangster movies.
Tribune Execs May Get Their $70 Million Bonus!!
By Nicholas Carlson
http://www.businessinsider.com/
Executives from the bankrupt Tribune company who want to pay themselves $70 million in bonuses will have to show Newspaper Guild members who is getting paid and how much, a Judge ruled yesterday.
Real estate mogul Sam Zell bought the Tribune company and took it private in 2007. Then he took on about $13 billion in debt.
With that load and ad prices plummetting, the Tribune Company filed for Chapter 11 in December.
Here's the AP report on the bonuses:
Newspaper Union to See Tribune Bonus Information
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) -- A union representing newspaper workers should be allowed to see details about the Tribune Co.'s proposal to give bonuses totaling up to $70 million to the company's top managers, a federal bankruptcy judge ruled Tuesday.
Judge Kevin Carey said details about the proposed bonus plan should be provided on a limited basis to attorneys for the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild, which represents 225 workers at the Tribune-owned The (Baltimore) Sun and opposes the bonuses.
The judge agreed to allow the Chicago-based company to keep under seal a compensation consultant's report underlying the bonus plan and said information to be shared by the Tribune will be restricted.
''It's going only to the Guild,'' Carey ruled, denying the Guild's request to share the information with other unions, including those that joined in its objection to the bonus plan. Only the Guild made a formal objection in the case; the others joined in the Guild's petition.
Tribune, which also owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt load. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007.
The company defended the proposed bonuses, saying they are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization. The bonuses, the company said, will help attract top-tier management talent if needed.
The Guild has argued that the performance targets are virtually guaranteed to be met and that the bonus plan could be a disguised retention plan for insiders.
Carey said he would decide later who within the Guild should be allowed to see the information. He scheduled a telephone conference with attorneys Friday to discuss the issue before ruling on the Tribune's request for a protective order to limit dissemination of the information.
A hearing on whether the court should approve the bonus plan itself was postponed until September.
Carey's ruling came after he said the Guild should be able to see certain information, subject to confidentiality provisions, solely for use in arguing its objection to the bonuses. He ordered a brief recess in Tuesday's hearing to allow attorneys a chance to discuss a mutually agreeable approach.
Tribune attorney Jonathan Lotsoff later told the judge that disagreements remained, even though the company had offered to provide the Guild essentially all the information it has given to its creditors committee, which includes a Guild representative.
Guild attorney Michael Joyce said the union would welcome that information, but because it did not know what is included, it may need to pursue additional details.
In a filing last month, the company proposed continuation of an incentive plan for about 720 employees, including its top 10 executives, with a maximum payout for this year of $45.6 million.
Tribune also has proposed bonuses of up to $10.6 million to be divided among 21 core managers, including the top 10 executives, for operating and restructuring efforts; and up to $9.3 million in performance bonuses to be divided among 23 key operations leaders. It also is seeking permission to pay about $3 million in bonuses earned last year to nine top executives.
Attorneys for the Tribune's creditors committee and a steering committee of its senior lenders reiterated their support for the bonus plan Tuesday.
''We believe the targets are appropriately set to incentivize the right people to maximize the value of the estate,'' said Damian Schaible, an attorney for the steering committee.
Associated Press writers Mary Claire Dale reported from Philadelphia and Andrew Vanacore contributed from New York.
http://www.businessinsider.com/
Executives from the bankrupt Tribune company who want to pay themselves $70 million in bonuses will have to show Newspaper Guild members who is getting paid and how much, a Judge ruled yesterday.
Real estate mogul Sam Zell bought the Tribune company and took it private in 2007. Then he took on about $13 billion in debt.
With that load and ad prices plummetting, the Tribune Company filed for Chapter 11 in December.
Here's the AP report on the bonuses:
Newspaper Union to See Tribune Bonus Information
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) -- A union representing newspaper workers should be allowed to see details about the Tribune Co.'s proposal to give bonuses totaling up to $70 million to the company's top managers, a federal bankruptcy judge ruled Tuesday.
Judge Kevin Carey said details about the proposed bonus plan should be provided on a limited basis to attorneys for the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild, which represents 225 workers at the Tribune-owned The (Baltimore) Sun and opposes the bonuses.
The judge agreed to allow the Chicago-based company to keep under seal a compensation consultant's report underlying the bonus plan and said information to be shared by the Tribune will be restricted.
''It's going only to the Guild,'' Carey ruled, denying the Guild's request to share the information with other unions, including those that joined in its objection to the bonus plan. Only the Guild made a formal objection in the case; the others joined in the Guild's petition.
Tribune, which also owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt load. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007.
The company defended the proposed bonuses, saying they are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization. The bonuses, the company said, will help attract top-tier management talent if needed.
The Guild has argued that the performance targets are virtually guaranteed to be met and that the bonus plan could be a disguised retention plan for insiders.
Carey said he would decide later who within the Guild should be allowed to see the information. He scheduled a telephone conference with attorneys Friday to discuss the issue before ruling on the Tribune's request for a protective order to limit dissemination of the information.
A hearing on whether the court should approve the bonus plan itself was postponed until September.
Carey's ruling came after he said the Guild should be able to see certain information, subject to confidentiality provisions, solely for use in arguing its objection to the bonuses. He ordered a brief recess in Tuesday's hearing to allow attorneys a chance to discuss a mutually agreeable approach.
Tribune attorney Jonathan Lotsoff later told the judge that disagreements remained, even though the company had offered to provide the Guild essentially all the information it has given to its creditors committee, which includes a Guild representative.
Guild attorney Michael Joyce said the union would welcome that information, but because it did not know what is included, it may need to pursue additional details.
In a filing last month, the company proposed continuation of an incentive plan for about 720 employees, including its top 10 executives, with a maximum payout for this year of $45.6 million.
Tribune also has proposed bonuses of up to $10.6 million to be divided among 21 core managers, including the top 10 executives, for operating and restructuring efforts; and up to $9.3 million in performance bonuses to be divided among 23 key operations leaders. It also is seeking permission to pay about $3 million in bonuses earned last year to nine top executives.
Attorneys for the Tribune's creditors committee and a steering committee of its senior lenders reiterated their support for the bonus plan Tuesday.
''We believe the targets are appropriately set to incentivize the right people to maximize the value of the estate,'' said Damian Schaible, an attorney for the steering committee.
Associated Press writers Mary Claire Dale reported from Philadelphia and Andrew Vanacore contributed from New York.
Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Bonus For The bankrupt? Michaels Says Yes
By Dan Monk
Senior Staff Writer
http://cincinnati.bizjournals.com/
A Delaware bankruptcy judge is hearing arguments Tuesday on whether Randy Michaels and other top executives of the Tribune Co. should be eligible for nearly $70 million in bonuses from the bankrupt newspaper company.
You may remember that Michaels led a small army of former Jacor Communications Inc. business managers to Chicago in 2008 to reshape the media empire acquired by Chicago billionaire Sam Zell.
After several months of job cuts and controversial business changes, the Tribune Co. filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in December.
This new controversy comes from the Tribune’s request for bankruptcy court approval of a new bonus plan, filed in early August. The company requested that it be kept under seal, but the court rejected that idea.
The proposal calls for new incentive payments to some 700 business managers, including $20.6 million to the Tribune’s top 10 execs, according to this AFL-CIO blog entry.
As you might expect, unions that claim membership at Tribune-owned newspaper and television stations don’t think too highly of Michaels' argument in court documents that “we must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles.”
Here’s a summary of the reaction to the new pay plan at Broadcast Union News.
Tribune CEOs seek $70 Million in Bonuses as Company Sinks
by John Small, Aug 8, 2009
AFL/CIO News
It’s not like we needed one more example of greedy corporate executives at a bankrupt company making a grab for big bonuses while axing hundreds of employees and freezing wages for many others.
But that’s what Tribune Co. executives are doing as the multimedia conglomerate sinks under the weight of $13 billion in debt incurred by its corporate leaders in 2007. And they want to keep the bonuses a big secret.
The company filed for Chapter 11 protection last December and, in its most recent action, is seeking court permission to dole out nearly $70 million in executive bonuses. The company also requested the court seal much of the request. The request was denied.
The Newspaper Guild-CWA , IBEW Local 1212, and the Teamsters, which represent employees at the Tribune-owned Baltimore Sun and WPIX-TV in New York, has asked the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware to block the company’s plan to pay up to $69.9 million in executive bonus this year, including $20.6 million to the 10 top managers (about $2 million each). Some 700 other managers would share in the bonus booty.
While the Tribune Co. is coddling its execs and managers with bonuses, its attitude toward employees was starkly demonstrated in late April when the Baltimore Sun laid off 61 newsroom employees, one-third of its news-gathering operation.
Some employees were fired while they were in the midst of writing and editing stories. Others were told to pack up their belongings immediately, and still others were escorted out of the main newspaper building by security guards.
Along with the Sun, the Tribune Co., owns the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times and other media properties.
In its filing with the court, the Guild noted the company has laid off hundreds of employees, shrunk its products and imposed a wage freeze on most employees. (Only those under union contracts continue to get raises.)
At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes.
While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management.
One of the top executives seeking the $2 million bonus said in an e-mail to employees in February that “a salary freeze enables us to share the sacrifice.” It’s not clear how a $2 million bonus enables the top managers to share the sacrifice.
The Bankruptcy Court is scheduled to review the bonus plan Aug. 11, but the unions asked the court to delay its review until the Tribune makes more information available.
Senior Staff Writer
http://cincinnati.bizjournals.com/
A Delaware bankruptcy judge is hearing arguments Tuesday on whether Randy Michaels and other top executives of the Tribune Co. should be eligible for nearly $70 million in bonuses from the bankrupt newspaper company.
You may remember that Michaels led a small army of former Jacor Communications Inc. business managers to Chicago in 2008 to reshape the media empire acquired by Chicago billionaire Sam Zell.
After several months of job cuts and controversial business changes, the Tribune Co. filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in December.
This new controversy comes from the Tribune’s request for bankruptcy court approval of a new bonus plan, filed in early August. The company requested that it be kept under seal, but the court rejected that idea.
The proposal calls for new incentive payments to some 700 business managers, including $20.6 million to the Tribune’s top 10 execs, according to this AFL-CIO blog entry.
As you might expect, unions that claim membership at Tribune-owned newspaper and television stations don’t think too highly of Michaels' argument in court documents that “we must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles.”
Here’s a summary of the reaction to the new pay plan at Broadcast Union News.
Tribune CEOs seek $70 Million in Bonuses as Company Sinks
by John Small, Aug 8, 2009
AFL/CIO News
It’s not like we needed one more example of greedy corporate executives at a bankrupt company making a grab for big bonuses while axing hundreds of employees and freezing wages for many others.
But that’s what Tribune Co. executives are doing as the multimedia conglomerate sinks under the weight of $13 billion in debt incurred by its corporate leaders in 2007. And they want to keep the bonuses a big secret.
The company filed for Chapter 11 protection last December and, in its most recent action, is seeking court permission to dole out nearly $70 million in executive bonuses. The company also requested the court seal much of the request. The request was denied.
The Newspaper Guild-CWA , IBEW Local 1212, and the Teamsters, which represent employees at the Tribune-owned Baltimore Sun and WPIX-TV in New York, has asked the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware to block the company’s plan to pay up to $69.9 million in executive bonus this year, including $20.6 million to the 10 top managers (about $2 million each). Some 700 other managers would share in the bonus booty.
While the Tribune Co. is coddling its execs and managers with bonuses, its attitude toward employees was starkly demonstrated in late April when the Baltimore Sun laid off 61 newsroom employees, one-third of its news-gathering operation.
Some employees were fired while they were in the midst of writing and editing stories. Others were told to pack up their belongings immediately, and still others were escorted out of the main newspaper building by security guards.
Along with the Sun, the Tribune Co., owns the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times and other media properties.
In its filing with the court, the Guild noted the company has laid off hundreds of employees, shrunk its products and imposed a wage freeze on most employees. (Only those under union contracts continue to get raises.)
At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes.
While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management.
One of the top executives seeking the $2 million bonus said in an e-mail to employees in February that “a salary freeze enables us to share the sacrifice.” It’s not clear how a $2 million bonus enables the top managers to share the sacrifice.
The Bankruptcy Court is scheduled to review the bonus plan Aug. 11, but the unions asked the court to delay its review until the Tribune makes more information available.
Saturday, August 8, 2009
Jeff Wurtz, Co-Founder announces new company: SCENIOS
Hi All,
I'm very proud to announce our new startup company, Scenios. Please sign-up and be part of our private Beta launch. I welcome your feedback so feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
Scenios LLC Announces Company and Angel FundingNew York City-Based Company to Provide Cloud-Based Digital Asset Platform and Community for Professionals; Emmy Award Winning Founders to Launch Without Seeking Venture Capital.
August 6, 2009 — New York — Scenios™, LLC — a stealth company developing a cloud-based Digital Asset Management platform integrated with search and social networking components- today announced initial details of its funding in preparation for a September beta launch. Geared to the multimedia professional and founded by Emmy®-award winning producers and editors (5 Emmys with one founder alone), Scenios also has an equally strong technical team in place.
Scenios will be supported on Mac® OS X®, Microsoft® Windows®, Linux® and iPhone® and is based on open technology standards such as H.264 and HTTP 5. All rights-managed assets that are uploaded to Scenios will be searchable and Scenios supports open API frameworks to allow its community to leverage other sites and technologies.
In a unique situation given the current world economic crisis, Scenios is not seeking additional capital beyond its angel funding. The founders are confident that Scenios will quickly generate more-than-sufficient revenue upon launch to support rapid growth and profit.
Scenios is not disclosing the amount of its angel funding round or sources, except to say that it is less than $2M US — this is to preserve the specifics of its platform and business model prior to launch.
"Scenios is the end-result of a vision shared by all of the company founders to enable a new class of Digital Asset Management geared to the multimedia professional as well as the 'prosumer'," said Mark Davis, one of the Scenios founders. "While we recognize that not seeking VC dollars is a bit unusual in this economy, we have raised more than sufficient funds to launch Scenios and we expect to achieve solid revenues and profits from launch. We believe that any company with sufficient 'sweat equity', expertise and vision can achieve a successful launch even without the backing of the VC community and intend to prove just that point."
About Scenios
Scenios is a 'stealth' startup based in New York City focusing on the convergence of Cloud-based Digital Asset Management, professional community building and open technology standards. The company is expected to launch in late 3rd quarter of 2009 — interested multimedia professionals can register in advance for details at http://www.scenios.com.
Best Regards,
Jeff Wurtz
Chief Evangelist
O- 917 832 1562
C- 516 772 8248
Jwurtz@scenios.com
I'm very proud to announce our new startup company, Scenios. Please sign-up and be part of our private Beta launch. I welcome your feedback so feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
Scenios LLC Announces Company and Angel FundingNew York City-Based Company to Provide Cloud-Based Digital Asset Platform and Community for Professionals; Emmy Award Winning Founders to Launch Without Seeking Venture Capital.
August 6, 2009 — New York — Scenios™, LLC — a stealth company developing a cloud-based Digital Asset Management platform integrated with search and social networking components- today announced initial details of its funding in preparation for a September beta launch. Geared to the multimedia professional and founded by Emmy®-award winning producers and editors (5 Emmys with one founder alone), Scenios also has an equally strong technical team in place.
Scenios will be supported on Mac® OS X®, Microsoft® Windows®, Linux® and iPhone® and is based on open technology standards such as H.264 and HTTP 5. All rights-managed assets that are uploaded to Scenios will be searchable and Scenios supports open API frameworks to allow its community to leverage other sites and technologies.
In a unique situation given the current world economic crisis, Scenios is not seeking additional capital beyond its angel funding. The founders are confident that Scenios will quickly generate more-than-sufficient revenue upon launch to support rapid growth and profit.
Scenios is not disclosing the amount of its angel funding round or sources, except to say that it is less than $2M US — this is to preserve the specifics of its platform and business model prior to launch.
"Scenios is the end-result of a vision shared by all of the company founders to enable a new class of Digital Asset Management geared to the multimedia professional as well as the 'prosumer'," said Mark Davis, one of the Scenios founders. "While we recognize that not seeking VC dollars is a bit unusual in this economy, we have raised more than sufficient funds to launch Scenios and we expect to achieve solid revenues and profits from launch. We believe that any company with sufficient 'sweat equity', expertise and vision can achieve a successful launch even without the backing of the VC community and intend to prove just that point."
About Scenios
Scenios is a 'stealth' startup based in New York City focusing on the convergence of Cloud-based Digital Asset Management, professional community building and open technology standards. The company is expected to launch in late 3rd quarter of 2009 — interested multimedia professionals can register in advance for details at http://www.scenios.com.
Best Regards,
Jeff Wurtz
Chief Evangelist
O- 917 832 1562
C- 516 772 8248
Jwurtz@scenios.com
M.A. in Labor Studies at CUNY Murphy Institute for Labor Studies
The Murphy Institute for Worker Education and Labor
Studies was established in collaboration with New York City
labor unions and the City University of New York.
About the new M.A. in Labor Studies The Master of Arts in Labor Studies is offered by the the Murphy Institute for Worker Education and Labor Studies and the School of Professional Studies. Labor Studies,
broadly defined as the study of work, workers and workers'
organizations, is increasingly relevant for professionals in
the labor movement and in labor-related fields who must
keep up with the intellectual demands posed by a rapidly
changing and ever-more complex global economy and culture.
In order to meet these demands, the curriculum of this new
M.A. program is interdisciplinary and comprehensive in scope,
drawing from sociology, economics, history, global studies,
political science, and cultural studies. It is grounded in current
economic and social conditions and informed by historical
analyses of work, workers and workers' institutions, nationally
and globally.
The degree prepares students for effective leadership in the labor movement; gives those in labor-related fields specialized knowledge; and provides opportunities for advanced scholarship in many areas of social science. Students in the Master of Arts in Labor Studies will study
with renowned faculty from across The City University of
New York as well as with expert practitioners in the field.
Degree Requirements:
To earn the M.A. in Labor Studies, students must complete 30 credits, distributed among seven required courses and three electives..
Labor leaders and allies of organized labor have long acknowledged the need for educated professionals who can develop successful strategies for growth and sustainability.
The goal of the Masters of Arts in Labor Studies is to foster a new population of professional union leadership and staff, as well as to encourage those aspiring to professional careers in labor or related fields.
It is a professional degree that serves the leadership needs of organized labor in New York City and across the nation. Graduates will contribute to shaping the future of New York and other urban centers. Students in this M.A. program will be introduced to a rich and varied intellectual community. They will be challenged by a rigorous curriculum, designed to meet CUNY standards of excellence and innovation in education.
The program requires 30 credits for completion, divided among seven required courses (including a final capstone course) and three out of six electives.
Required Courses:
1. Labor in the Era of Globalization
2. Theories and Perspectives on the Labor Movement
3. Labor and the Economy
4. Research Methods
5. Labor Law
6. Labor-Management Relations
7. Capstone Course
Electives:
1. U.S. Labor History from 1929 to the Present
2. Issues in Organizing
3. Labor and Politics
4. Comparative Labor Movements
5. Policy Analysis
6. Labor Studies Field Work/Internship
Tuition Rates:
Effective for the fall 2009 semester, New York State residents will pay $310 per credit, and out-of-state residents will pay $575 per credit.
Some students may be eligible for union tuition benefits.
To speak with a Murphy Institute admissions representative
about this program and the application process,
please call: (212) 827-0200.
The Murphy Institute is part of the
School for Professional Studiesand the Graduate School and University CenterThe City University of New York
25 West 43rd Street
New York, NY 10036-7406
Tel: 212.827.0200 Fax: 212.827.5955
65-30 Kissena Boulevard
Flushing, NY 11367
Tel: 718.997.3060 Fax: 718.997.3069
Studies was established in collaboration with New York City
labor unions and the City University of New York.
About the new M.A. in Labor Studies The Master of Arts in Labor Studies is offered by the the Murphy Institute for Worker Education and Labor Studies and the School of Professional Studies. Labor Studies,
broadly defined as the study of work, workers and workers'
organizations, is increasingly relevant for professionals in
the labor movement and in labor-related fields who must
keep up with the intellectual demands posed by a rapidly
changing and ever-more complex global economy and culture.
In order to meet these demands, the curriculum of this new
M.A. program is interdisciplinary and comprehensive in scope,
drawing from sociology, economics, history, global studies,
political science, and cultural studies. It is grounded in current
economic and social conditions and informed by historical
analyses of work, workers and workers' institutions, nationally
and globally.
The degree prepares students for effective leadership in the labor movement; gives those in labor-related fields specialized knowledge; and provides opportunities for advanced scholarship in many areas of social science. Students in the Master of Arts in Labor Studies will study
with renowned faculty from across The City University of
New York as well as with expert practitioners in the field.
Degree Requirements:
To earn the M.A. in Labor Studies, students must complete 30 credits, distributed among seven required courses and three electives..
Labor leaders and allies of organized labor have long acknowledged the need for educated professionals who can develop successful strategies for growth and sustainability.
The goal of the Masters of Arts in Labor Studies is to foster a new population of professional union leadership and staff, as well as to encourage those aspiring to professional careers in labor or related fields.
It is a professional degree that serves the leadership needs of organized labor in New York City and across the nation. Graduates will contribute to shaping the future of New York and other urban centers. Students in this M.A. program will be introduced to a rich and varied intellectual community. They will be challenged by a rigorous curriculum, designed to meet CUNY standards of excellence and innovation in education.
The program requires 30 credits for completion, divided among seven required courses (including a final capstone course) and three out of six electives.
Required Courses:
1. Labor in the Era of Globalization
2. Theories and Perspectives on the Labor Movement
3. Labor and the Economy
4. Research Methods
5. Labor Law
6. Labor-Management Relations
7. Capstone Course
Electives:
1. U.S. Labor History from 1929 to the Present
2. Issues in Organizing
3. Labor and Politics
4. Comparative Labor Movements
5. Policy Analysis
6. Labor Studies Field Work/Internship
Tuition Rates:
Effective for the fall 2009 semester, New York State residents will pay $310 per credit, and out-of-state residents will pay $575 per credit.
Some students may be eligible for union tuition benefits.
To speak with a Murphy Institute admissions representative
about this program and the application process,
please call: (212) 827-0200.
The Murphy Institute is part of the
School for Professional Studiesand the Graduate School and University CenterThe City University of New York
25 West 43rd Street
New York, NY 10036-7406
Tel: 212.827.0200 Fax: 212.827.5955
65-30 Kissena Boulevard
Flushing, NY 11367
Tel: 718.997.3060 Fax: 718.997.3069
Friday, August 7, 2009
Unions Outraged Over Bankrupt Tribune Company's $67 Million Dollar Executive Bonus Plan
Broadcast Union News
http://broadcastunionnews.blogspot.com/
Delaware Bankruptcy Court Judge Kevin Carey will hear arguments on August 11, 2009, in a dispute over the Tribune Co.'s request to approve executive bonuses totaling about $70 million for the company's top managers.
The Newspaper Guild unit at The Baltimore Sun has filed an objection in bankruptcy court to Tribune Company plans to award some $69.9 million in bonuses to top executives, claiming the move is unfair to rank-and-file employees.
The Guild was joined in thier objection by the Newspaper Guild of New York, which represents 29 employees at television station WPIX, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1212, representing just under 100 staff and freelance broadcast engineers at WPIX, two Baltimore-based Teamsters locals, and NABET-CWA.
While the numbed survivors of Sam Zell's ill advised Tribune take over struggle with higher health care premiums, loss of pensions, reduced pay and work hours, those overseeing this wreckage have told the bankruptcy judge that if they don't get more executive compensation, things will get really bad.
"Incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," Tribune's chief operating officer and its chief administrative officer wrote this month to a federal bankruptcy judge, seeking the court's approval of a plan to pay up to $69.9 million in management bonuses. "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level," they explained.
The objection was filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware on Tuesday, according to a copy of the motion.
It states: "the proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line. Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."
Bill Salganik, president of the guild unit, said in an e-mail that the company's action is unacceptable: "If Tribune has $69.9 million available to spend, we think it would be better spent on providing more and better news and service for readers and viewers and advertisers. That would not only serve the public better, but would be better for the business in the long run."
Tribune Co. contends that the incentives are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization, and to attract top-tier management talent if needed.
Tribune Co. attorneys say that compensation report needs to be kept under wraps because disclosure of compensation information and confidential business goals it contains could provide an advantage to competitors.
"Moreover, such information likely would affect employee morale and potentially create resentment among certain employees of the debtors as they compared their compensation to that of their peers, and could adversely impair the debtors' ability to negotiate and maintain favorable employment agreements in the future," Tribune Co. attorneys wrote in seeking to keep the report under seal.
Bob Daraio, former staff video engineer at WPIX said; "Tribune's assertion that incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," apparantly only applies to their already highly compensated executives and does not take in to account the damage this action will cause to the rest of Tribune's employees."
According to Andy Zipzer, editor of the Guild Reporter; "The best employees are motivated to do their best for a variety of reasons that have less to do with money and more to do with loyalty to the employer, pride in one's work, and a sense of responsibility."
Mr. Daraio concurs; " Loyalty, sacrifice, and responsibility is what Tribune management expects from the non-executive employees, how can they expect less from the corporate leadership? Handing out bonuses to the few, while cutting the pay and benefits of the rest, serves only to erode the employee loyalty and support that is vital to saving Tribune."
Tribune, which owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Baltimore Sun, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007
__________
Hey Bob,
How come NOBODY points out this little factoid:
With the economy shrinking and job losses amassing by the hundreds of thousands every month executive choice of positions is also curtailed. Thus the argument that "we need to incentivise executives" to keep quality management is rendered invalid: if someone wishes to quit their job, they will have no other positions available therefore they will stay. If they choose to quit anyway they would not have contributed much to the well being of the company in all probability had they stayed because of a bonus.
Yeah, I know... it's not a factoid per se, but it is a relevant argument against paying extra money to the thieves that caused the problem to begin with.
Best,
Danny
http://broadcastunionnews.blogspot.com/
Delaware Bankruptcy Court Judge Kevin Carey will hear arguments on August 11, 2009, in a dispute over the Tribune Co.'s request to approve executive bonuses totaling about $70 million for the company's top managers.
The Newspaper Guild unit at The Baltimore Sun has filed an objection in bankruptcy court to Tribune Company plans to award some $69.9 million in bonuses to top executives, claiming the move is unfair to rank-and-file employees.
The Guild was joined in thier objection by the Newspaper Guild of New York, which represents 29 employees at television station WPIX, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1212, representing just under 100 staff and freelance broadcast engineers at WPIX, two Baltimore-based Teamsters locals, and NABET-CWA.
While the numbed survivors of Sam Zell's ill advised Tribune take over struggle with higher health care premiums, loss of pensions, reduced pay and work hours, those overseeing this wreckage have told the bankruptcy judge that if they don't get more executive compensation, things will get really bad.
"Incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," Tribune's chief operating officer and its chief administrative officer wrote this month to a federal bankruptcy judge, seeking the court's approval of a plan to pay up to $69.9 million in management bonuses. "We must continue motivating our people to overcome obstacles, achieve our performance goals and take the company to the next level," they explained.
The objection was filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware on Tuesday, according to a copy of the motion.
It states: "the proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line. Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."
Bill Salganik, president of the guild unit, said in an e-mail that the company's action is unacceptable: "If Tribune has $69.9 million available to spend, we think it would be better spent on providing more and better news and service for readers and viewers and advertisers. That would not only serve the public better, but would be better for the business in the long run."
Tribune Co. contends that the incentives are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization, and to attract top-tier management talent if needed.
Tribune Co. attorneys say that compensation report needs to be kept under wraps because disclosure of compensation information and confidential business goals it contains could provide an advantage to competitors.
"Moreover, such information likely would affect employee morale and potentially create resentment among certain employees of the debtors as they compared their compensation to that of their peers, and could adversely impair the debtors' ability to negotiate and maintain favorable employment agreements in the future," Tribune Co. attorneys wrote in seeking to keep the report under seal.
Bob Daraio, former staff video engineer at WPIX said; "Tribune's assertion that incentivizing employees is essential to Tribune's future success," apparantly only applies to their already highly compensated executives and does not take in to account the damage this action will cause to the rest of Tribune's employees."
According to Andy Zipzer, editor of the Guild Reporter; "The best employees are motivated to do their best for a variety of reasons that have less to do with money and more to do with loyalty to the employer, pride in one's work, and a sense of responsibility."
Mr. Daraio concurs; " Loyalty, sacrifice, and responsibility is what Tribune management expects from the non-executive employees, how can they expect less from the corporate leadership? Handing out bonuses to the few, while cutting the pay and benefits of the rest, serves only to erode the employee loyalty and support that is vital to saving Tribune."
Tribune, which owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Baltimore Sun, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007
__________
Hey Bob,
How come NOBODY points out this little factoid:
With the economy shrinking and job losses amassing by the hundreds of thousands every month executive choice of positions is also curtailed. Thus the argument that "we need to incentivise executives" to keep quality management is rendered invalid: if someone wishes to quit their job, they will have no other positions available therefore they will stay. If they choose to quit anyway they would not have contributed much to the well being of the company in all probability had they stayed because of a bonus.
Yeah, I know... it's not a factoid per se, but it is a relevant argument against paying extra money to the thieves that caused the problem to begin with.
Best,
Danny
'Baltimore Sun' Guild Files Motion Against Tribune Bonus Plan
By Joe Strupp
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1004000231
NEW YORK: The Newspaper Guild unit at The Baltimore Sun has filed an objection in bankruptcy court to Tribune Company plans to award some $69.9 million in bonuses to top executives, claiming the move is unfair to rank-and-file employees.
The objection was filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware on Tuesday, according to a copy of the motion. It states: "the proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line. Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."Bill Salganik, president of the guild unit, said in an e-mail that the company's action is unacceptable: "If Tribune has $69.9 million available to spend, we think it would be better spent on providing more and better news and service for readers and viewers and advertisers. That would not only serve the public better, but would be better for the business in the long run."A hearing on the Tribune request for the bonuses is set for Aug. 11.
Tribune filed for bankruptcy protection last December.
Joe Strupp (jstrupp@editorandpublisher.com) is a senior editor at E&P.
Tribune Co. bonus Plan To Be Heard In Court
(AP) — A Delaware bankruptcy judge agreed Thursday to hear arguments next week in a dispute over the Tribune Co.'s request to approve bonuses totaling about $70 million for the company's top managers.
Judge Kevin Carey agreed to a Tribune Co. request for an expedited hearing on its motion seeking to prevent the release of a compensation consultant's report to a labor union challenging the bonus plans. The judge is scheduled to hear arguments Tuesday, in conjunction with a previously scheduled hearing in Chicago-based Tribune Co.'s Chapter 11 case.
In an objection filed this week, the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild said the bonuses are unwarranted and requested access to the compensation report that Tribune has filed under seal.
"At a time when media businesses are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," attorneys for the guild wrote. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims, and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
The guild is joined in its objection by the Newspaper Guild of New York, which represents 29 employees at television station WPIX, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1212, representing just under 100 staff and freelance broadcast engineers at WPIX, and by two Baltimore-based Teamsters locals.
Tribune, which owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Baltimore Sun, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007.
Tribune Co. contends that the incentives are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization, and to attract top-tier management talent if needed.
Tribune Co. attorneys say they have offered to share the compensation report with the guild, but that the guild has refused to agree to confidentiality provisions. The company has argued that the report needs to be kept under wraps because disclosure of compensation information and confidential business goals it contains could provide an advantage to competitors.
"Moreover, such information likely would affect employee morale and potentially create resentment among certain employees of the debtors as they compared their compensation to that of their peers, and could adversely impair the debtors' ability to negotiate and maintain favorable employment agreements in the future," Tribune Co. attorneys wrote in seeking to keep the report under seal.
Tribune Co. notes in court filings that its creditors committee, which includes a representative of the guild, supports the bonus plan, as does a steering committee of the company's senior lenders.
The U.S. trustee in the case, while not formally objecting, has said Tribune Co. has not provided sufficient information to justify the bonus plans or the sealing of the consultant's report.
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1004000231
NEW YORK: The Newspaper Guild unit at The Baltimore Sun has filed an objection in bankruptcy court to Tribune Company plans to award some $69.9 million in bonuses to top executives, claiming the move is unfair to rank-and-file employees.
The objection was filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware on Tuesday, according to a copy of the motion. It states: "the proposed bonuses to top executives are excessive and may, in fact, have a detrimental effect on motivating others who contribute to the bottom line. Indeed, the payment of disproportionate bonuses to a select group of executives may have the opposite effect on the rank-and-file employees."Bill Salganik, president of the guild unit, said in an e-mail that the company's action is unacceptable: "If Tribune has $69.9 million available to spend, we think it would be better spent on providing more and better news and service for readers and viewers and advertisers. That would not only serve the public better, but would be better for the business in the long run."A hearing on the Tribune request for the bonuses is set for Aug. 11.
Tribune filed for bankruptcy protection last December.
Joe Strupp (jstrupp@editorandpublisher.com) is a senior editor at E&P.
Tribune Co. bonus Plan To Be Heard In Court
(AP) — A Delaware bankruptcy judge agreed Thursday to hear arguments next week in a dispute over the Tribune Co.'s request to approve bonuses totaling about $70 million for the company's top managers.
Judge Kevin Carey agreed to a Tribune Co. request for an expedited hearing on its motion seeking to prevent the release of a compensation consultant's report to a labor union challenging the bonus plans. The judge is scheduled to hear arguments Tuesday, in conjunction with a previously scheduled hearing in Chicago-based Tribune Co.'s Chapter 11 case.
In an objection filed this week, the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild said the bonuses are unwarranted and requested access to the compensation report that Tribune has filed under seal.
"At a time when media businesses are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," attorneys for the guild wrote. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims, and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
The guild is joined in its objection by the Newspaper Guild of New York, which represents 29 employees at television station WPIX, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1212, representing just under 100 staff and freelance broadcast engineers at WPIX, and by two Baltimore-based Teamsters locals.
Tribune, which owns the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Baltimore Sun, The Hartford Courant and other dailies, as well as 23 TV stations, sought bankruptcy protection in December because of dwindling advertising revenues and a $13 billion debt. Much of that debt was amassed when real estate mogul Sam Zell took the Tribune Co. private in late 2007.
Tribune Co. contends that the incentives are based on specific performance targets and are needed to retain key employees facing significant industry challenges while working toward a successful reorganization, and to attract top-tier management talent if needed.
Tribune Co. attorneys say they have offered to share the compensation report with the guild, but that the guild has refused to agree to confidentiality provisions. The company has argued that the report needs to be kept under wraps because disclosure of compensation information and confidential business goals it contains could provide an advantage to competitors.
"Moreover, such information likely would affect employee morale and potentially create resentment among certain employees of the debtors as they compared their compensation to that of their peers, and could adversely impair the debtors' ability to negotiate and maintain favorable employment agreements in the future," Tribune Co. attorneys wrote in seeking to keep the report under seal.
Tribune Co. notes in court filings that its creditors committee, which includes a representative of the guild, supports the bonus plan, as does a steering committee of the company's senior lenders.
The U.S. trustee in the case, while not formally objecting, has said Tribune Co. has not provided sufficient information to justify the bonus plans or the sealing of the consultant's report.
Thursday, August 6, 2009
CWA Newsletter: TNG-CWA Wins Landmark E-Mail Case After 9-Year Battle
"CWA Communications Department" news@cwa-union.org
In a big victory for TNG-CWA members in Oregon, the U.S. Court of Appeals not only upheld their appeal over union use of company e-mail, it also slammed the infamous union-busting lawyer who told managers to pursue the case.
The Washington D.C. Court's sharply worded July decision characterized lawyer Michael Zinser's arguments as "simply more distortion than the words can bear." Zinser is known for trying to break newspaper unions.
The case began at the Eugene Register-Guard in 2000, when managers disciplined the president of TNG-CWA Local 37194 for using the company's e-mail system to send three e-mails about Guild business.
The e-mails were sent after work hours.
The Guild filed unfair labor practice charges, but the then Bush-dominated NLRB vote sided with the company over two of the mailings.
The company claimed that e-mail could only be used for business purposes, but the Guild was able to present abundant evidence that the company's e-mail system was used by both employees and managers for a wide assortment of news – from baby shower invitations to requests for United Way volunteers.
The evidence proved the union was the only exception, and the U.S. Court of Appeals agreed. Its decision showed irritation not only with Zinser but with the NLRB, saying the board's rationale smacked of "a post hoc invention."
"The court's decision made it clear that the company had discriminated based on union activity," TNG-CWA President Bernie Lunzer said. "I was at the Court of Appeals when Michael Zinser presented his case, and a jury of kindergarteners could have seen through it. He tried to argue that the union was a special case and could be barred from communicating by company e-mail, even though everyone else was allowed to use it freely."
NABET-CWA to Union-Busting NBC: 'We'll Walk and Take Advertisers With Us'
In a move to bust the union, NBC is demanding a change in job titles but not work functions so it can remove positions from the bargaining unit.
Undeterred, NABET-CWA members at network-owned stations in four cities have voted overwhelmingly to strike, if necessary.
NABET-CWA Vice President Jim Joyce said NBC has unilaterally switched some jobs to the vague title of "content producer" and wants to switch many more, potentially affecting 200 workers. "The work itself doesn't change; people are largely doing the same jobs they've been doing through their careers as editors, news photographers and news writers," he said. "But they are being forced to reapply as 'content producers' with no union contract." The union has filed numerous unfair labor practice charges against NBC.
The workers plan to increase informational picketing outside NBC studios that employ 2,500 NABET members in Washington, D.C., New York, Chicago and Los Angeles. Meanwhile, NABET-CWA President John Clark says the union is contacting newsmakers and advertisers asking them to boycott NBC.
"The favorable strike authorization vote shows that our membership understands the significance and danger of the issues confronting us in these negotiations," Clark said. "We will do everything we can to defeat NBC Universal's attempt at union-busting, including the hand-billing of on-air sponsors to inform them of the dispute, and contacting labor-friendly politicians and other public figures to request that they not appear on NBC's news shows."
Bargaining began in September, six months before the contract expired on March 31, 2009. Talks so far have failed to get NBC to budge on critical issues. Besides trying to take away work NABET members have done for decades, the company wants changes in the seniority system that could hurt career workers.
In a big victory for TNG-CWA members in Oregon, the U.S. Court of Appeals not only upheld their appeal over union use of company e-mail, it also slammed the infamous union-busting lawyer who told managers to pursue the case.
The Washington D.C. Court's sharply worded July decision characterized lawyer Michael Zinser's arguments as "simply more distortion than the words can bear." Zinser is known for trying to break newspaper unions.
The case began at the Eugene Register-Guard in 2000, when managers disciplined the president of TNG-CWA Local 37194 for using the company's e-mail system to send three e-mails about Guild business.
The e-mails were sent after work hours.
The Guild filed unfair labor practice charges, but the then Bush-dominated NLRB vote sided with the company over two of the mailings.
The company claimed that e-mail could only be used for business purposes, but the Guild was able to present abundant evidence that the company's e-mail system was used by both employees and managers for a wide assortment of news – from baby shower invitations to requests for United Way volunteers.
The evidence proved the union was the only exception, and the U.S. Court of Appeals agreed. Its decision showed irritation not only with Zinser but with the NLRB, saying the board's rationale smacked of "a post hoc invention."
"The court's decision made it clear that the company had discriminated based on union activity," TNG-CWA President Bernie Lunzer said. "I was at the Court of Appeals when Michael Zinser presented his case, and a jury of kindergarteners could have seen through it. He tried to argue that the union was a special case and could be barred from communicating by company e-mail, even though everyone else was allowed to use it freely."
NABET-CWA to Union-Busting NBC: 'We'll Walk and Take Advertisers With Us'
In a move to bust the union, NBC is demanding a change in job titles but not work functions so it can remove positions from the bargaining unit.
Undeterred, NABET-CWA members at network-owned stations in four cities have voted overwhelmingly to strike, if necessary.
NABET-CWA Vice President Jim Joyce said NBC has unilaterally switched some jobs to the vague title of "content producer" and wants to switch many more, potentially affecting 200 workers. "The work itself doesn't change; people are largely doing the same jobs they've been doing through their careers as editors, news photographers and news writers," he said. "But they are being forced to reapply as 'content producers' with no union contract." The union has filed numerous unfair labor practice charges against NBC.
The workers plan to increase informational picketing outside NBC studios that employ 2,500 NABET members in Washington, D.C., New York, Chicago and Los Angeles. Meanwhile, NABET-CWA President John Clark says the union is contacting newsmakers and advertisers asking them to boycott NBC.
"The favorable strike authorization vote shows that our membership understands the significance and danger of the issues confronting us in these negotiations," Clark said. "We will do everything we can to defeat NBC Universal's attempt at union-busting, including the hand-billing of on-air sponsors to inform them of the dispute, and contacting labor-friendly politicians and other public figures to request that they not appear on NBC's news shows."
Bargaining began in September, six months before the contract expired on March 31, 2009. Talks so far have failed to get NBC to budge on critical issues. Besides trying to take away work NABET members have done for decades, the company wants changes in the seniority system that could hurt career workers.
Tribune Co. Bonus Plan Draws Questions
U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee And Four Unions Object To Payment Request
The U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee in Tribune Co.'s Chapter 11 case and four of the company's unions have raised objections to management's plan to pay out tens of millions of dollars in performance bonuses.
The filings came Tuesday and Wednesday in response to Tribune Co.'s July 22 request for authorization from the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware to pay from $21.5 million to almost $67 million in bonuses to more than 700 managers and other key employees.Tribune Co., which owns the Chicago Tribune, also sought to pay nine of its top 10 executives $3.1 million in belated 2008 bonuses.
In its response to Tribune Co.'s motion, the U.S. trustee said the company didn't provide enough data to justify its incentive plan. The trustee said there is "insufficient information" in the motion to prove that the payments are for what management called "bona fide incentive programs and awards based on real performance targets."The trustee, which is charged with enforcing bankruptcy laws, said the awards are based on meeting specific cash flow targets but that Tribune Co. does not "give any factual and/or historical context to back up their characterization of that performance target as being 'real.' "
It also questions whether the awards are in the "ordinary course of business," as required by law.
Consequently, the trustee said the company should provide cash-flow targets for 2006 through 2008 and actual performance against those targets. Likewise, Tribune Co. should provide projections and actual results for 2009.
The trustee said it reserves the right to supplement its response once it has more information. It objected to Tribune Co.'s request to seal parts of a consultant's report filed in support of its motion.
Tribune Co. said in a statement: "The motion now before the court has the support of our senior lenders and the unsecured creditors committee. Importantly, the bulk of these incentive programs benefit more than 700 employees across the company and are performance-based. We believe our 2009 incentive program is both moderate and reasonable."
Four of Tribune Co.'s unions, meanwhile, lodged their own objections to the plans. The Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild, which sits on the unsecured creditors committee in Tribune Co.'s case and represents employees at The Sun, Tribune Co.'s daily in Baltimore, filed an objection which was joined by local units of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters in Baltimore, the Communications Workers of America, and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, in New York.
"At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," a union filing said. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
Among other claims, the unions question whether the goals set by the bonus plans are challenging enough. "The [bonus plan] is not designed to drive employee performance toward challenging goals which are subject to the risks of the marketplace," the filing said.
Tribune Co., which filed for Chapter 11 protection last December because it was struggling to manage the heavy debt it took on in going private a year earlier, has said that the bonus payments are needed to motivate managers working under difficult conditions. They will only be paid in full if the company well exceeds performance targets.
The U.S. Bankruptcy Trustee in Tribune Co.'s Chapter 11 case and four of the company's unions have raised objections to management's plan to pay out tens of millions of dollars in performance bonuses.
The filings came Tuesday and Wednesday in response to Tribune Co.'s July 22 request for authorization from the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware to pay from $21.5 million to almost $67 million in bonuses to more than 700 managers and other key employees.Tribune Co., which owns the Chicago Tribune, also sought to pay nine of its top 10 executives $3.1 million in belated 2008 bonuses.
In its response to Tribune Co.'s motion, the U.S. trustee said the company didn't provide enough data to justify its incentive plan. The trustee said there is "insufficient information" in the motion to prove that the payments are for what management called "bona fide incentive programs and awards based on real performance targets."The trustee, which is charged with enforcing bankruptcy laws, said the awards are based on meeting specific cash flow targets but that Tribune Co. does not "give any factual and/or historical context to back up their characterization of that performance target as being 'real.' "
It also questions whether the awards are in the "ordinary course of business," as required by law.
Consequently, the trustee said the company should provide cash-flow targets for 2006 through 2008 and actual performance against those targets. Likewise, Tribune Co. should provide projections and actual results for 2009.
The trustee said it reserves the right to supplement its response once it has more information. It objected to Tribune Co.'s request to seal parts of a consultant's report filed in support of its motion.
Tribune Co. said in a statement: "The motion now before the court has the support of our senior lenders and the unsecured creditors committee. Importantly, the bulk of these incentive programs benefit more than 700 employees across the company and are performance-based. We believe our 2009 incentive program is both moderate and reasonable."
Four of Tribune Co.'s unions, meanwhile, lodged their own objections to the plans. The Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild, which sits on the unsecured creditors committee in Tribune Co.'s case and represents employees at The Sun, Tribune Co.'s daily in Baltimore, filed an objection which was joined by local units of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters in Baltimore, the Communications Workers of America, and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, in New York.
"At a time when media companies are suffering incomparable losses and struggling to survive, the Debtors have proposed spending $69.9 million to reward their top management for financial performance that, year-over-year, evidences declining fortunes," a union filing said. "While creditors face limited recovery on their claims and most rank-and-file employees live with frozen pay and benefits, the Debtors believe a proper exercise of business judgment results in millions of dollars distributed to management."
Among other claims, the unions question whether the goals set by the bonus plans are challenging enough. "The [bonus plan] is not designed to drive employee performance toward challenging goals which are subject to the risks of the marketplace," the filing said.
Tribune Co., which filed for Chapter 11 protection last December because it was struggling to manage the heavy debt it took on in going private a year earlier, has said that the bonus payments are needed to motivate managers working under difficult conditions. They will only be paid in full if the company well exceeds performance targets.
Wednesday, August 5, 2009
As Local Sharing Progresses, New Concerns Emerge
By Hillary Atkin
TV Week
New. Experimental. Here to Stay?
That would be the tease for the rapidly spreading practice of fiercely competitive television stations joining to pool their resources as a way to reduce costs and expand coverage.
The pooling of broadcast news video, also known as local news sharing (LNS), is a concept that has caught fire in recent months—but not without controversy—and is under way in several dozen markets, including all five of the nation’s largest DMAs.
“In these challenging economic times, we began discussions on how to be more efficient,” said Sharri Berg, senior VP of news operations for Fox Television Stations, which has 12 of its stations participating with local competitors in news-pooling arrangements. “The result was not only cost efficiency, but this gave us flexibility in directing our own unilateral resources. If we’re covering a local news conference, if a station wants to send a reporter, it’s their choice. LNS in no way constrains or dictates, but in fact gives stations more options.”
Many major station groups are taking part, including stations affiliated with and/or owned by the NBC Television Network, Tribune Broadcasting, Gannett Broadcasting, CBS Broadcasting, Scripps Television Station Group, McGraw-Hill Broadcasting and Sinclair Broadcast Group.
The practice is not without critics, however, who argue that it decreases competition, costs jobs, blurs the individuality of stations and limits the ability to cover stories.
There’s no question about the financial benefits, however. “We’ve got to be smarter businessmen,” said Steve Charlier, senior VP of news and operations at Tribune Broadcasting stations. “Our goal was to operate efficiently and improve content, and be able to grow, to put more bodies in the street, and have more content.”
The practice of pooling broadcast video is not a new one, and has long gone on in courtrooms, at concerts and sporting events, and in other controlled or restricted situations where multiple cameras might create havoc. It’s also similar to in-house broadcast network feeds, which have existed for decades.
“Production sharing is going to become increasingly common,” said Richard Hanley, assistant professor of journalism at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Conn. “It happened with newspapers, who forged joint operating agreements and shared printing facilities. So this is not unusual for media companies to share production costs, and television news is no different. It’s a reality of the moment and the future. As long as there are still separate reporters, I don’t think it’s a fatal issue to media.”
Philadelphia was the first market to begin the LNS venture in January 2009, after an agreement was announced between Fox and NBC Local Media for WCAU-NBC 10 and WTXF-FOX 29 to share video, following a trial run between the two news departments that began the previous summer.
While individually retaining all other aspects of their news-gathering operations, the stations went to work gathering and distributing general market video coverage through a separate LNS entity staffed with 19 experienced assignment editors, photographers and management. Meanwhile, each station pursued the goal of using its own resources to focus on other specialized reporting.
The arrangement has evolved from pooling video obtained at basic bread-and-butter daily news events like press conferences, speeches and court hearings.
“It really has exceeded our expectations in terms of coverage,” said Kingsley Smith, VP and news director of WTXF-TV. “We have 6½ hours of news on every day. The LNS shoots 25 to 45 stories a day and plays a big part in helping with coverage we have not been able to get. It is a content provider that picks up a lot of community stuff and good local flavor. It’s evolved to where the LNS has enterprised its own stories and pitched them to the stations.”
Yet even as costs have gone down—although no one is yet specifying how much—and story count has gone up (an estimated 20 percent at some stations), media watchdogs have questioned how such arrangements affect coverage and impact the viewing audience’s favorable feelings for local stations.
Jill Geisler, faculty member at the Poynter Institute, is concerned about what she called the hazards of pooling, including diluted coverage, missing contacts and stories in the halls of power, the potential proliferation of staged events, the fact that pooling may save money but not jobs—and that non-pool players may escape all these hazards. In a June article for PoynterOnline, she called on news directors to exercise leadership and evaluate these risks to prove that pool coverage can make sense economically and journalistically.
While news-pooling arrangements are fast becoming standard operating procedure, many local news leaders—including ABC O&Os in Los Angeles, New York and Chicago—are choosing not to participate. News executives at some of those stations have said that going it alone makes them stronger and more unique in the marketplace. Behind the scenes they have been concerned that jumping into the pool would prop up their weakest competitors.
After a six-week trial run in the news pool, Meredith Corp.’s Atlanta station, WGCL-TV, recently took its toes out of the water it had shared with Fox O&O WAGA-TV and Gannett’s WXIA-TV, saying the pool limited its ability to cover different stories. Yet Meredith said it remains committed to the concept—its Phoenix station is on board—and Fox executives are circumspect about the pullout.
“With anything new you have to give it time and become comfortable with the concept and expectations,” said Berg. “You have to be committed to make it work. If you believe in the concept it will work. It depends on the market; each market is different. Some LNSes cover more breaking news, some cover a broader output of community events. We look at what types of news they’re covering every week, making sure all stations are getting what they need.”
Yet perhaps the biggest concern of all among working broadcast journalists is job loss.
“Each station pays for two individuals, and they get four for free,” said a 20-year veteran photographer at one of the three Los Angeles stations participating in LNS, who did not wish to be identified. “It’s a terrible idea. Eventually they’re going to cry wolf, say they have no money and expand the idea—and more people will be laid off. Are writers next? It has really lousy prospects, in my opinion.”
He said he is not only concerned about losing the work, but losing the competitive edge that his station prides itself upon. “You want coverage, yet you’re not willing to pay for it? You want to compete? Hire extra reporters. It’s work that belongs to us, and they’re basically getting it for nothing,” the photographer said.
“If it was about slashing jobs, how would we still cover news and keep the industry thriving?” Berg said. “Yes, sharing a chopper can save half a million dollars, helping make the best use of our resources. LNS is an important component in that.”
At Tribune’s stations, Charlier said the LNS has not contributed to any cutbacks that have been made, and that some of the stations have added news hours, and hope to add more. “We haven’t made a direct layoff as a result of LNS,” he said.
“How we’re using this strategy is that it provides us a window to grow in a tough economy,” Charlier said. “It’s to make us smarter operators and have more content. Not only is the economy tough, people have short attention spans, and we work hard to earn their attention. As always, content is king. This is how we branch out, focusing on the rest of the material in the day’s newscasts.”
TV Week
New. Experimental. Here to Stay?
That would be the tease for the rapidly spreading practice of fiercely competitive television stations joining to pool their resources as a way to reduce costs and expand coverage.
The pooling of broadcast news video, also known as local news sharing (LNS), is a concept that has caught fire in recent months—but not without controversy—and is under way in several dozen markets, including all five of the nation’s largest DMAs.
“In these challenging economic times, we began discussions on how to be more efficient,” said Sharri Berg, senior VP of news operations for Fox Television Stations, which has 12 of its stations participating with local competitors in news-pooling arrangements. “The result was not only cost efficiency, but this gave us flexibility in directing our own unilateral resources. If we’re covering a local news conference, if a station wants to send a reporter, it’s their choice. LNS in no way constrains or dictates, but in fact gives stations more options.”
Many major station groups are taking part, including stations affiliated with and/or owned by the NBC Television Network, Tribune Broadcasting, Gannett Broadcasting, CBS Broadcasting, Scripps Television Station Group, McGraw-Hill Broadcasting and Sinclair Broadcast Group.
The practice is not without critics, however, who argue that it decreases competition, costs jobs, blurs the individuality of stations and limits the ability to cover stories.
There’s no question about the financial benefits, however. “We’ve got to be smarter businessmen,” said Steve Charlier, senior VP of news and operations at Tribune Broadcasting stations. “Our goal was to operate efficiently and improve content, and be able to grow, to put more bodies in the street, and have more content.”
The practice of pooling broadcast video is not a new one, and has long gone on in courtrooms, at concerts and sporting events, and in other controlled or restricted situations where multiple cameras might create havoc. It’s also similar to in-house broadcast network feeds, which have existed for decades.
“Production sharing is going to become increasingly common,” said Richard Hanley, assistant professor of journalism at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Conn. “It happened with newspapers, who forged joint operating agreements and shared printing facilities. So this is not unusual for media companies to share production costs, and television news is no different. It’s a reality of the moment and the future. As long as there are still separate reporters, I don’t think it’s a fatal issue to media.”
Philadelphia was the first market to begin the LNS venture in January 2009, after an agreement was announced between Fox and NBC Local Media for WCAU-NBC 10 and WTXF-FOX 29 to share video, following a trial run between the two news departments that began the previous summer.
While individually retaining all other aspects of their news-gathering operations, the stations went to work gathering and distributing general market video coverage through a separate LNS entity staffed with 19 experienced assignment editors, photographers and management. Meanwhile, each station pursued the goal of using its own resources to focus on other specialized reporting.
The arrangement has evolved from pooling video obtained at basic bread-and-butter daily news events like press conferences, speeches and court hearings.
“It really has exceeded our expectations in terms of coverage,” said Kingsley Smith, VP and news director of WTXF-TV. “We have 6½ hours of news on every day. The LNS shoots 25 to 45 stories a day and plays a big part in helping with coverage we have not been able to get. It is a content provider that picks up a lot of community stuff and good local flavor. It’s evolved to where the LNS has enterprised its own stories and pitched them to the stations.”
Yet even as costs have gone down—although no one is yet specifying how much—and story count has gone up (an estimated 20 percent at some stations), media watchdogs have questioned how such arrangements affect coverage and impact the viewing audience’s favorable feelings for local stations.
Jill Geisler, faculty member at the Poynter Institute, is concerned about what she called the hazards of pooling, including diluted coverage, missing contacts and stories in the halls of power, the potential proliferation of staged events, the fact that pooling may save money but not jobs—and that non-pool players may escape all these hazards. In a June article for PoynterOnline, she called on news directors to exercise leadership and evaluate these risks to prove that pool coverage can make sense economically and journalistically.
While news-pooling arrangements are fast becoming standard operating procedure, many local news leaders—including ABC O&Os in Los Angeles, New York and Chicago—are choosing not to participate. News executives at some of those stations have said that going it alone makes them stronger and more unique in the marketplace. Behind the scenes they have been concerned that jumping into the pool would prop up their weakest competitors.
After a six-week trial run in the news pool, Meredith Corp.’s Atlanta station, WGCL-TV, recently took its toes out of the water it had shared with Fox O&O WAGA-TV and Gannett’s WXIA-TV, saying the pool limited its ability to cover different stories. Yet Meredith said it remains committed to the concept—its Phoenix station is on board—and Fox executives are circumspect about the pullout.
“With anything new you have to give it time and become comfortable with the concept and expectations,” said Berg. “You have to be committed to make it work. If you believe in the concept it will work. It depends on the market; each market is different. Some LNSes cover more breaking news, some cover a broader output of community events. We look at what types of news they’re covering every week, making sure all stations are getting what they need.”
Yet perhaps the biggest concern of all among working broadcast journalists is job loss.
“Each station pays for two individuals, and they get four for free,” said a 20-year veteran photographer at one of the three Los Angeles stations participating in LNS, who did not wish to be identified. “It’s a terrible idea. Eventually they’re going to cry wolf, say they have no money and expand the idea—and more people will be laid off. Are writers next? It has really lousy prospects, in my opinion.”
He said he is not only concerned about losing the work, but losing the competitive edge that his station prides itself upon. “You want coverage, yet you’re not willing to pay for it? You want to compete? Hire extra reporters. It’s work that belongs to us, and they’re basically getting it for nothing,” the photographer said.
“If it was about slashing jobs, how would we still cover news and keep the industry thriving?” Berg said. “Yes, sharing a chopper can save half a million dollars, helping make the best use of our resources. LNS is an important component in that.”
At Tribune’s stations, Charlier said the LNS has not contributed to any cutbacks that have been made, and that some of the stations have added news hours, and hope to add more. “We haven’t made a direct layoff as a result of LNS,” he said.
“How we’re using this strategy is that it provides us a window to grow in a tough economy,” Charlier said. “It’s to make us smarter operators and have more content. Not only is the economy tough, people have short attention spans, and we work hard to earn their attention. As always, content is king. This is how we branch out, focusing on the rest of the material in the day’s newscasts.”
Monday, August 3, 2009
IATSE is Twenty-first International Union to Endorse HR 676
Orlando, Florida. The 66th Quadrennial Convention of IATSE, the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees became the twenty-first international union to endorse HR 676, national single payer healthcare legislation introduced by Congressman John Conyers (D-MI).
On July 29, 2009, over 800 delegates, representing more than 100,000 members nationwide, voted unanimously to endorse H.R. 676. Since a campaign to endorse HR 676 began within IATSE last January, over seventy-five individual IATSE locals have endorsed HR 676.
International President Matthew D. Loeb stated from the podium after the vote that HR 676 is the "right thing to do."
Robert Score, Recording Corresponding Secretary of IATSE Local One in New York City, led the six month campaign.
HR 676 would institute a single payer health care system by expanding a greatly improved Medicare system to everyone residing in the U. S.
HR 676 would cover every person for all necessary medical care including prescription drugs, hospital, surgical, outpatient services, primary and preventive care, emergency services, dental, mental health, home health, physical therapy, rehabilitation (including for substance abuse), vision care, hearing services including hearing aids, chiropractic, durable medical equipment, palliative care, and long term care.
HR 676 ends deductibles and co-payments. HR 676 would save hundreds of billions annually by eliminating the high overhead and profits of the private health insurance industry and HMOs.
In the current Congress, HR 676 has 85 co-sponsors in addition to Conyers.Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders has introduced SB 703, a single payer bill in the Senate.
HR 676 has been endorsed by 555 union organizations in 49 states including 130 Central Labor Councils and Area Labor Federations and 39 state AFL-CIO's (KY, PA, CT, OH, DE, ND, WA, SC, WY, VT, FL, WI, WV, SD, NC, MO, MN, ME, AR, MD-DC, TX, IA, AZ, TN, OR, GA, OK, KS, CO, IN, AL, CA, AK, MI, MT, NE, NY, NV & MA).
For further information, a list of union endorsers, or a sample endorsement resolution, contact:
Kay Tillow
All Unions Committee For Single Payer Health Care--HR 676
c/o Nurses Professional Organization (NPO)
1169 Eastern Parkway, Suite 2218
Louisville, KY 40217
(502) 636 1551Email: nursenpo@aol.comhttp://unionsforsinglepayerHR676.org
On July 29, 2009, over 800 delegates, representing more than 100,000 members nationwide, voted unanimously to endorse H.R. 676. Since a campaign to endorse HR 676 began within IATSE last January, over seventy-five individual IATSE locals have endorsed HR 676.
International President Matthew D. Loeb stated from the podium after the vote that HR 676 is the "right thing to do."
Robert Score, Recording Corresponding Secretary of IATSE Local One in New York City, led the six month campaign.
HR 676 would institute a single payer health care system by expanding a greatly improved Medicare system to everyone residing in the U. S.
HR 676 would cover every person for all necessary medical care including prescription drugs, hospital, surgical, outpatient services, primary and preventive care, emergency services, dental, mental health, home health, physical therapy, rehabilitation (including for substance abuse), vision care, hearing services including hearing aids, chiropractic, durable medical equipment, palliative care, and long term care.
HR 676 ends deductibles and co-payments. HR 676 would save hundreds of billions annually by eliminating the high overhead and profits of the private health insurance industry and HMOs.
In the current Congress, HR 676 has 85 co-sponsors in addition to Conyers.Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders has introduced SB 703, a single payer bill in the Senate.
HR 676 has been endorsed by 555 union organizations in 49 states including 130 Central Labor Councils and Area Labor Federations and 39 state AFL-CIO's (KY, PA, CT, OH, DE, ND, WA, SC, WY, VT, FL, WI, WV, SD, NC, MO, MN, ME, AR, MD-DC, TX, IA, AZ, TN, OR, GA, OK, KS, CO, IN, AL, CA, AK, MI, MT, NE, NY, NV & MA).
For further information, a list of union endorsers, or a sample endorsement resolution, contact:
Kay Tillow
All Unions Committee For Single Payer Health Care--HR 676
c/o Nurses Professional Organization (NPO)
1169 Eastern Parkway, Suite 2218
Louisville, KY 40217
(502) 636 1551Email: nursenpo@aol.comhttp://unionsforsinglepayerHR676.org
OPEN HOUSE for the Cornell ILR/CUNY Undergraduate Joint Certificate in Labor Relations
You are invited to an OPEN HOUSE for the Cornell ILR/CUNY Undergraduate Joint Certificate in Labor Relations on
Wednesday, August 12th, 6pm
Cornell Conference Center
16 East 34th Street, 6th floor, Room A.
This 16-credit Undergraduate Certificate Program is offered through an educational partnership between two of the nation's leading institutions for the study of labor: Cornell University's School of Industrial and Labor Relations and CUNY's Joseph S. Murphy Institute for Workers Education and Labor Studies.
The program is designed to provide students with an understanding of employment relations, labor law, and unions.
The weekday evening classes begin the first week in September and include:
Collective Bargaining (4 credits)
Labor and Employment Law (4 credits)
Unions and Labor Relations (4 credits)
Work, Culture and Politics in New York City (4 credits)
Labor History (4 credits).
To find out more about the program, please call 212-340-2847 or visit our website: www.ilr.cornell.edu/cmi.
I hope you can join us!
In solidarity,
Pam Whitefield
Cornell ILR/CUNY Murphy Institute Joint Certificate in Labor Relations
http://www.imakenews.com/eletra/go.cfm?z=localone%2C382921%2Cb8vVVKp9%2C3411322%2CbfRGg5V
Wednesday, August 12th, 6pm
Cornell Conference Center
16 East 34th Street, 6th floor, Room A.
This 16-credit Undergraduate Certificate Program is offered through an educational partnership between two of the nation's leading institutions for the study of labor: Cornell University's School of Industrial and Labor Relations and CUNY's Joseph S. Murphy Institute for Workers Education and Labor Studies.
The program is designed to provide students with an understanding of employment relations, labor law, and unions.
The weekday evening classes begin the first week in September and include:
Collective Bargaining (4 credits)
Labor and Employment Law (4 credits)
Unions and Labor Relations (4 credits)
Work, Culture and Politics in New York City (4 credits)
Labor History (4 credits).
To find out more about the program, please call 212-340-2847 or visit our website: www.ilr.cornell.edu/cmi.
I hope you can join us!
In solidarity,
Pam Whitefield
Cornell ILR/CUNY Murphy Institute Joint Certificate in Labor Relations
http://www.imakenews.com/eletra/go.cfm?z=localone%2C382921%2Cb8vVVKp9%2C3411322%2CbfRGg5V
Deal Memos
By Dr. Fred Ginsburg
FILM UNDERGROUND
Hardly a day ever passes that Tom and I are not besieged with phone calls from novices and students wanting to know how to get started in Production Sound, or from professional mixers crying the blues over how they got screwed over on their last gig.
So for the benefit of some of our younger and less combat experienced readers, here are some personal views on how to survive as an up and coming free-lancers.
Note that most of this article is written relating to nonunion shoots. Employment on union shows is not so risky, since there are strict guidelines for the producers to follow, along with the recourse of union intervention if crew members are mistreated.
Deal Memo
Deal Memos are the term that independent producers use for employment contracts. Since the word "contract" implies something legally detailed and binding, the term "memo" is used to suggest an agreement somewhat less formal.
Do not be mislead; a Deal Memo is a contract and is binding.
The problem is that it is usually not worth the effort and legal expense to try and enforce it.
Many of the deal memos that have been handed to me by Producers are nothing more than hastily rewritten Model Releases. Why a Producer would want me to sign away rights to my voice and photographed image I cannot imagine! (Behind the scenes documentaries not withstanding).
But a Deal Memo is the employment agreement that states what you are being hired to do; what you will be paid; terms of employment; and misc. details.
Make sure that the wording is specific and relevant! Do not be afraid to cross out paragraphs left over from the actors' contracts.
Your Employer
The memo should clearly state who the employer is.
If it is a bona fide, long-standing production company—that is okay. But if the name of the production company is the name of the film, expect the production office to shut down forever on the last day of shooting! Get the real name of the producer, including actual address (verify it) and social security number. If the producer refuses his/her real name or address, be wary!
You
The memo should have your name on it, of course.
Your Job
It should detail your job function on the set, such as Production Sound Mixer, Boom Operator, etc. That way you do not end up hauling lumber around.
Salary
How much are you being paid?
For what period of time: hourly, daily, or weekly?
Define that period of time, such as an 8-hour workday, excluding an off-the-clock lunch break of not less than 30 minutes but not more than one hour. Or perhaps a 10 hour workday, or even a 12 hour day.
When will you get paid?
State laws usually require paychecks not more than 7 days after the pay period, but check your local laws. Most crews like to be paid on a weekly basis, beginning not more than 7 days from the first day of work. Do not accept any deal where you won't be paid until the end of a lengthy shoot; that is a sure sign that the producer does not have any funds!
Do not be nice about not getting paid. If you were promised a paycheck on Friday, and that check is not there, then make it very clear that it had better be there by the next morning. Holding back your roll of dailies can help make the point; even if it means accidently turning in a blank roll... oops. And if the check still is not there the following morning, well, time to take evasive action. Leave the set, and make sure to take your equipment with you!
Overtime
Overtime traditionally means at least time and a half for any hours beyond 8 per day, 40 per week, or seventh consecutive workday. In the movie biz, these rules often get bent. Figure in your basic overtime to your rate when you agree to (or define) a long working day, or weekly rate. Your deal memo should state that you expect overtime compensation for all time beyond your basic 8, 10, or 12 hour day; as well as for weeks extending longer than the defined week.
Producers will counter with the statement that no one is getting paid overtime because no day will go overtime! To that, I point out, if we do not go into overtime—then you will not have to pay me overtime. But if you do not agree to pay me overtime when the day goes into overtime, then I will simply pack up and go home at the end of my shift and the rest of the crew can shoot M.O.S. (Of course, I never leave my equipment behind for someone else to use!)
Travel And Expenses
The deal memo should cover areas such as meals (who pays?), travel expenses, gas, tolls, parking.
Travel days should be compensated, at least partially.
Airfare should be prepaid, and round-trip tickets are given to each crew member before departure. Make sure you have a return ticket in your possession, just in case the production falls apart while you are on distant location.
Hotel accommodations are to be of reasonable quality (clean, no bugs) and private room/bath. No dorms or sharing of facilities. You are entitled to your privacy and rest. Rooms should be prepaid or secured with the Producer's credit card; never your own.
Are you an Employee or an Independent Contractor?
Low budget producers will often try to entice you into being an Independent Contractor so that you will not have taxes deducted from your meager paychecks. But the IRS does not consider you to be an Independent Contractor unless you are working independently of the crew, such as an Editor in their own offices. If you work under the direct supervision of the production company, then you are not independent. If you use your own equipment or facilities, determine your own hours, choose your own locations & working conditions—then you may qualify as an Independent Contractor.
Insurance
But the biggest problem that you face as an Independent Contractor is not taxes, but insurance coverage. What happens if you get sick or injured on the set? What if disaster strikes your equipment? Independent Contractors are self-insured. Employees are covered by Workman's Comp and Liability provided by the Producer.
Equipment
Equipment and expendables. Is the producer renting an equipment package from you and paying you weekly for it? Is the equipment totally your own, or is it from a rental house? Whose account is it under, yours or the producers? Who is providing insurance coverage against loss or damage? Is the company purchasing expendables and providing them to you, or are you bringing the expendables and billing the company on an as-used basis?
If you are engaged to act as a middleman in arranging for equipment, make sure that the rental house understands that you are acting on behalf of the producer and not for yourself. They may be willing to entrust their gear to the producer because they trust YOU, but then they will want to hold you RESPONSIBLE. Make it clear that they must be comfortable with the producer's credit app and insurance, and that you are not personally vouching for your client.
By the way, never put up front money or your credit card to cover company bulk purchases. If you have to front for expendables, then they belong to you until the company reimburses you, at a profit!
Term Of Employment
The deal memo should state the start and completion dates of the project. Are you being hired for the duration of the show, weekly, or on a day-to-day hire? How many days prior to the start date does the production company need to notify you in the event of postponement or cancellation? After all, you are turning away other work being offered to you because the producer has booked you! Will you be compensated for delays? What about compensation for prep days, location scouting, and travel days?
Deferred Salary
Read free. Do not seriously expect to be paid any real money after the picture is completed and "sold". You have better odds of winning the lottery!
Whatever compensation you are going to get, you will receive at the end of each shooting week. After that, forget it.
So make sure you that you are willing to settle for whatever is offered to you up front.
But if you feel lucky, and decide to gamble on a Deferred deal, then play it for as much as you can get. Do not defer straight salary; if you have to wait and gamble, then it should be for at least double or triple your normal rate.
Expendables, expenses, and equipment rental are not deferrable!!
Priority of Deferred Payment
Your deal should state that you get paid as quickly as anyone else. Investors who put up cash should not be paid off any sooner than professionals who put up their time and skill. Your services are equal to cash, since the producer would otherwise have to PAY for them.
The few times that I have had to accept a partially deferred deal, I have added a clause stating that all of the soundtracks that I record are my property and copyright until my contract is paid off in full—only at that time will the ownership and rights to the sound recordings revert to the producer.
The producer is prohibited from entering into any agreement with any outside party that constitutes sale or transfer of ownership of the sound recordings until my contract is paid in full. That prevents a producer from legally selling off the film to a distributor, and then claiming that the amount of the sale was insufficient to pay off the deferred debt.
The distributors purchasing the rights to the film always claim that any deferred contracts are between the crew and the producer.
I also record a copyright claim at the head of every tape.
Ownership of the sound recordings serves as mechanic's lien and may give you a little more leverage to insure payment. But don't count on it. Lawyers usually only take your case if really big money is involved.
Most importantly in your deal memo, pay attention to who signs it. An approval by a production assistant is not considered binding by the producer. It must be signed by the producer if deferred payments are involved. The producer or a senior production manager must sign any deal memo. Make sure that the production manager is, in fact, empowered to make the deal.
The issue of deal memos is a complicated one, and this article should not be used in lieu of consulting with an attorney. Many fine line legal issues are involved, and the laws vary widely from state to state.
Be careful in what you sign and what you agree to! Make sure that the deal memo covers not just what the producer expects from you, but what you expect from the producer! The more specific, the better. If you are not using the services of a lawyer, then write everything out in plain, common day English. A judge is more likely to rule in your favor if the intent of the agreement is clear, even if it is not in legalese. When your agreement starts sounding like it was written by a lawyer, then legal loopholes are more likely to be applied.
Get A Copy
Always get a signed copy of the agreement, including initialed pages and initialed cross-outs. Better yet, ask to take an unsigned copy of the deal memo home for a couple of days to look over. Explain that you never sign any contract without consulting with your lawyer. Even if you do not have a lawyer, that will give you a chance to show the agreement to a couple of seasoned professionals who might spot something fishy or badly misworded.
Dr. Fred Ginsburg, CAS has over 15 years experience as a Production Mixer for film and video. He is president of the Equipment Emporium, a supplier of professional audio & video equipment as well as seminars & training.
http://www.cyberfilmschool.com/magazine/
FILM UNDERGROUND
Hardly a day ever passes that Tom and I are not besieged with phone calls from novices and students wanting to know how to get started in Production Sound, or from professional mixers crying the blues over how they got screwed over on their last gig.
So for the benefit of some of our younger and less combat experienced readers, here are some personal views on how to survive as an up and coming free-lancers.
Note that most of this article is written relating to nonunion shoots. Employment on union shows is not so risky, since there are strict guidelines for the producers to follow, along with the recourse of union intervention if crew members are mistreated.
Deal Memo
Deal Memos are the term that independent producers use for employment contracts. Since the word "contract" implies something legally detailed and binding, the term "memo" is used to suggest an agreement somewhat less formal.
Do not be mislead; a Deal Memo is a contract and is binding.
The problem is that it is usually not worth the effort and legal expense to try and enforce it.
Many of the deal memos that have been handed to me by Producers are nothing more than hastily rewritten Model Releases. Why a Producer would want me to sign away rights to my voice and photographed image I cannot imagine! (Behind the scenes documentaries not withstanding).
But a Deal Memo is the employment agreement that states what you are being hired to do; what you will be paid; terms of employment; and misc. details.
Make sure that the wording is specific and relevant! Do not be afraid to cross out paragraphs left over from the actors' contracts.
Your Employer
The memo should clearly state who the employer is.
If it is a bona fide, long-standing production company—that is okay. But if the name of the production company is the name of the film, expect the production office to shut down forever on the last day of shooting! Get the real name of the producer, including actual address (verify it) and social security number. If the producer refuses his/her real name or address, be wary!
You
The memo should have your name on it, of course.
Your Job
It should detail your job function on the set, such as Production Sound Mixer, Boom Operator, etc. That way you do not end up hauling lumber around.
Salary
How much are you being paid?
For what period of time: hourly, daily, or weekly?
Define that period of time, such as an 8-hour workday, excluding an off-the-clock lunch break of not less than 30 minutes but not more than one hour. Or perhaps a 10 hour workday, or even a 12 hour day.
When will you get paid?
State laws usually require paychecks not more than 7 days after the pay period, but check your local laws. Most crews like to be paid on a weekly basis, beginning not more than 7 days from the first day of work. Do not accept any deal where you won't be paid until the end of a lengthy shoot; that is a sure sign that the producer does not have any funds!
Do not be nice about not getting paid. If you were promised a paycheck on Friday, and that check is not there, then make it very clear that it had better be there by the next morning. Holding back your roll of dailies can help make the point; even if it means accidently turning in a blank roll... oops. And if the check still is not there the following morning, well, time to take evasive action. Leave the set, and make sure to take your equipment with you!
Overtime
Overtime traditionally means at least time and a half for any hours beyond 8 per day, 40 per week, or seventh consecutive workday. In the movie biz, these rules often get bent. Figure in your basic overtime to your rate when you agree to (or define) a long working day, or weekly rate. Your deal memo should state that you expect overtime compensation for all time beyond your basic 8, 10, or 12 hour day; as well as for weeks extending longer than the defined week.
Producers will counter with the statement that no one is getting paid overtime because no day will go overtime! To that, I point out, if we do not go into overtime—then you will not have to pay me overtime. But if you do not agree to pay me overtime when the day goes into overtime, then I will simply pack up and go home at the end of my shift and the rest of the crew can shoot M.O.S. (Of course, I never leave my equipment behind for someone else to use!)
Travel And Expenses
The deal memo should cover areas such as meals (who pays?), travel expenses, gas, tolls, parking.
Travel days should be compensated, at least partially.
Airfare should be prepaid, and round-trip tickets are given to each crew member before departure. Make sure you have a return ticket in your possession, just in case the production falls apart while you are on distant location.
Hotel accommodations are to be of reasonable quality (clean, no bugs) and private room/bath. No dorms or sharing of facilities. You are entitled to your privacy and rest. Rooms should be prepaid or secured with the Producer's credit card; never your own.
Are you an Employee or an Independent Contractor?
Low budget producers will often try to entice you into being an Independent Contractor so that you will not have taxes deducted from your meager paychecks. But the IRS does not consider you to be an Independent Contractor unless you are working independently of the crew, such as an Editor in their own offices. If you work under the direct supervision of the production company, then you are not independent. If you use your own equipment or facilities, determine your own hours, choose your own locations & working conditions—then you may qualify as an Independent Contractor.
Insurance
But the biggest problem that you face as an Independent Contractor is not taxes, but insurance coverage. What happens if you get sick or injured on the set? What if disaster strikes your equipment? Independent Contractors are self-insured. Employees are covered by Workman's Comp and Liability provided by the Producer.
Equipment
Equipment and expendables. Is the producer renting an equipment package from you and paying you weekly for it? Is the equipment totally your own, or is it from a rental house? Whose account is it under, yours or the producers? Who is providing insurance coverage against loss or damage? Is the company purchasing expendables and providing them to you, or are you bringing the expendables and billing the company on an as-used basis?
If you are engaged to act as a middleman in arranging for equipment, make sure that the rental house understands that you are acting on behalf of the producer and not for yourself. They may be willing to entrust their gear to the producer because they trust YOU, but then they will want to hold you RESPONSIBLE. Make it clear that they must be comfortable with the producer's credit app and insurance, and that you are not personally vouching for your client.
By the way, never put up front money or your credit card to cover company bulk purchases. If you have to front for expendables, then they belong to you until the company reimburses you, at a profit!
Term Of Employment
The deal memo should state the start and completion dates of the project. Are you being hired for the duration of the show, weekly, or on a day-to-day hire? How many days prior to the start date does the production company need to notify you in the event of postponement or cancellation? After all, you are turning away other work being offered to you because the producer has booked you! Will you be compensated for delays? What about compensation for prep days, location scouting, and travel days?
Deferred Salary
Read free. Do not seriously expect to be paid any real money after the picture is completed and "sold". You have better odds of winning the lottery!
Whatever compensation you are going to get, you will receive at the end of each shooting week. After that, forget it.
So make sure you that you are willing to settle for whatever is offered to you up front.
But if you feel lucky, and decide to gamble on a Deferred deal, then play it for as much as you can get. Do not defer straight salary; if you have to wait and gamble, then it should be for at least double or triple your normal rate.
Expendables, expenses, and equipment rental are not deferrable!!
Priority of Deferred Payment
Your deal should state that you get paid as quickly as anyone else. Investors who put up cash should not be paid off any sooner than professionals who put up their time and skill. Your services are equal to cash, since the producer would otherwise have to PAY for them.
The few times that I have had to accept a partially deferred deal, I have added a clause stating that all of the soundtracks that I record are my property and copyright until my contract is paid off in full—only at that time will the ownership and rights to the sound recordings revert to the producer.
The producer is prohibited from entering into any agreement with any outside party that constitutes sale or transfer of ownership of the sound recordings until my contract is paid in full. That prevents a producer from legally selling off the film to a distributor, and then claiming that the amount of the sale was insufficient to pay off the deferred debt.
The distributors purchasing the rights to the film always claim that any deferred contracts are between the crew and the producer.
I also record a copyright claim at the head of every tape.
Ownership of the sound recordings serves as mechanic's lien and may give you a little more leverage to insure payment. But don't count on it. Lawyers usually only take your case if really big money is involved.
Most importantly in your deal memo, pay attention to who signs it. An approval by a production assistant is not considered binding by the producer. It must be signed by the producer if deferred payments are involved. The producer or a senior production manager must sign any deal memo. Make sure that the production manager is, in fact, empowered to make the deal.
The issue of deal memos is a complicated one, and this article should not be used in lieu of consulting with an attorney. Many fine line legal issues are involved, and the laws vary widely from state to state.
Be careful in what you sign and what you agree to! Make sure that the deal memo covers not just what the producer expects from you, but what you expect from the producer! The more specific, the better. If you are not using the services of a lawyer, then write everything out in plain, common day English. A judge is more likely to rule in your favor if the intent of the agreement is clear, even if it is not in legalese. When your agreement starts sounding like it was written by a lawyer, then legal loopholes are more likely to be applied.
Get A Copy
Always get a signed copy of the agreement, including initialed pages and initialed cross-outs. Better yet, ask to take an unsigned copy of the deal memo home for a couple of days to look over. Explain that you never sign any contract without consulting with your lawyer. Even if you do not have a lawyer, that will give you a chance to show the agreement to a couple of seasoned professionals who might spot something fishy or badly misworded.
Dr. Fred Ginsburg, CAS has over 15 years experience as a Production Mixer for film and video. He is president of the Equipment Emporium, a supplier of professional audio & video equipment as well as seminars & training.
http://www.cyberfilmschool.com/magazine/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)